Loading...
171113 Council AGD PacketTable of Contents Agenda 3 Minutes of the Meeting of October 23, 2017 171023 Council MIN 13 Oxford People Against Landfill (OPAL) Group Del Reg OPAL 26 MOTION-Municipalities-Town of Tillsonburg 27 CIP Application 519 Broadway Nelles del 29 FIN 17-33 2017 Third Quarter Financial Results FIN17-33 2017 Third Quarter Financial Results 30 2017 Q3 Consolidated Results 31 FIN 17-34 2017 Third Quarter Finance Department FIN17-34 2017 Third Quarter Finance Department Results 32 Q3 Results - Finance 34 DCS 17-36 - Building, Planning & By-Law Services 2017 Q3 Results THAT Council receives Report DCS 17-36 Building, Planning & By-Law Services 2017 Q3 Results 37 Q3 Financial Summary 42 FRS 17-06 Third Quarter 2017 Fire Department Results FRS 17-06 Third Quarter 2017 Fire Department Results 44 Financial Plan Summary 48 OPS 17-27 2017 Third Quarter Operations Services OPS 17-27 2017 Third Quarter Operations Services 50 OPS 17-27 Attachment 1 - Operating Summaries 53 RCP 17-47 - Recreation Culture and Parks 2017 Q3 Results RCP 17-47 - Recreation Culture and Parks 2017 Q3 Results 64 Memo Re RCP Q2 Results 67 RCP Q3 2017 Financial Summaries 68 CAO 17-05 , 0.5 FTE Increase - Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering 0.5 FTE Increase - Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering 75 0.5 FTE Increase - Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering 77 CAO 17-06, Bonds for Development Securities Bonds for Development Securities 78 CA) 17-06 Attachments 80 CL 17-21 Committee Appointments CL 17-21 Committee Appointment 87 Reg Butcher Appl 88 1 DCS 17-34 - Sign Variance – 360 Quarter Town Line – Simply 360 Residential Development DCS 17-34 - Sign Variance 360 Quarter Town Line Simply 360 Residential Development 90 DCS 17-35 Sign Variance – 180-190 Simcoe Street – Billboard Sign DCS 17-35 Sign Variance 180-190 Simcoe Street Billboard Sign 94 DCS 17-37 International Per Diem Rate Report DCS 17-37 100 OPS 17-28 Parking Improvements at Community Centre OPS 17-28 Parking Improvements at Community Centre 102 OPS 17-28 Attachment 1 - Parks & Recreation Advisory Committee Report 106 RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retrofit at the Tillsonburg Community Centre RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retrofit at the Tillsonburg Community Centre 107 RCP 17-02 - Budget Issue Paper - Utilities Cost Increases 115 TCC Consolidated Scope of Work 118 Example Amortization Schedule from Infrastructure Ontario 123 RCP 17-50 - Visitor Parking Improvements at OPP Station RCP 17-50 - Visitor Parking Improvements at OPP Station 125 Committee Minutes 170912 Fire Strat Planning MIN 128 171005 HBC MIN 130 171012 Airport MIN 132 171017 AAC MIN 137 Long Point Region Conservation Authority Minutes - October 4, 2017 171004 LPRCA MIN 140 Tillsonburg Police Services Board Minutes - September 20, 2017 170920 PSB MIN 146 By-Law 4147, to amend By-Law 3876, Committee Appointments for the Town of Tillsonburg. 4147 To amend By-Law 3876, to Define the Mandate, Membership & Meeting Procedures for Committees 150 Nov 13, 2017 Consolidated Schedule A - Committee Appointment By-Law 151 By-Law 4148, To Confirm the Proceedings of the Council meeting of November 13, 2017. By-law 4148 Confirming Nov 13 156 2 = 1. Call to Order 2. Closed Session Proposed Resolution #1 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council move into Closed Session to consider: 1. a proposed or pending acquisition or disposition of land by the municipality or local board (Access to Memorial Park and TCC). 3. Adoption of Agenda Proposed Resolution #2 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT the Agenda as prepared for the Council meeting of Monday, November 13, 2017 be adopted. 4. Moment of Silence 5. Disclosures of Pecuniary Interest and the General Nature Thereof 6. Adoption of Council Minutes of Previous Meeting 6.1. Minutes of the Meeting of October 23, 2017 171023 Council MIN Proposed Resolution #3 Moved By: Seconded By: The Corporation of the Town of Tillsonburg COUNCIL MEETING Monday, November 13, 2017 6:00 PM Council Chambers 200 Broadway, 2nd Floor AGENDA 3 Council Meeting – Agenda - 2 - THAT the Minutes of the Council Meeting of October 23, 2017 be approved. 