Loading...
190321 BIA AGDTillsonburg Business Improvement Area Board Meeting – Agenda - Thursday, March 21st, 2019 7:00 am breakfast, 7:30 am meeting – Carriage Hall – 25 Brock Street West, Tillsonburg 1.CALL TO ORDER: Determine if a quorum is present. Time: __________ 2.ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA: a.moved by:___________________ seconded by: __________________ 3.ADOPTION OF THE MINUTES from the meeting of February 21st, 2019 (Attached) a.moved by:___________________ seconded by: __________________ 4.TREASURER’S REPORT – D. Rasokas a.February 2019 First Ontario bank statements (Attached) b.Funds as of February 28th, 2019: $202,158.96 c.February financials (Attached) 5.DELEGATIONS: i.None. 6.COMMITTEE REPORTS: a.Beautification: i.Report OP-ED-03-19-2019 (Attached) RESOLUTION: That the BIA Board of Management approves the 2019 Beautification plan with an upset limit of $40,000 be approved and funded within the existing total financial envelope of the 2019 BIA budget. Moved by: _______________________ Seconded by: ___________________________ 1 ii.ED attended the Horticultural Society meeting of March 5th: 1)Presentation to the group was made by a Beekeeper from Arva, ON on the need to plant bee-friendly landscape specimens 2)BIA is now a member of THS and has a seat at the table (Cost $15) iii.ED met with Chris Tucker of Classic Displays: 1)E-mail memo (Attached) 2)There is a March 31st, 2019 deadline for 25% discount b.Communications: i.Report from Events and Marketing Co-ordinator c.Promotions: i.There was committee meeting held at Boston Pizza on Thursday, March 14th, 2019. The committee will be adding at least one more event to the calendar. There was a general discussion about investing in beautification prior to a marketing push. ii.Proposed draft calendar for 2019 (Attached) 7.EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR’S REPORT: a.Report on Downtown Tillsonburg Gap Analysis (Attached) The ED met with the Development Commissioner on March 13th, 2019 to review and discuss the next steps on the report. The ED recommends to the Board that the report be adopted and that the recommendations (next steps) be added to the staff work-plan for implementation in 2019 and beyond. 2 Motion: “Moved by___________________ and Seconded by _______________________ and resolved that the BIA Board of Management adopts the Downtown Tillsonburg Gap Analysis report and further that the ED and EMC report back to the board on an implementation plan for next steps during the balance of 2019; and add 2-3 additional strategic imperatives to the 2020 work plan”. b.ED attended the Turtlefest meeting of March 8th at the Tillsonburg Town Centre. c.ED met with the Promotions Team from Rogers Radio on March 8th. d.ED met with David Calder and Senior Staff to follow-up on outstanding issues and concerns - all with positive results. e.Verbal update on work plan. f.Meetings and events attended: i.Mayor’s Breakfast March 19 ii.Merchant meetings – various throughout the BIA zone iii.Meeting with CIBC regarding corporate credit card iv.Meeting with Promotions Committee March 14th. v.Met with supplier/vendors March 15th on outdoor beautification purchases for 2019. 8.OTHER BUSINESS: a.WiFi: work plan to get this back up and running is underway. K. Deleebeeck will be working with us and ERTH (contractor) to expedite the reintroduction of WiFi. b.Correspondence: from Hurley’s Mattress and Appliance (Attached) 3 9.NEW BUSINESS: MOTION TO MOVE INTO CLOSED SESSION TO DISCUSS ACQUISITION OR DISPOSAL OF LAND. ED REPORT CL-ED -03-19-2019-A. moved by:___________________ seconded by: __________________ MOTION TO MOVE BACK INTO OPEN SESSION: Moved by: ______________________ Seconded by: _______________________ 10. ROUNDTABLE: 11. NEXT MEETING – Thursday, April 25th, 2019 at Carriage Hall – 7:00 am breakfast, 7:30 am meeting 12. MOTION TO ADJOURN : a.moved by:___________________ seconded by: __________________ 4 Tillsonburg Business Improvement Area Board Meeting – Minutes for Thursday, February 21st, 2019 7:30 am – Carriage Hall – 25 Brock Street West, Tillsonburg 1.CALL TO ORDER a.The meeting was called to order at 7:32 am by the Board Chair In attendance: C. Tomico, D. Gilvesy, C. Pepper, M. Rosehart, D. Rasokas, M. Tedesco, M. Renaud, K. Slattery, C. Pepper Regrets: W. Cameron, J. Scott 2.ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA – Moved by GILVESY, Seconded by RASOKAS – “Carried” 3.ADOPTION OF THE MINUTES – Minutes from the meeting of December 18th, 2018; Moved by RASOKAS, Seconded by GILVESY – “Carried” 4.TREASURER’S REPORT: There was a brief presentation by D. Rasokas highlighting the finances for the month of January. There were no funds received from the town for any BIA related income. The only major expense in January was the ED contract pay statement. The Treasurer indicated that there were still excess funds in the chequing account that are not earning interest. The Treasurer then suggested that excess funds should be moved into the savings account. To this end, the following resolution was put onto the floor: Motion: That all but $50,000 of our cash be moved to a High Interest Savings account at First Ontario Credit Union until the funds are needed. Moved by: Rasokas, Seconded by Rosehart – “carried” 5.Judi Misener of the Tillsonburg Horticultural Society delivered a presentation to the Board on the 2019 four-season urn program. There were no questions posed or concerns raised. 1 6.Executive Director’s report: a.The ED gave a verbal report on the Downtown London BIA governance issues and member discontentment. b.The ED reviewed the importance of following the Municipal Act with respect to the BIA meeting protocols. The ED distributed the Ontario Ombudsman investigative report to the Owen Sound BIA dated October 2nd, 2018. c.The ED attended meetings with Turtlefest, MOU with Town, FIP committee meeting with the Town, meetings with several BIA members, two meetings with First Ontario Credit Union and meetings with the CEO of the Chamber of Commerce. d.The ED has published updated full-year meeting calendars for each of the full board and the promotions sub-committee. e.The ED met with the principles of 21, 25, 27 Brock Street concerning the newly created darkness created by the removal of the three light heads on Brock Street East. The ED also spoke with the Manager of Long & McQuade, KTN Taxi and Carriage Hall regarding this concern. A resolution was put on the floor as follows: Motion: And resolved that the BIA Board of Management asks the Town of Tillsonburg to place a moratorium on the removal of the 6 light poles on Brock Street East and West pending a review and engagement with the concerned parties and further that an action plan is put into place to address said concerns. Moved by: TEDESCO, Seconded by: ROSEHART – “CARRIED” 7.Committee Reports: a.Beautifications: The ED did cover off that there were conversations held between the Tillsonburg Horticultural Society and the BIA. The ED had also undertaken preliminary design work on new banners for the south vista entrance to the BIA zone from Tillson Avenue/Simcoe Street intersection. The ED distributed the proposed “Rear Façade Checklist” as requested by the CBO, Town of Tillsonburg. Board members are to review 2 and send comment to the ED who will in turn summarize and e-mail the town’s CBO. The ED led a discussion about the proposed drawing of 21, 25, 27 Brock Street East façade drawing. b. Communications: K. Slattery presented a report on her digital marketing progress including a demonstration of the current state of all social media sites. The EMC noted increases in visits to all digital platforms. c. Promotions: The committee provided a copy of the full-year promotional calendar with proposed activities and dates. Some of the information regarding specifics of dates, times and activities is to follow. The ED spoke about the marquee events beyond Turtlefest in 2019 to include an all-day block party on Canada Day in conjunction with The Station Arts Centre, the Christmas Crawl/Holi-Dazzle in early December and the New Year’s Eve Block Party event on December 31st, 2019. The ED suggested that board members can provide feedback on the promotional calendar by e-mail. The ED also spoke about having BIA B2B social events for people to get to know each other. 