111201Regular Council Meeting MinutesMINUTES: Meeting for the Committee "Open Council'
130
Review Access: • Public Private
MINUTES
Town of Tillsonburg
Meeting for the Committee "Open Council"
on
Thursday December 1, 2011 09:00 AM
Council Chambers
Chair: John Lessif
Orders of the Day:
CALL TO ORDER
The meeting was called to order at 9:01am.
ADDITIONS TO THE AGENDA
i) Message from Mayor
ii)Thames Valley District School Board Announcement
iii) 2012 Budget status update from CAO
ADOPTION OF AGENDA
Resolution No. 1
Moved by: Councillor Rosehart
Seconded by: Councillor Getty AND RESOLVED THAT the Agenda as prepared for the Open
Session of the Council Meeting of December 1, 2011 be adopted, as amended.
"Carried".
i) Message from Mayor
The Mayor reminded Council that today is the one year anniversary of this Council. He noted that there
have been significant challenges over the past year, and that many more challenges lie ahead.
ii) Thames Valley District School Board Announcement
The CAO and Mayor updated Council on the recent announcement by the TVDSB that several schools in
Tillsonburg have been recommended for closure. The CAO provided background on the advance notice
and information that Town representatives received from the TVDSB prior to the announcement. Council
generally agreed that this announcement is a positive development in our community and will improve the
Page 1
rO q
MINUTES: Meeting for the Committee "Open Council"
quality of education in the area.
iii) Budget status update from CAO
The CAO provided a status update in regards to where the Town is at with the 2012 budget process,
indicating that the process is slightly behind schedule. It was also raised that the Town is still awaiting
growth data from MPAC which is due to arrive December 13th, 2011. The target is to have the budget
approved by end of January 2012.
DISCLOSURE OF PECUNIARY INTEREST OR THE GENERAL NATURE THEREOF
None were disclosed.
FINANCE
1.2012 Draft Budget [q
Presented By: Director of Finance
The Director of Finance provided a review of what has been decided as part of the budget process
to date.
Resolution No. 2
Moved by: Councillor Getty
Seconded by: Councillor Rosehart AND RESOLVE THAT the 2012 Draft Budget presentations
from the Director of Finance be received as information.
/001� "Carried"
2.2012 Budget Five Year Comparison
2012 - 5 year compadson.xls
The Director of Finance overviewed the major fluctuations detailed in the spreadsheet provided.
Council Direction, and requests for staff to bring back further information
Fire: Council would like to know when the bunker gear storage unit for the fire station arrives as
there is concern about one of the fire trucks being stored outdoors in the Works yard. The CAO
indicated that it is estimated to be delivered within two weeks, at which point the truck will be
relocated from the works yard to the bay at the fire station.
Airport: Council would like to know how the proposed budget increase fits into the airport's
five-year sustainability plan, and how the plan will move the airport toward becoming free from
taxpayer subsidy. Council is also interested in a report that shows revenues versus costs, and
specifically overviews fuel sales (with a litre per year comparison) as well as data on airport
usage. The Director of Development and Communication Services indicated that a report of this
nature is forthcoming in the new year, likely in January or February. Council would also like to
know what the impact on property taxes to South West Oxford would be in a scenario where the
airport was jointly owned.
Library: The Library CEO and Library Board Chair will deliver a presentation on the Library budget
at Council's meeting of December 12, 2011.
/ORIN Tourism: Council directed staff to bring back a figure for what the budget allocation for "Special
Events" was for 2011. Additionally,
Council has concerns regarding the proposed budget allocation of $43,000 for a FTE, located
under "Tourism". They are proposing that this be relocated to Economic Development. Finally,
Page 2
r4+,
MINUTES: Meeting for the Committee "Open Council"
Council suggested that perhaps Tourism should not be an independent department in the budget,
but rather part of Economic Development.
Parks and Recreation- Council would like to know the budget for Director of Community Services,
and revenue.
Engineering: Council would like staff to provide more detail on the proposed $16,000 budget
allocation for "Overhead Charge". As well, staff to bring back a report on the proposed Sidewalk
Inspector for a cost of $9000. Council would like to know whether this person can work fewer
hours with the Town still doing its 'due diligence'.
Municipal Facilities: Council felt that this allocation did not warrant an independent'department
in the budget, and directed staff to roll this into other departments.
Solid Waste: Council directed the Director of Operations to explore the possibility of user fees at
the transfer station for residential users (for large item dropoff), to help offset the portion of
transfer station costs that are incurred by the Town.
Labour: Council directed staff to bring back a comprehensive report detailing the Town's labour
costs including vacation, sick time, head count, and filled positions vs. vacant.
Hydro: Council is waiting on information to be presented to the Board on the THI budget
In addition to the above, Council flagged a number of items for future discussion
Roads: Council is interested in a five year projection of roads -related infrastructure costs. Council
indicated that the growing infrastructure deficit is a very serious issue that will need to be
discussed at future meetings.
Streetlights: Council has concerns over street lights remaining on once the sun is up, and would
like to explore possible solutions.
Parks and Recreation: Council is concerned by the decreased revenue from youth programs
/0"h\ offered at the Community Centre, and would like to explore new programming options that do not
compete with private sector providers in the community.