7. Delegations and Presentations 7.1. Oxford People Against Landfill (OPAL) Group Presented By: Bryan Smith Del Reg OPAL MOTION-Municipalities-Town of Tillsonburg Proposed Resolution #4 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT the presentation from the Oxford People Against Landfill (OPAL) Group be received, as information. 7.2. CIP Application 519 Broadway Presented By: Dr. Gary Nelles Nelles del Proposed Resolution #5 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT the presentation from Dr. Gary Nelles regarding CIP Application - 519 Broadway be received, as information. 8. Committee Reports & Presentations 9. Public Meetings 10. Planning Applications 11. Information Items 12. Mayor 13. Quarterly Reports 13.1. FIN 17-33 - 2017 Third Quarter Financial Results FIN17-33 2017 Third Quarter Financial Results 4 Council Meeting – Agenda - 3 - 2017 Q3 Consolidated Results Proposed Resolution #6 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report FIN 17-33 2017, Third Quarter Financial Results, as information. 13.2. FIN 17-34 2017 - Third Quarter Finance Department Financial Results FIN17-34 2017 Third Quarter Finance Department Results Q3 Results - Finance Proposed Resolution #7 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report FIN 17-34 2017, 2017 Third Quarter Finance Department Results, as information. 13.3. DCS 17-36 – Third Quarter Building, Planning & By-Law Services Financial Results THAT Council receives Report DCS 17-36 Building, Planning & By-Law Services 2017 Q3 Results Q3 Financial Summary Proposed Resolution #8 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report DCS 17-36, 2017 Third Quarter Building, Planning & By-Law Services Financial Results, as information. 13.4. FRS 17-06 - Third Quarter Fire Department Financial Results FRS 17-06 Third Quarter 2017 Fire Department Results Financial Plan Summary Proposed Resolution #9 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report FRS 17-06, 2017 Third Quarter Fire Department Financial Results, as information. 5 Council Meeting – Agenda - 4 - 13.5. OPS 17-27 2017 Third Quarter Operations Services Financial Results OPS 17-27 2017 Third Quarter Operations Services OPS 17-27 Attachment 1 - Operating Summaries Proposed Resolution #10 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report OPS 17-27, 2017 Third Quarter Operations Services Financial Results, as information. 13.6. RCP 17-47 – Third Quarter Recreation, Culture and Parks Financial Results RCP 17-47 - Recreation Culture and Parks 2017 Q3 Results Memo Re RCP Q2 Results RCP Q3 2017 Financial Summaries Proposed Resolution #11 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report RCP 17-47, 2017 Third Quarter Recreation Culture and Parks Financial Results, as information. 14. Reports from Departments 14.1. Chief Administrative Officer 14.1.1. CAO 17-05 , 0.5 FTE Increase - Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering 0.5 FTE Increase - Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering 0.5 FTE Increase - Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering Proposed Resolution #12 Moved By: Seconded By: That Council receives Report CAO 17-05 0.5 FTE Increase – Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering; AND THAT the Council of the Town of Tillsonburg authorizes the CAO to increase the Town FTE complement by 0.5 to allow for a full-time Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering to be funded by Tillsonburg Hydro Inc. 14.1.2. CAO 17-06, Bonds for Development Securities Bonds for Development Securities CA) 17-06 Attachments 6 Council Meeting – Agenda - 5 - Proposed Resolution #13 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report CAO 17-06 Bonds for Development Securities; AND THAT the Council of Town of Tillsonburg amend the Site Plan Agreement By-Law and Subdivision Agreement to include Bonds as an additional form of financial security for site plan applications and subdivision developments. 