8. OTHER BUSINESS: a. The ED discussed efforts to “fix” the currently inoperative downtown WiFi system. b. The ED presented the board with a verbal report about the sidewalk sinking at 21 Brock Street East – the follow-up is for the ED to write a letter of support to the town regarding the property-owner’s concerns. 9. NEW BUSINESS: a. C. Pepper raised a point about a follow-up to the 2019 Turtlefest event and the request from the Turtlefest committee regarding an increase in funding from the BIA. After a group discussion, it was decided to defer this request to the Promotions Committee that any funding to be provided to Turtlefest is to come from the promotions budget . The board also discussed the additional supports to the Turtlefest committee as well as more clearly defining the EMC’s role. The ED will attend the full Turtlefest committee meetings effective immediately. The next Turtlefest Board Meeting is March 8th at the Tillsonburg Town Centre. The board also clarified that the role of the EMC will be to 3 exclusively work on the Block Party portion of Turtlefest – the ED, EMC and C. Pepper will meet to discuss further. b. There was a suggestion made about painting “no bicycle” markings on the sidewalks in the downtown core to prevent cyclist/pedestrian collisions. The ED will contact the town for next steps. The ED will meet with the Chair of the Tillsonburg Police Services Board as a follow-up to smoking issues in front of the TTC, bicycle markings on sidewalks and the proposed parking changes to Broadway. ROUNDTABLE: There were no roundtable points made. 10. NEXT MEETING – March 21st, 2019 – Carriage Hall, 7:00 am breakfast, 7:30 am meeting 11. MOTION TO ADJOURN – 9:43 AM – M. ROSEHART 4 February 2019 February 2018 INCOME REVENUE 4100 Taxes - regular 7,495.92 4110 Taxes - other 4120 Taxes - write-off 4150 - AGM 287.62 4250 - Christmas Crawl 800.00 4450 Interest Income 6.17 5.90 Total REVENUE $ 293.79 $ 8,301.82 Total Income $ 293.79 $ 8,301.82 GROSS PROFIT $ 293.79 $ 8,301.82 EXPENSES 8000 SPECIAL PROJECTS 8100 Electronic Bulletin Board - Maintenance 81.00 Total 8000 SPECIAL PROJECTS $ 0.00 $ 81.00 BEAUTIFICATIONS 5550 Keep Downtown Beautiful 5750 FIP 9,000.00 Total BEAUTIFICATIONS $ 9,000.00 $ 0.00 MARKETING/PROMOTION 6050 BIA Business Directory 100.00 6100 Office/Meeting exp 27.18 6200 General Advertising 88.88 6300 Christmas Crawl Promotions 168.00 Total MARKETING/PROMOTION $ 384.06 $ 0.00 OPERATIONS 7000 Bank Service Charges 25.00 25.00 7100 Mileage 7011 AGM Meals, hall rental 320.81 7150 Executive Director 3,910.23 6,088.32 7210 Bookkeeping 120.00 120.00 7450 Office Expense 314.22 26.99 7460 Telephone Expense 0.00 77.17 Total OPERATIONS $ 4,690.26 $ 6,337.48 Total Expenses $ 14,074.32 $ 6,418.48 PROFIT -$ 13,780.53 $ 1,883.34 Total Tillsonburg BIA Profit and Loss Feb-19 Actual YTD 2019 Budget Budget Remaining Income 4000 Donations - GRK 2,000.00 2,000.00 4440 Transfer from Reserves 11,064.00 11,064.00 REVENUE 0.00 4100 Taxes - regular 136,621.00 136,621.00 4150 AGM 287.62 200.00 -87.62 4200 Donations - Sobeys 2,500.00 2,500.00 4350 HST Rebate 15,000.00 15,000.00 4450 Interest Income 12.71 360.00 347.29 4460 Interest from Surplus 1,260.00 1,260.00 4470 Interest from Tax Adjustment Continguency 600.00 600.00 Total 4450 Interest Income $ 12.71 $ 2,220.00 $ 2,207.29 4750 Urban Design - FIP Program 25,000.00 25,000.00 Total REVENUE $ 300.33 $ 181,541.00 $ 181,240.67 Total Income $ 300.33 $ 194,605.00 $ 194,304.67 Gross Profit $ 300.33 $ 194,605.00 $ 194,304.67 Expenses 8000 SPECIAL PROJECTS 0.00 8100 Electronic Bulletin Board - Maintenance 69.95 500.00 430.05 Total 8000 SPECIAL PROJECTS $ 69.95 $ 500.00 $ 430.05 BEAUTIFICATIONS 0.00 5000 Christmas Lights & Decorations 750.00 750.00 5100 Trees 2,000.00 2,000.00 5150 Hanging Baskets Watering 5,000.00 5,000.00 5200 Benches - Repairs & Maintainanc 5,500.00 5,500.00 5300 EBB Restoration 10,000.00 10,000.00 5550 Keep Downtown Beautiful 1,500.00 1,500.00 5750 FIP 9,000.00 50,000.00 41,000.00 Total BEAUTIFICATIONS $ 9,000.00 $ 74,750.00 $ 65,750.00 MARKETING/PROMOTION 0.00 6050 BIA Business Directory 100.00 -100.00 6100 Office/Meeting exp/Sundry/Phone 27.18 -27.18 6200 General Advertising 114.88 5,000.00 4,885.12 6300 Christmas Promotions/Crawl 168.00 4,000.00 3,832.00 6350 Seasonal Promotions 5,000.00 5,000.00 6500 Santa Claus Parade 1,250.00 1,250.00 6600 Block Party Turtlefest 3,000.00 3,000.00 Total MARKETING/PROMOTION $ 410.06 $ 18,250.00 $ 17,839.94 Total 2019 Tillsonburg BIA Budget vs. Actuals: 2019 Budget Feb-19 February 2019 Budget vs Actuals 1 Actual YTD 2019 Budget Budget Remaining OPERATIONS 0.00 7000 Bank Service Charges 50.00 250.00 200.00 7011 AGM Meals, hall rental 320.81 -320.81 7050 Debt Interest 3,677.00 3,677.00 7100 Mileage 250.00 250.00 7150 Executive Director 7,243.56 40,000.00 32,756.44 7160 Additional Contract Work 10,000.00 10,000.00 7200 Accounting - Professional Fees 4,520.00 4,520.00 7210 Bookkeeping 240.00 1,440.00 1,200.00 7300 Debt Principal 11,500.00 11,500.00 7350 HST Expense 20,000.00 20,000.00 7450 Office Expense 314.22 2,000.00 1,685.78 7460 Telephone Expense 500.00 500.00 7550 Professional Development 1,000.00 1,000.00 7600 Quickbooks Software 240.00 240.00 7650 Rent 3,600.00 3,600.00 7800 Repayment of Tax Adjustment 2,000.00 2,000.00 Total OPERATIONS $ 8,168.59 $ 100,977.00 $ 92,808.41 Total Expenses $ 17,648.60 $ 194,477.00 $ 176,828.40 Net Income -$ 17,348.27 $ 21.30 $ 17,369.57 February 2019 Budget vs Actuals 2 Report - OP-ED-03-19-2019-A To: BIA Board of Management From: Mark Renaud, Executive Director Date: March 19th, 2019 Subject: 2019 Beautification plan and funding One of the primary strategic imperatives of any BIA is the beautification of the public areas of the defined BIA zone. To this end, I wish to present the 2019 full- year beautification plan for consideration by the Board of Management. There are some important deadlines with respect to purchasing lead times and discounts available which expire March 31st, 2019. The vast majority of investment will be made for spring/summer/early fall beautification elements consisting of significant purchases of public realm elements including new banners, furniture, plant materials, smoking control, and market umbrellas. Discussion: Historically, the BIA has mainly focused on the Broadway corridor from Venison Street to Oxford Street. We need to address the gaps that exist on the other primary side streets too as these areas do not have waste receptacles, smoking control, potted plants, trees or other decorative elements. There are existing areas that are overgrown and are causing site line and safety issues. On March 15th, the ED met with the Senior Property Manager of the Tillsonburg Town Centre Mall with respect to areas of focus, improvement and concern. To this end, Strathallen Group is onside with every one of our initiatives to clean up, beautify, maintain and enhance the properties and perimeter of 200 Broadway. All areas of Broadway need proper street furniture and planters. To this end, each block will receive potted plants, trees, café tables, chairs and market umbrellas emblazoned with the BIA logo. In discussion with Daniel Locke, the Town’s Manager of Public Works, he indicated that the town had purchased 5,000 pieces of the grey inter-locking stone bricks which could be used to replace where the grates and trees are being removed. Cost: The cost of the 2019 Beautification plan is approximately $38,000 plus a contingency allowance of $2,000 for a total of $40,000. There may be contributions to reduce cost(s) from any or all of the following parties: Town of Tillsonburg Strathallen Group Gino’s Pizza Tim Horton’s (Salverda Donuts) Actionable items: 1) ED and Chair to complete downtown walk-through with Senior Town Staff – date TBD. 2) Remove and reinstall banner hardware which was installed incorrectly and facing the wrong way. Who: TBD. Completion date: April 10th. 3) Request a letter of support from the Town of Tillsonburg for permission to repurpose the 200 Broadway/Tillsonburg Town Centre main entrance into an outdoor café. Who: ED. Completion date: March 31st, 2019 4) Purchase market umbrellas, café tables and chairs, pots, plants, smoking control for deployment on Broadway, Oxford Street, Harvey Street, Ridout Street and Brock Street. 5) Development of the patio-ization of the front main entrance for 200 Broadway including the creation of a demarcation point and delineation of a non-smoking seating & dining area. This will include strategic placement of café tables, chairs, market umbrellas and potted plants. 