Council made a number of further suggestions
Airport: Council suggested the possibility of increasing contributions of airport users to help offset
the required tax subsidy.
Tourism: Council feels there is much room for other community organizations (specifically the
beneficiaries of increased tourism) to contribute to tourism expenditures, such as the BIA, the
Chamber, Station Arts, etc. It was suggested that Turtlefest should be 100% funded by the BIA.
Resolution No. 3
Moved by: Councillor Klein
Seconded by: Councillor Beres AND RESOLVE THAT the 2012 Draft Budget 5 year comparison
from the Director of Finance be received as information.
"Carried"
3.2012 Budget - Debt Summary
Presented By: Director of Finance
The Director of Finance provided a summary of the Town's debt and payback plan.
/0*^� Council indicated that it wishes to focus on the sale of surplus lands to address the debt.
Council inquired as to the possibility of selling the lands located at 200 Broadway to landlord, in
order to reduce the debt. For clarity, the Town owns the lands and parking lots at 200 Broadway,
Page 3
e%t
MINUTES: Meeting for the Committee "Open Council'
and First Capital Realty owns the mall structure. Staff clarified that the landlord has an interest in
acquiring the lands that the structure sits on, but not the parking lots.
Resolution No. 4
Moved by: Councillor Beres
Seconded by: Councillor Klein AND RESOLVE THAT the 2012 Draft Budget Debt Summary from
the Director of Finance be received as information.
"Carried"
4. FIN 11-040 Quarter Town Line, Concession to Esseltine Q
Presented By: Director of Finance
The Director of Finance provided an overview of his report and added some additional information
that has come to light since the writing of the report, indicating that the project came in under
budget and that gas tax dollars are available to assist in paying for it.
Council directed staff to bring back information on whether development charges can fund the
balance of this project instead of through taxes, and whether development charges fit the criteria
for paying for this project.
It was clarified by staff that should council decide to use the gas tax for this project, it would result
in a further decrease to the capital amount raised from taxation.
/006\In order to address the matter, staff recommended that the gas tax funds be utilized, and take the
amount that that frees up and put it into capital reserves. This means that $142,281 will come from
gas tax, and the rest will come from taxation or development charges. This course of action was
endorsed by Council, and staff was asked to bring back a consolidated report outlining the
recommendation.
Resolution No. 5
Moved by: Councillor Stephenson
Seconded by: Beres AND RESOLVE THAT Council receives report FIN 11-040 Quarter Town
Line, Concession to Esseltine, as information.
"Carried"
5.2011 Projected Year End Reserves a
Presented By: Director of Finance
This item was deferred until a future budget meeting.
Resolution No. 6
Moved by:
Seconded by:
RESOLVE THAT the 2011 Projected Year End Reserves be received as information.
FURTHER RESOLVE THAT the 2011 reserve activity be approved as identified in the
attached spreadsheet.
"Deferred"
eaftN 6. FIN11-038 PIL Calculation Q
Presented By: Director of Finance
Council raised concern over the contribution of PIL by hospitals and that it has declined with the
Page 4
MINUTES: Meeting for the Committee "Open Council'
decline in number of beds, while the footprint and activity levels of hospitals are increasing.
Council indicated an interest in making this concern known to the Ministry of Health and Oxford
County by passing a resolution at a future meeting. It was also raised that TDMH may support the
town in this effort.
Council requested that staff bring back a report on the amount of tax/PIL on all hospital owned
properties.
Resolution No. 7
Moved by: Councillor Getty
Seconded by: Councillor RosehartAND RESOLVE THAT Council receives report FIN 11-038 PIL
Calculation as information.
"Carried"
7.2012 Rates and Fees [A)
Presented By: All Directors
Resolution No. 8
Moved by: Councillor Klein
Seconded by: Councillor Beres AND RESOLVE THAT Council receive 2012 Rates and Fees as
information.
Further resolve that a By -Law be brought forward on December 12, 2011 for Council
consideration.
"Carried"
NOTICE OF MOTION
BY-LAWS
8. Bylaw No. 3571 - To confirm the proceedings of Council at its meeting of December 1, 2011.
Id
Confirmatory Bylaw 3571.pdf
Resolution No.9:
Moved by: Councillor Klein
Seconded by: Councillor Beres
AND RESOLVE THAT By -Law 3571, To Confirm the Proceedings of Council for the Council
Meeting of December 1, 2011, be read for a first and second time and this constitutes the first and
second reading thereof.
FURTHER RESOLVE THAT By -Law 3571 be given third and final reading and the Mayor and
Clerk be and are hereby authorized to sign the same, and place the Corporate Seal thereunto.
"Carried"
/Aft, ROUNDTABLE
ADJOURNMENT
Page 5
MINUTES: Meeting for the Committee "Open Council"
Moved by: Moved by Councillor Klein
Seconded by: Councillor Stephenson AND RESOLVE THAT the meeting be adjourned at 2:52pm.
Approval Received: (1 of 1)
Nicole Wellsbury/Tillsonburg (Friday December 02,
2011 11:40 AM)
Town of Tillsonburg
Page 6