14.2. Clerk’s Office 14.2.1. CL 17-21 Committee Appointments CL 17-21 Committee Appointment Reg Butcher Appl Proposed Resolution #14 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report CL 17-21, Committee Appointment; AND THAT Reg Butcher be appointed to the Heritage, Beautification & Cemetery Advisory Committee; AND THAT By-Law 4147, to Amend Schedule A of By-Law 3876, be brought forward for Council consideration. 14.3. Development and Communication Services 14.3.1. DCS 17-34 - Sign Variance – 360 Quarter Town Line – Simply 360 Residential Development DCS 17-34 - Sign Variance 360 Quarter Town Line Simply 360 Residential Development Proposed Resolution #15 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report DCS 17-34 Sign Variance – 360 Quarter Town Line – Simply 360 Residential Development; AND THAT a variance to Sign By-Law 3798 be approved for the construction of a temporary 38 m2 (400 ft2) subdivision promotional banner sign mounted on a trailer located on the East side of Quarter Town Line between Trillium Drive and Southridge Road described as 360 Quarter Town Line (Plan 41M119, LOT 2) with the following conditions: (i) A sign permit is obtained; 7 Council Meeting – Agenda - 6 - (ii) Skirting is installed around the bottom perimeter of the trailer acceptable to Building/By-Law Services; (iii) Signage is maintained as per Sign By-Law 3798, Clean Yard By-Law 3810 and maintained reasonably level; (iv) If the maintenance of the sign becomes derelict in any manner the signage will be ordered to be removed and any replacement signage will be required to be installed as per Sign By- Law 3798. 14.3.2. DCS 17-35 Sign Variance – 180-190 Simcoe Street – Billboard Sign DCS 17-35 Sign Variance 180-190 Simcoe Street Billboard Sign Proposed Resolution #16 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report DCS 17-35 Sign Variance – 180-190 Simcoe Street – Billboard Sign; AND THAT Council not approve the sign variance application request for the placement of a billboard sign noted in Report DCS 17-35 Sign Variance – 180- 190 Simcoe Street – Billboard Sign; AND THAT the signage is removed on or before November 20, 2017. 14.3.3. DCS 17-37 International Per Diem Rate Report DCS 17-37 Proposed Resolution #17 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report DCS 17-37 International Per Diem Rate; AND THAT the Treasury Board Secretariat of Canada’s Meal Per Diem Rate be approved for use for international travel instead of the Town’s standard per diem rate; AND THAT the Town’s Personnel Policy be amended to reflect this change. 14.4. Finance 14.5. Fire and Emergency Services 8 Council Meeting – Agenda - 7 - 14.6. Operations 14.6.1. OPS 17-28 Parking Improvements at Community Centre OPS 17-28 Parking Improvements at Community Centre OPS 17-28 Attachment 1 - Parks & Recreation Advisory Committee Report Proposed Resolution #18 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report OPS 17-28, Parking Improvements at Community Centre; AND THAT the cost estimate of $175,000 associated with enhancing parking at the Tillsonburg Community Centre be referred to the 2018 budget deliberations. 14.7. Recreation, Culture & Park Services 14.7.1. RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retrofit at the Tillsonburg Community Centre RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retrofit at the Tillsonburg Community Centre RCP 17-02 - Budget Issue Paper - Utilities Cost Increases TCC Consolidated Scope of Work Example Amortization Schedule from Infrastructure Ontario Proposed Resolution #19 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Report RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retrofit at the Tillsonburg Community Centre be received; AND THAT Council give 2018 pre-budget approval and authorize staff to proceed with implementing the Energy Retrofit project as designed by I.B. Storey Inc.; AND THAT Council award RFT 2017-011 – Refrigeration to Cimco Refrigeration Division of Toromont Industries at their tendered price of $693,700.00 before taxes; AND THAT Council award RFT 2017-012 – Automation to Trane Sales Agency - N.L. Clarke Sales Ltd. at their tendered price of $76,450.00 before taxes; AND THAT Council award RFT 2017-014 – Electrical Co-Generation to Whitby Hydro Energy Services Corporation at their tendered