6) Prune existing trees in front of 200 Broadway. Who: TBD. Completion date: April 15th. 7) Remove evergreen shrubs on the south side of Bridge Street from Broadway to the first entrance from 200 Broadway. Who: volunteers. Completion date: March 24th. 8) Plant new trees on Harvey Street, east side, from Brock northerly to Avondale United Church. Who: volunteers. Completion date: pending locates and approval from Town of Tillsonburg. 9) Procure and install 7 new pole banners for Oxford Street heritage poles from Tillson Avenue intersection to Broadway. Completion date 04/21/19 10) Remove all dead, damaged and improperly located trees on Broadway. Who: Volunteers. Completion date: April 1st, 2019. Cost: $0. Town staff to pick up cut-down pieces and dispose of at transfer station. 11) Install new all-weather composite park benches at - Oxford/Broadway parkette. Who: BIA. Completion date: April 30th, 2019. 12) Trim trees, remove perennials from Oxford/Broadway parkette. Who: Town. Completion date: April 15th. 13) Meeting with Tillsonburg Horticultural Society on beautification plan. March 20th at 10:30 am. 14) ED to procure, at the best possible cost; keeping in mind the reliability of the vendor/contractor; for all supplies, furniture, hardware and materials as discussed in this report. I have drafted the following resolution for consideration of the board as follows: Resolution #OP-ED-03-19-2019-A MOVED BY: _____________________ and SECONDED BY: ______________________ AND RESOLVED THAT THE BOARD OF MANAGEMENT OF THE BIA APPROVES THE 2019 BEAUTIFICATION PLAN AND FUNDING WITH AN UPSET LIMIT OF $40,000 TO BE FUNDED WITHIN THE EXISTING FRAMEWORK OF THE OVERALL BIA APPROVED BUDGET FOR 2019. THIS INCLUDES PARTIAL REALLOCATION OF DOLLARS FROM FIP FUNDING TO BEAUTIFICATIONS- GENERAL. CARRIED: ________________________ DEFEATED: ___________________________ APPROVED BY: _______________________ 2019 Beautification Worksheet Tillsonburg BIA 19-Mar-19 Quantity Unit Price Extension HST:Totals: Banners Oxford Street 7 90.00$ 630.00$ Trees Broadway 10 225.00$ 2,250.00$ Harvey 5 225.00$ 1,125.00$ Oxford Street 1 225.00$ 225.00$ Broadway patio 2 225.00$ 450.00$ Perennials/flowers/hostas 250 4.74$ 1,185.00$ Soil/mulch/gravel 1 750.00$ 750.00$ Market umbrellas 30 88.00$ 2,640.00$ Umbrella bases 28 62.50$ 1,750.00$ Planters Broadway patio small size 5 105.00$ 525.00$ large size 2 225.00$ 450.00$ Broadway small size 22 105.00$ 2,310.00$ tree planter/large pot 8 425.00$ 3,400.00$ large size 8 225.00$ 1,800.00$ Oxford St.8 105.00$ 840.00$ Banner brackets (new)14 65.00$ 910.00$ Café tables Broadway patio 10 125.00$ 1,250.00$ Broadway 20 125.00$ 2,500.00$ Oxford 2 125.00$ 250.00$ Spares 5 125.00$ 625.00$ Chairs Broadway patio 40 60.00$ 2,400.00$ Broadway 40 60.00$ 2,400.00$ Oxford 6 60.00$ 360.00$ Spare-unassigned 12 60.00$ 720.00$ Smoking control:4 250.00$ 1,000.00$ Winter lights 4 640.00$ 2,560.00$ Galvanized barrier 2 180.00$ 360.00$ Benches Broadway/Oxford parkette 2 1,215.00$ 2,430.00$ Sub-totals:38,095.00$ CONTINGENCY @ %5 1,904.75$ Totals:39,999.75$ Chris Tucker Mar 15, 2019, 4:58 PM (4 days ago) to me Hello Mark, Thank you once again for your time and interest earlier today. It was a pleasure meeting with you and I look forward to continuing the longstanding relationship between Classic Displays and the Downtown Tillsonburg BIA. As mentioned in our meeting, Classic Displays has been servicing BIA’s across the country since our inception back in 1977. I myself have been with the company since 2005 and have had a focus on the BIA market since that time (14 years). I can definitely appreciate your vision and believe it is more than attainable provided a plan is put in place, stuck to and bought into by the other key members of your community (Business owners and municipality). Below I have summarized some of the points discussed earlier today as well as provided your requested information and pricing. Street Scape: Banners When dressing your street, the key target for beautification efforts should be the pedestrians walking the street, not the vehicle traffic. Most vehicles will continue to drive the street, regardless of how the downtown looks. If it appeals to those walking the street, they are far more likely to visit again, stay longer and spend more time in your downtown. For that reason, I would recommend that your current banner hardware (which is currently upside down, the swing arms should be on the bottom, not the top) be relocated to the sidewalk side of the street. I also believe it should be lowered. You want it to catch the eye of those walking the street, people should not have to look up to see the image. I would recommend the lower banner arm be 9-10’ above the sidewalk. I would also strongly recommend that your new program feature a hashtag or other link/reference to your new social media efforts. This will help to educate the public on the new efforts being made by the BIA and hopefully increase traffic on those platforms. Furniture Should the BIA wish to expand their waste and recycling program, I would recommend moving to a new container that makes it easier to distinguish the proper waste stream for which to deposit waste. This can be achieved either through a combination of larger graphics as well as colour coding the waste streams. I did see lots of cross contamination in your bins, hopefully, making the streams more distinguishable will help to reduce this in the future. Benches, we had discussed this matter thoroughly during our meeting. To summarize my thoughts on this, benches should always be installed facing the storefronts and not the street. The main reasons for this are 3 fold. 1. The bench seats will stay cleaner as they are protected from splashing dirt, salt and grim from passing vehicles. This will make them more inviting to use. 2. When someone is sitting on a bench facing a store front, it is advertising for the store. They can look in the window, maybe see something of interest, possibly inspire them to go in and shop. This will not happen with their back to the store. 3. Safety. If a child is sitting on the bench with a parent and they decide to dart off of the bench, they will not be pointed in the direction of traffic. It also allows a parent waiting on a child in a shop to see them as the exit a store. Christmas Décor The new trend amongst BIA’s is to move away from traditional Christmas décor such as wreaths and trees and focus on more winter specific displays such as snowflakes. The main reason for this is that it gives the BIA’s more bang for their buck. A snowflake can be installed in early November and can stay on the pole until Mid-March, where as a wreath or a tree starts to look out of place after about mid-January. The extension of the program will not only help to justify the expense of the décor, it will also add additional much needed brightness to the otherwise dark and dreary streets and evenings that are present in late January and early February where it is still getting dark at 4:30 in the afternoon. The other big trend in Christmas décor is finding that Photo Op moment/display, which will be instantly uploaded to someone’s Facebook or Instagram account. These focal pieces can also be branded or placed next to branded items to further promote the BIA and their décor efforts. This would tie into the large illuminated rings we discussed or the fiberglass photo bear. Should you or your team wish to discuss any of the above points in greater detail, please do not hesitate to contact me and I will be more than happy to assist you further. Please find below your requested pricing for the items discussed, along with a link to the appropriate section of our webpage. We are currently in the midst of our Annual New Year’s sale, with discounts being offered on any units which can be produced and invoiced before March 31st. This is an annual sale with savings of up to 30% off. I have listed the sale pricing below as well in red. Christmas Décor 4’ Snowflake $625.00 $562.50 http://www.classicdisplays.com/product/holiday-displays/exterior/led-rope-light/snowflake 4’ Snow Flurry $725.00 $652.50 http://www.classicdisplays.com/product/holiday-displays/exterior/led-rope-light/snow-flurry 5’ Snow Blossom $750.00 $675.00 http://www.classicdisplays.com/product/holiday-displays/exterior/led-rope-light/snow-blossom 5’ Snow Swirl $835.00 $751.50 http://www.classicdisplays.com/product/holiday-displays/exterior/led-rope-light/snow-swirl 4’ Snow Diamonds $795.00 $715.50 http://www.classicdisplays.com/product/holiday-displays/exterior/led-rope-light/snow-diamond 5’ Snow Spear $865.00 $778.50 http://www.classicdisplays.com/product/holiday-displays/exterior/led-rope-light/snow-spear 7’ Snow Fall $935.00 $841.50 http://www.classicdisplays.com/product/holiday-displays/exterior/led-rope-light/snowfall 5’ Snow Crystal $975.00 $877.50 http://www.classicdisplays.com/product/holiday-displays/exterior/led-rope-light/snow-crystal Illuminated arch "Otaki" - LED - warm white - 11.5' x 13.1' x 5.9' - 24V UL - US plug $15,535.00 $10,874.50 https://classicdisplays.com/product/otaki-archway/ Fiberglass Bear $5,600.00 $5,040.00 https://classicdisplays.com/product/photo-bear/ Banners I am waiting to hear back on your requested larger sizes and hope to have something to you on Tuesday Morning (I am off on Monday) 24” x 72” x 25 banners $78.20 each. 23oz, full colour 24” x 84” x 25 banners 24” x 96” x 25 banners Banner arms Fixed upper arm-as per sample left $50.00 each Swing lower arm-same as on your poles $60.00 each Furniture The Griffin-Very Narrow Footprint https://classicdisplays.com/product/griffin/ Griffin Waste and Recycling Unit, Straight or Stone Effect colours Labelled with front & rear decals $ 999.00 $899.10 Fully labelled including front back and sides $1,475.00 $1,375.10 Corporate Logo (pair) $ 55.00 Front Panel (piece) $ 90.00 Side panel (piece) $ 70.00 Back panel (piece) $ 135.00 Calla Planter $165.00 $148.50 https://classicdisplays.com/product/calla/ Hosta $735.00 $661.50 https://classicdisplays.com/product/hosta/ Hanging Self-Watering Baskets $375.00 $337.50 Additional information attached https://classicdisplays.com/product/pro-series-hanging-basket/ Accessible Riverside Bench https://classicdisplays.com/product/accessible-riverside-2/ Accessible Classic Riverside Bench, 6' w/ Arms Recycled Plastic Slats $ 1,350.00 $1,215.00 Accessible Classic Riverside Bench Multi Coloured, 6' w/ Arms Recycled Plastic Slats $ 1,450.00 $1,305.00 Optional center arm $130.00 Please also find attached images of the laneway lighting we did for Brampton that we had also discussed (photo bear is also in the shot). If there is anything further I can do for you at this time, please do not hesitate to contact me. Thank you again for your time and interest and I look forward to working with you this year. Chris Tucker Classic Displays 905 282 8888 www.classicdisplays.com Beautifying Public Spaces Through Furniture and Display Products Tillsonburg BIA - 2019 Events, Marketing & Promotions Committee Meeting/Events Schedule Month: Meeting or Event date/time: Place: Description: February Committee Meeting Thursday, February 7th 5:00 pm BIA boardroom 20 Oxford Street Committee meeting March Committee Meeting Wednesday, March 13th 5:00 – 6:00 pm Boston Pizza 102 Broadway Committee meeting MARCH BIA MEMBER SOCIAL Wednesday, March 27th 5:00 pm – 7:00 pm Boston Pizza Private dining room MEMBER EVENT MARCH BUSINESS SPOTLIGHT TBD – finalize with Kim Miggens (away until 2nd week of March) Peddlar’s Quay 20 Ridout St. W. EVENT APRIL BUSINESS SPOTLIGHT TBD TBD EVENT April Committee Meeting Thursday, April 18 5:00 – 7:00 pm BIA boardroom 20 Oxford Street Committee meeting April Downtown Clean-up & Decorating contest TBD TBD EVENT MAY Business of the Month TBD TBD EVENT MAY IS BIKE MONTH “Ride your bike downtown” TBD TBD EVENT May Committee Meeting Thursday, May 16th 5:00 – 7:00 pm BIA boardroom 20 Oxford Street Committee meeting June Committee Meeting Thursday, June 13th 5:00 – 7:00 pm BIA boardroom 20 Oxford Street Committee meeting JUNE Business of the month TBD TBD EVENT TURTLEFEST BLOCK PARTY Friday, June 14 5:00 pm to midnight Broadway from Baldwin/Oxford to Bridge EVENT Sidewalk Days TBD In conjunction with Tillsonburg Town Centre EVENT July Committee Meeting Thursday, July 11th 5:00 – 7:00 pm BIA boardroom 20 Oxford Street Committee meeting CANADA DAY - ALL DAY BLOCK PARTY w. STATION ARTS including PARADE & CAR SHOW Monday, July 1st All day on Bridge Street Parade: Bidwell Street Bridge Street from Broadway to Rolph Parade, Car show & Block Party Event JULY Business of the Month TBD TBD Event July Committee Meeting Thursday, July 18th 5:00 – 7:00 pm BIA boardroom 20 Oxford Street Committee meeting August Committee Meeting Thursday, August 15 5:00 pm BIA boardroom 20 Oxford Street Committee meeting AUGUST Business of the Month TBD TBD Event FALL DECORATION CONTEST TBD All of downtown EVENT September Committee Meeting Thursday, September 12 5:00 – 7:00 pm BIA boardroom 20 Oxford Street Committee meeting SEPTEMBER Business of the Month TBD TBD EVENT TTC marketing promo TBD Tillsonburg Town Centre EVENT OCTOBER Business of the Month TBD TBD EVENT October Committee Meeting Thursday, October 17th 5:00 pm BIA boardroom 20 Oxford Street Committee Meeting HALLOWEEN PROMO TBD To begin October 15th and end October 31st All of downtown EVENT NOVEMBER Business of the Month TBD TBD EVENT November Committee Meeting Thursday, November 14 5:00 – 7:00 pm BIA boardroom 20 Oxford Street Committee Meeting DECEMBER Business of the Month TBD TBD EVENT CHRISTMAS CRAWL HOLI-DAZZLE Crawl – Friday, December 6th Holi-Dazzle – Saturday, December 7th Broadway and all downtown participating merchants/businesses EVENT December BIA Office Christmas Open House TBD All downtown participating merchants/businesses EVENT December Committee Meeting Thursday, December 12th 5:00 pm BIA boardroom 20 Oxford Street Regular NEW YEAR’S EVE AT THE CLOCK TOWER BLOCK PARTY Tuesday, December 31st 9:00 pm – 1:00 am Clock Tower and Bridge Street from Broadway to Bidwell Block party, ball drop, fireworks 1 DOWNTOWN TILLSONBURG RETAIL GAP ANALYSIS January 2019 DRAFT 360 Collective and Page by Page Consulting 99 Ivy Ave Toronto ON M4L 2H8 www.360collective.co 647 339 9008 2 Contents 1.Market Profile 2.Socio-Economic Profile 3.Retail Supply Inventory 4.Retail Visitation Profile 5.SWOT 6.Next Steps 3 Market Audit -profile Socio-Economic Profile Trade Areas •10 Minute Walk Time: 800 m radius •5 Minute Drive Time 10 MINUTE WALK TIME 5 MINUTE DRIVE TIME 4 Market Audit -profile Socio-Economic Profile Trade Areas •10 Minute Walk Time: 800 m radius •5 Minute Drive Time •30 Minute Drive Time (Truncated for man made barriers) 30 MINUTE DRIVE TIME (truncated) 10 MINUTE WALK TIME 5 MINUTE DRIVE TIME 5 10 MINUTE WALKING DISTANCE 5 MINUTE DRIVE TIME TOWN OF TILLSONBURG 30 MINUTE DRIVE TIME (TRUNCATED)ONTARIO Population 2018 3,324 14,770 16,318 61,495 14,279,818 Annual Growth Rate 2011 to 2016 0.2%0.8%0.9%0.8%1.5% Persons Per Household 1.9 2.14 2.17 2.62 2.56 Daytime Worker Population 4,751 8,867 9,138 19,709 6,960,297 AGE PROFILE 0 to 9 8%9%9%13%10% 10 to 19 8%10%10%13%11% 20 to 29 10%11%11%13%14% 30 to 39 10%10%10%11%13% 40 to 49 10%11%11%11%13% 50 to 59 12%14%13%14%15% 60 to 69 13%14%14%12%12% 70+30%22%21%13%12% Median Age 54.1 49.4 48.7 40.0 40.9 HOUSEHOLD SIZE 1 Person 45%33%32%24%26% 2 Person 36%40%40%38%33% 3 Person 9%12%13%14%16% 4+ Person 10%15%15%24%25% Key Findings: •There is a growing base of residents within an easy 10-minute walking distance of Downtown Tillsonburg. •The primary trade area is similar to the 5-minute drive time, which is similar to the boundaries for the Town of Tillsonburg. There are over 16,000 residents in the Town of Tillsonburg. •Within a 30-minute drive time (truncated) there is a catchment trade area of approximately 60,000 residents. •In addition, Downtown retailers benefit from approximately 4,751 daytime workers within an easy walking distance as well as over 9,000 day time workers in Downtown and nearby industrial/commercial areas. •The age profile skews heavily senior based on those families that are aging in place, empty nesters, and retirees. There are a growing number of young families living in the trade areas as well . •The higher number of retirees and seniors corresponds with a high proportion of single person households. This is followed by a high proportion of empty nesters or two-person households. Source: Statistics Canada, 2016 Census, Environics 2018 Est. Market Audit -profile Socio-Economic Profile 6 Market Audit -profile Socio-Economic Profile Town of Tillsonburg Age Profile 2011 and 2018 Source: Statistics Canada, 2011 2016 Census, Environics 2018 Est. 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 0 to 9 10 to 19 20 to 29 30 to 39 40 to 49 50 to 59 60 to 69 70+ 2011 2016 2018 Salient Findings: •The age profile skews older as both the baby boomer residents are aging in place and new residential has been built to cater to this demographic. •Generally, the Tillsonburg age trends follow the Ontario age trends of a growing baby boomer generation, a smaller Gen X (40 to 55), a growing Millennial (22 to 39), and a smaller Gen Z (teenager) population •The recent baby boom of Millennials entering parenthood hasn’t affected the Tillsonburg population yet. 7 Key Findings: •Most residents have a college degree or a diploma. This matches the higher proportion of residents who work in blue collar professions. •Household income in Tillsonburg is similar to the local areas. However, near Downtown the higher proportion of fixed income seniors skews the household income lower. •The real rate of household income growth excluding inflation has been growing annually at 1.3% which is a positive indicator for retail growth opportunities. 10 MINUTE WALKING DISTANCE 5 MINUTE DRIVE TIME TOWN OF TILLSONBURG 30 MINUTE DRIVE TIME (TRUNCATED)ONTARIO EDUCATION AND OCCUPATION Less than High School 28%24%23%31%18% High School Graduate 31%28%28%27%25% College, Diploma 31%32%32%29%25% Bachelor Degree or Higher 10%16%17%13%32% Labour Force Part. Rate 51%60%60%55%62% Mngt., Business, Admin 11%16%18%18%26% Health, Science, Ed. Govt 17%22%22%18%28% Arts, Culture, Recreation 3%2%2%2%3% Sales and Services 24%21%20%16%23% Trades and Transport 21%19%18%24%13% Primary 8%5%4%10%2% Processing, Mfg 14%14%14%11%5% COMMUTE TO WORKVehicle 85%94%94%93%77% Pulbic Transit 1%1%1%1%15% Other 14%5%5%6%8% HOUSEHOLD INCOMEAverage HH Income $67,339 $84,280 $86,339 $85,798 $106,524 An. Real Growth in HH Inc.1.4%1.3%1.3%1.4%1.3% Source: Statistics Canada, 2016 Census, Environics 2018 Est. Socio-Economic Profile Market Audit -profile 8 Key Findings: •Due to the higher proportion of seniors, there are a significant proportion of households that do not own their home but live in retirement or assisted living developments. •Correspondingly, there is a higher proportion of females to males as women often make up a higher proportion oF assisted living residents. •The segmentation of the households reveals a mix of retirees, lower to middle income workers, and older middle-income households. •It is noted there there are a large number of rooming type houses for temporary farm workers primarily in the 30 minute drive time trade area. 10 MINUTE WALKING DISTANCE 5 MINUTE DRIVE TIME TOWN OF TILLSONBURG 30 MINUTE DRIVE TIME (TRUNCATED)ONTARIO Housing Tenure Own/Rent 49% / 51%67% / 33%70% / 30%76% / 24%69% / 31% Gender Male/Female 46% / 54%48% / 52%48% / 52%50% / 50%49% / 51% Mobility Mover within 5 years 35%35%34%31%38% Marital Status Single, Never Married 21%20%20%23%28% Married, Common Law 50%59%60%62%57% Div, Sep, Widowed 29%21%20%15%15% Prizm Segment Heartland Retirees 10%12%12%4%2% Sunset Towers 17%12%11%4%3% Lunch at Tim's 20%11%11%8%5% Serenity Springs 8%10%10%9%2% Second City Retirees 3%8%9%3%4% Fresh Air Families 2%5%8%3%4% Source: Statistics Canada, 2016 Census, Environics 2018 Est. Socio-Economic Profile Market Audit -profile 9 HEARTLAND RETIREES SUNSET TOWERS LUNCH AT TIM’S SERENITY SPRINGS SECOND CITY RETIREES FRESH AIR FAMILIES % of Tillsonburg Pop.12%11%11%10%9%8% AVERAGE HH INCOME $81,015 $43,8419 $64,713 $77,040 $100,147 $113,003 OWN/RENT OWN RENT OWN OWN/ RENT OWN OWN SHOPPING •Enjoy rural life but like access to larger shopping areas •Very good at buying online •Shopping is purposeful and utilitarian •Like to go out to local bar •Support ethical companies •Like to hang out in stores such as Home Hardware and local pharmacy to socialize •Lower income •Bargain hunters •Search and collect loyalty programs •Bargain hunters •Bulk food •Discount stores •Dinner theatre •Very locally minded •Community theatre and night out •Spend on vacations, cruises, dining out, coffee place/café •Visit home improvement stores often •Energy conscious •Somewhat tech savvy but do like in-store help and assistance •Want to buy products related to their personal interests •Big box •Discount grocers •Eat out on a regular basis •Equip family rooms with high tech entertainment •Travel to Florida and East Coast •Source: Statistics Canada, 2016 Census, Environics 2018 Est. Socio-Economic Profile Market Audit -profile 10 HEARTLAND RETIREES SUNSET TOWERS LUNCH AT TIM’S SERENITY SPRINGS SECOND CITY RETIREES FRESH AIR FAMILIES % of Tillsonburg Pop.12%11%11%10%9%8% AVERAGE HH INCOME $81,015 $43,8419 $64,713 $77,040 $100,147 $113,003 OWN/RENT OWN RENT OWN OWN/ RENT OWN OWN ATTITUDES •Higher % of Baby Boomers •Unpretentious •Blue collar or agriculture occupations •Child free so more time for other activities •Like outdoors and nature – parks, fishing, cottage, •Very community minded, traditional values that support country life but not closed minded •Retirement or modest pension •Unpretentious •Hobbies – sewing crafts, collecting •Casino, bingo •Enjoy the slower pace of things •Low tech engagement •Tight knit communities •Enjoy socializing •Casino •Like to look good •Want to get away and will go to vacations •Trust small businesses •Retirement AND Age in place singles and couples •Support local •Go on Staycations •Not online, not tech savvy •Like to read •Generous donors and give to charities •Want to live healthy lives •Very rational and logical in buying decisions •Religious and moral oriented •Older and mature couples •Had worked for companies with good pensions –mfg, govt, teaching, nursing, etc. •Go on cruises •Cottages •Hobbies –golf, gardening, kayak •Focus is on their home and community •Want to leave a legacy behind •Believe Canadian ideals of work hard •Middle aged with children •Dual income households •Solid, upper middle income lifestyle •Have a financial planner to help them •Like small businesses •Very Canadian •Old fashioned •Source: Statistics Canada, 2016 Census, Environics 2018 Est. Socio-Economic Profile Market Audit -profile 11 HEARTLAND RETIREES SUNSET TOWERS LUNCH AT TIM’S SERENITY SPRINGS SECOND CITY RETIREES FRESH AIR FAMILIES % of Tillsonburg Pop.12%11%11%10%9%8% AVERAGE HH INCOME $81,015 $43,8419 $64,713 $77,040 $100,147 $113,003 OWN/RENT OWN RENT OWN OWN/ RENT OWN OWN LEISURE •Camping, gardening, motorcycles, pickups, powerboats, snowmobiles •Hobbies –bird watching, cross country skiing •Hobbies •Crafts •Casino •Go to baseball game •Hobbies – knitting, woodworking, crafts •Curling •Auto racing •Men go fishing or snowmobiling •Women sew or garden •Go too outdoor and RV shows •Community and faith based activities •Outdoors, fishing, boating, canoeing, camping, boats, motorcycles, pick ups •Crafts –knitting Source: Statistics Canada, 2016 Census, Environics 2018 Est. Socio-Economic Profile Market Audit -profile 12 10 MINUTE WALKING DISTANCE 5 MINUTE DRIVE TIME TOWN OF TILLSONBURG 30 MINUTE DRIVE TIME (TRUNCATED) ONTARIO AVERAGE HOUSEHOLD INCOME $67,339 $84,280 $86,339 $85,798 $106,524 Local Neighbour Goods Food from Grocery Stores $5,672 $6,707 $6,836 $7,438 $8,118 Health Care and Pharmacy $2,271 $2,586 $2,628 $2,680 $3,010 Alcohol Purchased from Stores $1,011 $1,306 $1,335 $1,182 $1,524 Retail Merchandise Women's Clothing and Accessories $1,084 $1,468 $1,512 $1,504 $1,979 Men's Clothing and Accessories $581 $795 $818 $908 $1,200 Children's Clothing $35 $42 $44 $54 $65 Home Furnishings $871 $1,028 $1,061 $1,143 $1,650 Nursery Flowers $169 $224 $234 $229 $226 Pet Food $271 $369 $382 $452 $317 Gifts $505 $550 $556 $541 $472 Leisure Retail $352 $493 $508 $532 $646 Electronics $526 $704 $727 $735 $1,024 Appliances $451 $567 $590 $685 $602 Home Improvement $103 $145 $157 $250 $166 Source: Statistics Canada, 2016 Census, Environics 2018 Est.* Very high HH income expenditure compared to Ontario Trade AreaMarket Audit -profile Household Expenditure Profile 13 10 MINUTE WALKING DISTANCE 5 MINUTE DRIVE TIME TOWN OF TILLSONBURG 30 MINUTE DRIVE TIME (TRUNCATED) ONTARIO AVERAGE HOUSEHOLD INCOME $67,339 $84,280 $86,339 $85,798 $106,524 Food Services Dinner at Restaurants $1,486 $1,815 $1,850 $1,858 $2,533 Lunch at Restaurants $809 $980 $996 $1,003 $1,363 Breakfast at Restaurants $240 $286 $288 $296 $361 Snacks and Beverages $514 $594 $601 $579 $547 Alcohol Serviced on Premises $466 $601 $616 $438 $767 Services Clothing Services $116 $99 $99 $72 $219 Packaged Travel $145 $123 $164 $389 $648 Recreation Memberships $238 $361 $375 $325 $502 Personal Care $495 $616 $632 $606 $755 Movies $62 $86 $87 $68 $88 Live Sporting Events $10 $13 $14 $18 $42 Live Performing Arts $45 $53 $57 $75 $118 Museums $50 $67 $71 $64 $93 Source: Statistics Canada, 2016 Census, Environics 2018 Est.* Very high HH income expenditure compared to 30 Min Trade AreaMarket Audit -profile Household Expenditure Profile 14 Key Findings: •Many expenditures by households in the 10-minute walking trade area and the 5-minute drive time trade area are lower than the average based primarily on lower average household incomes. •To understand the character and shopping behaviour of the trade area residents an analysis of household expenditures of each trade area compared to the Ontario average was conducted. Second, the index was compared to household incomes to determine if a greater proportion of the budget was spend on each commodity listed. •For example, households in the 5 minute drive time spend $6,707 annually on food from grocery stores. This is 83% of the average household for Ontario. However, because the average household income of the 5 minute drive is $84,280 or 79% of the Ontario average, it is clear that households in the 5 minute drive time spend a higher proportion (83% compared to 79%) of their budget on food from grocery stores compared to the average Ontario household. •Based on this analysis, households in Tillsonburg spend a higher than average proportion of their budget on: •Home: both large and small purchases including grocery items and alcohol, cut flowers and home furnishings to appliances and outdoor supplies •Entertaining: going out for small snacks, cafes, socializing, personal care services, and gifts for others •Seniors: health care goods and services Market Audit -profile Household Expenditure Profile 15 Downtown Tillsonburg Retail Supply Inventory –December 2018 16 Supply –Downtown Tillsonburg Retail Inventory Area Inventory Methodology •Baseline data from the Town •Physical inventory based on a site visit in Dec 2018 •Actual square footages from leasing material of Strathallen leasing material •Other retailers are estimated •Includes ground level businesses and easily accessible retail spaces Market Audit -profile Downtown Retail Study Area Downtown BIA and CIP 17 NO. OF BUSINESSES % OF TOTAL EST. SF % OF TOTAL RETAIL MERCHANDISE Furniture and Home Furnishings 5 2.8%17,264 2.8% Electronics and Appliances 9 5.0%11,958 1.9% Home Improvement, Building Supplies 1 0.6%1,300 0.2% Clothing and Accessories 14 7.8%35,156 5.7% General Merchandise 3 1.7%146,366 23.5% Leisure Retail 9 5.0%16,666 2.7% Other Retail 6 3.3%25,183 4.1% TOTAL RETAIL MERCHANDISE 47 26.1%253,893 40.8% FOOD AND DRUG RETAIL Food and Beverage 7 3.9%46,471 7.5% Health, Pharmacy 4 2.2%23,426 3.8% TOTAL FOOD AND DRUG RETAIL 11 6.1%69,897 11.2% EATING ESTABLISHMENTS 16 8.9%40,553 6.5% OTHER SERVICES Personal Services 18 10.0%24,398 3.9% Financial 7 3.9%29,170 4.7% Recreation 2 1.1%2,100 0.3% Professional Services 32 17.8%74,923 12.1% Medical Services 23 12.8%69,476 11.2% Other Services 15 8.3%41,399 6.7% TOTAL OTHER SERVICES 97 53.9%241,466 38.8% TOTAL OCCUPIED 171 95.0%605,809 97.5% VACANT 9 5.0%15,780 2.5% TOTAL 180 100.0%621,589 100.0% Supply –Downtown Tillsonburg Retail Inventory Area Key Findings •Vacancy is low, 2.5% •Retail merchandise is the dominant category due to large format stores, skews the analysis •High proportion of services including professional and medical –provides a source of visitor traffic to other businesses in Downtown but does occupy some prime retail spaces •Good proportion of food and drug retailers but opportunity for more growth •Lower proportion of eating establishments than in other Downtowns but there is good range of chains and independents •New developments will add more SF to the Downtown particularly in the north end Market Audit -profile 18 Supply –Downtown Tillsonburg Retail Inventory Area Key Findings •Through observation it was noted that there is pedestrian flow between the Tillsonburg Town Centre and the rest of Downtown as well as the nearby Metro particularly within the 2 block radius of the Tillsonburg Town Centre. •The location of the Bulk Barn is a key retailer that appeals to all shoppers and helps to move pedestrian traffic throughout the entire Downtown. •Policies that have ensured offices and administrative offices to locate in Downtown have been successful at ensuring there is daytime traffic for the businesses. •There are a few emerging ‘clusters’ of businesses –home décor for example but they have not located near to each other for ease of shopping. •According to the Downtown BIA, hours of operation especially amongst independent retailers is a cause for some retail sales leakage. Other causes are the lack of some discount and value oriented retailers. Market Audit -profile 19 Mark’s Work Wearhouse –Tuesday -Thursday Saturday Supply –Downtown Tillsonburg Retailer Visitation Times Market Audit -profile Dollar Tree –Tuesday Thursday Saturday LCBO –Tuesday Thursday Saturday 20 Canadian Tire –Tuesday Thursday Saturday Supply –Downtown Tillsonburg Retailer Visitation Times Market Audit -profile Walmart –Tuesday Thursday Saturday Metro –Tuesday Thursday Saturday 21 Kelsey’s –Tuesday Thursday Saturday Supply –Downtown Tillsonburg Retailer Visitation Times Market Audit -profile Copper Mug –Tuesday Thursday Saturday Boston Pizza –Tuesday Thursday Saturday 22 Corner Griddle –Tuesday Thursday Saturday Supply –Downtown Tillsonburg Retailer Visitation Times Market Audit -profile Corey’s –Tuesday Thursday Saturday Pita Pit –Tuesday Thursday Saturday 23 Shoppers Drug Mart –Tuesday Thursday Saturday Supply –Downtown Tillsonburg Retailer Visitation Times Market Audit -profile Bulk Barn –Tuesday Thursday Saturday 24 •Saturday is the biggest shopping day in Downtown •This is followed closely by weekday evening visitation •There is a fairly good visitation to the weekday restaurants and cafes primarily from the local area daytime workers •Increasingly local residents commute to work and they are conducting a higher proportion of their local shopping needs during the early evening and some weeknights are relatively busy •For some businesses, there is a relatively strong daytime traffic demand including Shoppers Drug Mart, Bulk Barn, Mark’s Work Wearhouse, Copper Mug, and other restaurants such as Pita Pit •Early morning Saturday has increased visitation for a number of businesses as local households want to start their weekends early and get their errands done so they can go out and enjoy the rest of the day so places such as Corner Griddle have a good brunch time traffic Market Audit -profile Summary: Supply –Downtown Tillsonburg Retailer Visitation Times 25 Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats –Retail Development in Downtown Tillsonburg 26 SWOT STRENGTHS •Solid base of residents of 16,000 that is growing •Real household income growth (excluding inflation) •Somewhat isolated from other commercial areas, so they are able to create a draw from other nearby smaller communities •Mix of target markets in Downtown including people living there, workers, local and regional visitors that support daytime and limited night time retail activities, as well as some seasonal workers •Convenient –easy to get to, easy to park, free parking, wide main street •Charm –heritage and historical two and three-storey buildings creating a base of residential within the core •Character –friendly shop owners and workers, open, communicative •Tillsonburg Town Centre blends in well with the main street and doesn’t overly detract from the main street businesses •Good assortment of discount and value-based retail •Some historical long-term businesses with longevity creates confidence in prospective retailers WEAKNESSES •Skewed household income –those on fixed incomes, lower income, savers not spenders, but some high-income households •Not a tourist town (can be a benefit –not affected by the whims of the tourism industry) •Retail is scattered throughout Town to the north, centre, and east and not clustered as effectively as it could be (e.g, grocery stores, home improvement stores are located throughout the entire town rather than clustered to create better flows and critical mass synergy) •Seniors based area who have things provided for them such as food –don’t need to shop •Slightly too much ground level retail is devoted to services especially professional services and medical services rather than retail (however, want the services in the Downtown just not so much on the main street) •Few places for socialization to happen on the street and inside businesses •Few places for triggering a night time economy THREATS •London closest competition and London is already over retailed •Strathallen owns both malls in Tillsonburg which can make it confusing from a leasing and marketing perspective (are there exclusivities) •Other more tourist-based towns that are more experiential (e.g., watching food being prepared, combining entertainment and food together such as a band playing in a café) and lure locals for a night out or dinner 27 SWOT OPPORTUNITIES RECOMMENDATION RATIONALE Food and Beverage •No further major grocery stores or LCBO •Potential for specialty food stores (e.g., Goodness Me) •Ensure Walmart carries enough value oriented food items •Specialty food can complement the existing grocery stores such as Metro and Walmart •They can provide a link in the customer journey similar to the function and location of Bulk Barn •Should be paired with additional functions such as catering, prepared food as take away, and home meal replacement Health and Pharmacy •Health related goods and services will always be in high demand and can shift •There may not be a need for a large pharmacy but smaller unique health stores, optical stores, etc, could be warranted •In an older community such as Tillsonburg, health care is a major household expenditure from prescriptions, over the counter medicine, health supplies, optical stores, health supplements, naturalpaths, etc. Furniture and Home Furnishings •Focus should be on retaining existing furniture, home furnishings type stores and allow for more modern home furnishings stores to establish themselves (e.g., Saturday Afternoons) or art galleries •Craft or hobby oriented home furnishings such as custom made Mennonite furniture •There are several furniture stores in Downtown •Focus on retention of existing stores and ensure they maintain a modern, current offering •There is a potential to combine hobby and craft expertise of Tillsonburg with furniture and home furnishings making Electronics •Focus on retention of existing stores including the ability to order online and pick up in store •Electronic stores are becoming showrooms for the latest technology •Stores need to be able to offer the ability for consumers to order online and then pick up in store as a way of not only providing increased convenience to local residents but for increased shopping 28 SWOT OPPORTUNITIES RECOMMENDATION RATIONALE Clothing and Accessories •Focus on retention of existing clothing, jewellery, and accessories stores •Any new retailer should have a narrow and deep focus (concentrate on one or two lines or offerings and carry a deep assortment in for each one) •Focus on craft, handmade items •There is limited growth not on only in Tillsonburg but across North America for clothing and accessory related retail •Similar to home furnishings, there is an opportunity to combine craft and hobby skill sets with clothing lines –such as knitted sweaters, custom leather bags (where some of the manufacturing is done on site) Leisure Retail •Focus on retention of existing gift and book stores •Increase the number of craft and hobby related stores including supplies as well as production ie: workshops •Have places such as knitting cafes, children / adult art schools, art cafes, book store cafes, etc.) •Locate craft supplies together (sewing, leather handwork, knitting, art supplies, DIY stores •Add learning programs to retailers such as singing, piano, art, story writing/story telling •Create opportunities for local craft, hobby, entrepreneurs to hone their skills General Merchandise •No additional discount oriented stores •There are ample discount general merchandise stores •New stores would only spread the sales around Home Improvement •No major new home improvement stores •Could be co-located better across the City •Ample selection of home improvement type stores in Tillsonburg 29 SWOT OPPORTUNITIES RECOMMENDATION RATIONALE Eating Establishments •Need to replace or add to the number of places for socialization and eating -cafes, coffee places, andother food/socialization places in Downtown •More sit down, casual restaurants that are higher quality •Dinner theatre options •Include more eating establishments with entertainment •Food is the glue that holds the community together •There are good food options at present but the strategy should focus on where there are gaps in the food service mix •Local residents do not spend high amounts on eating out but will spend it on “in between” activities •There is a lack of casual and better quality restaurants in Tillsonburg (probably losing market share to other communities) Night Time Economy •Monitor the change in demographic toward young families to be able to provide a timely response to their needs e.g., bowling alley, dinnertime needs, ice cream shops open after soccer games etc. •As a community changes so too do their needs. It’s important to watch this change and to be able to plan a response. Some businesses already have a weeknight later evening business profile that other businesses can piggy back of. See Next Steps for further comments. 30 NEXT STEPS –in order of timing •Either the Town or the BIA needs to create a full business directory so that people can find the information easily for: •Marketing purposes and •Recruitment/investment. •Work with the BIA Board and new ED to create their own Retail Wish List from the BIA’s perspective. •Town to Identify locations for re-development based on a set of criteria. •BIA should develop a new website where the directory and the properties for lease at any given time can be accessible. The Town may also have a list of all for lease or for sale properties. v Social Media cannot do this effectively and people need access to that information. •Work with building owners where there are currently places to rent and/or buy to impart on them the need for certain businesses to fill the gaps. •Host session with local commercial realtors and share the data that has been uncovered here and the retail wish list -they can be part of the solution and kept in the loop. •Consider a Strategic or Action Planning Process for the BIA. With a new Board and/or staff, this can often help them come to a shared vision for their downtown. Town staff should be part of the process to include City vision and information for one cohesive effort. •Create an “Invest in Tillsonburg Downtown” digital and/or online marketing piece siting investment incentives and information gathered from this process and Retail wish list. •Encourage Like businesses to either locate closely or work together for marketing purposes. •Create a common branding graphic to post in vacant store fronts: “Imagine Your Business Here”. •Work to attract a local investor who will compete against himself to fill the retail gaps & take market share. •Regularly evaluate the senior/young family ratio development projects. The downtown retail mix needs to adapt to the changing demographic as it happens as an increase in young families will demand different retail and service opportunities 31 Sector Recommendation Rationale Next Steps (Initial Thoughts) Food and Beverage No further major grocery stores or LCBO Potential for specialty food stores (e.g., Goodness Me) Ensure Walmart carries enough value oriented food items Specialty food can complement the existing grocery stores such as Metro and Walmart They can provide a link in the customer journey similar to the function and location of Bulk Barn Should be paired with additional functions such as catering, prepared food as take away, and home meal replacement Some recruitment of specialty food stores in the past Health and Pharmacy Health related goods and services will always be in high demand and can shift There may not be a need for a large pharmacy but smaller unique health stores, optical stores, etc, could be warranted In an older community such as Tillsonburg, health care is a major household expenditure from prescriptions, over the counter medicine, health supplies, optical stores, health supplements, naturalpaths, etc. Appear to be well serviced in this regard Furniture and Home Furnishings Focus should be on retaining existing furniture, home furnishings type stores and allow for more modern home furnishings stores to establish themselves (e.g., Saturday Afternoons) or art galleries Craft or hobby oriented home furnishings such as custom made Mennonite furniture There are several furniture stores in Downtown Focus on retention of existing stores and ensure they maintain a modern, current offering There is a potential to combine hobby and craft expertise of Tillsonburg with furniture and home furnishings making Concept of combining hobby/craft with furniture is of interest Electronics Focus on retention of existing stores including the ability to order online and pick up in store Electronic stores are becoming showrooms for the latest technology Needs further review Stores need to be able to offer the ability for consumers to order online and then pick up in store as a way of not only providing increased convenience to local residents but for increased shopping Clothing and Accessories Focus on retention of existing clothing, jewellery, and accessories stores Any new retailer should have a narrow and deep focus (concentrate on one or two lines or offerings and carry a deep assortment in for each one) Focus on craft, handmade items There is limited growth not on only in Tillsonburg but across North America for clothing and accessory related retail Similar to home furnishings, there is an opportunity to combine craft and hobby skill sets with clothing lines – such as knitted sweaters, custom leather bags (where some of the manufacturing is done on site) Interesting opportunity re combining craft and hobby skills with clothing lines. Already have two quilting and related experiential type tourism operators in the downtown Leisure Retail Focus on retention of existing gift and book stores Increase the number of craft and hobby related stores including supplies as well as production ie: workshops Have places such as knitting cafes, children / adult art schools, art cafes, book store cafes, etc.) Locate craft supplies together (sewing, leather handwork, knitting, art supplies, DIY stores Add learning programs to retailers such as singing, piano, art, story writing/story telling Create opportunities for local craft, hobby, entrepreneurs to hone their skills Interesting opportunities General Merchandise No additional discount oriented stores There are ample discount general merchandise stores New stores would only spread the sales around Agreed Home Improvement No major new home improvement stores Could be co-located better across the City Ample selection of home improvement type stores in Tillsonburg Agreed Eating Establishments Need to replace or add to the number of places for socialization and eating - cafes, coffee places, and other food/socialization places in Downtown More sit down, casual restaurants that are higher quality Dinner theatre options Include more eating establishments with entertainment Food is the glue that holds the community together There are good food options at present but the strategy should focus on where there are gaps in the food service mix Local residents do not spend high amounts on eating out but will spend it on “in between” activities There is a lack of casual and better quality restaurants in Tillsonburg (probably losing market share to other communities Challenge is that our market is well-served by over 40 eateries and demographics (young families and seniors) so how do we foster a “foodie” type or higher end establishment??? Night-time Economy Monitor the change in demographic toward young families to be able to provide a timely response to their needs e.g., bowling alley, dinnertime needs, ice cream shops open after soccer games etc. As a community changes so to do their needs. It’s important to watch this change and to be able to plan a response. Some businesses already have a weeknight later evening business profile that other businesses can piggy back off. See Next Steps for further comments. Next Steps (from Retail Gap Analysis) Next Step Action/Status Capacity Building Either the Town or the BIA needs to create a full business directory so that people can find the information easily for: • Marketing purposes • Recruitment/investment BIA should develop a new website where the directory and the properties for lease at any given time can be accessible. The Town may also have a list of all for lease or for sale properties. Social Media cannot do this effectively and people need access to that information. BIA currently working to address the lack of a website and members directory. Website with available properties for lease needs to be discussed further in context of other recommendations on investment readiness for the downtown Work with the BIA Board and new ED to create their own Retail Wish List from the BIA’s perspective. BIA Board reviewing gap analysis at their March 21 meeting Host session with local commercial realtors and share the data that has been uncovered here and the retail wish list - they can be part of the solution and kept in the loop To be discussed further Encourage Like businesses to either locate closely or work together for marketing purposes. To be discussed further Consider a Strategic or Action Planning Process for the BIA. With a new Board and/or staff, this can often help them come to a shared vision for their downtown. Town staff should be part of the process to include City vision and information for one cohesive effort. BIA to review strategy development from 2016/17 timeframe. Action plan in terms of revamping BIA activities underway by new Executive Director Investment Readiness Town to Identify locations for re-development based on a set of criteria. Downtown Parking Study provides initial guidance in this regard. Need to prioritize and obtain Council direction with respect to specific development sites Create an “Invest in Tillsonburg Downtown” digital and/or online marketing piece siting investment incentives and information gathered from this process and Retail wish list. To be reviewed further. Retail Gap Analysis study provides the data for this, which can be used to develop an investment profile. Currently $2,000 in approved Economic Development & Marketing budget for downtown initiatives. Can be matched with BIA funding??? Create a common branding graphic to post in vacant store fronts: “Imagine Your Business Here”. To be reviewed further. Work with building owners where there are currently places to rent and/or buy to impart on them the need for certain businesses to fill the gaps. To be reviewed further. Review of and potential development of a new vacancy rebate program is included in Economic Development & Marketing business plan Consider establishing a task force or working group on retail recruitment that includes Town Centre Mall plus other individuals with interest, i.e. BIA, Economic Development, realtor (s), owners, etc Work to attract a local investor who will compete against himself to fill the retail gaps & take market share. To be reviewed further Regularly evaluate the senior/young family ratio development projects. The downtown retail mix needs to adapt to the changing demographic as it happens as an increase in young families will demand different retail and service opportunities To be reviewed in future in light of current and proposed residential development projects in the downtown Tillsonburg South end Parkette -Hurleys Inbox x Hurleys Appliance <hurleys.appliance@gmail.com> 9:30 AM (4 hours ago) to me Good Morning Mark, As our contact on the Tillsonburg BIA we need your help please. The Parkette directly in front of our business is causing us great concern. In the beginning years it was groomed, cleaned and maintained on a regular basis and was a real asset, not only for us and our customers, but also for the beautification of the whole downtown area. The upkeep and care has greatly declined over time and specific issues are now continual. Although a much appreciated effort has been put forward for spring cleanup it does not continue throughout the season. The trees in the Parkette are becoming quite tall and perhaps overgrown which now restricts the signage for our business. This is especially crucial for us as we are NOT permitted any signage on any property surrounding our business, other than a sandwich board sign. Our options are limited to the space on the outside of our building. The day to day cleanliness of the Parkette is also very neglected. Please carry our concerns forward to find an acceptable solution and let us know. We are willing to work with you and are looking forward to your response. Thank You The Hurleys 58 Broadway St Tillsonburg, ON N4G 3P3 519-688-3464 hurleys.appliance@gmail.com www.hurleysappliance.com