price of $1,033,585.00 before taxes; 9 Council Meeting – Agenda - 8 - AND THAT Council authorize the Construction Oversight, Commissioning and Turnover & Closeout phases of the contract with I.B. Storey Inc. at a cost not to exceed $99,000; AND THAT pursuant to the Town of Tillsonburg’s Debt Management Policy, the Director of Finance is authorized to place debt to finance the project with the debt servicing costs funded through operational savings (reduced energy consumption) resulting from completing the project; AND THAT in collaboration with Oxford County, the Town commits to complete a community-wide greenhouse gas inventory, targets and plan by April 2019 in order for this project to be eligible for submission to the GHG Challenge fund. 15. Unfinished Business 15.1. RCP 17-50 - Visitor Parking Improvements at OPP Station RCP 17-50 - Visitor Parking Improvements at OPP Station Proposed Resolution #20 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives Report RCP 17-50 - Visitor Parking Improvements at OPP Station; AND THAT the costs associated with implementing additional visitor parking at the OPP Station are considered during the 2018 budget deliberations. 16. Staff Information Reports 17. Committee Minutes & Reports 17.1. Committee Minutes 170912 Fire Strat Planning MIN 171005 HBC MIN 171012 Airport MIN 171017 AAC MIN Proposed Resolution #21 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives the Fire Strategic Planning Committee Minutes dated September 12, 2017; the Heritage, Beautification and Cemetery Advisory 10 Council Meeting – Agenda - 9 - Committee Minutes dated October 5, 2017; the Airport Advisory Committee Minutes dated October 12, 2017; and the Accessibility Advisory Committee Minutes dated October 17, 2017, as information. 17.2. Long Point Region Conservation Authority Minutes - October 4, 2017 171004 LPRCA MIN Proposed Resolution #22 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives the Long Point Region Conservation Authority Board of Directors Minutes dated October 4, 2017, as information. 17.3. Tillsonburg Police Services Board Minutes - September 20, 2017 170920 PSB MIN Proposed Resolution #23 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT Council receives the Tillsonburg Police Services Board Minutes dated September 20, 2017, as information. 18. Notice of Motions 19. Resolutions 20. Resolutions Resulting from Closed Session 21. By-Laws By-Laws from the Meeting of Monday, November 13, 2017 21.1 Proposed Resolution #24 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT By-Law 4147, to amend By-Law 3876, Committee Appointments for the Town of Tillsonburg, Nov 13, 2017 Consolidated Schedule A 11 Council Meeting – Agenda - 10 - be read for a first, second, third and final reading and that the Mayor and the Clerk be and are hereby authorized to sign the same, and place the corporate seal thereunto. 21.2 Proposed Resolution #25 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT By-Law 4148, to Confirm the Proceedings of the Council meeting of November 13, 2017, be read for a first, second, third and final reading and that the Mayor and the Clerk be and are hereby authorized to sign the same, and place the corporate seal thereunto. 22. Items of Public Interest 23. Adjournment Proposed Resolution #26 Moved By: Seconded By: THAT the Council Meeting of Monday, November 13, 2017 be adjourned at _____ p.m. 12 = ATTENDANCE Mayor Stephen Molnar Councillor Max Adam Deputy Mayor Dave Beres Councillor Penny Esseltine Councillor Jim Hayes Councillor Chris Rosehart Councillor Brian Stephenson Staff: Donna Wilson, Town Clerk Dave Rushton, Director of Finance/Treasurer (Attended 4:00 – 5:30pm) Janelle Costantino, Deputy Treasurer Kevin DeLeebeeck, Director of Operations Rick Cox, Director of Recreation, Culture & Parks Jeff Smith, Fire Chief Lana White, Executive Assistant/Deputy Clerk Regrets: David Calder, CAO 1. Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 4:00pm. 2. Adoption of Agenda Resolution #1 Moved By: Councillor Rosehart Seconded By: Councillor Hayes THAT the Agenda as prepared for the Council meeting of Monday, October 23, 2017 be adopted. Carried The Corporation of the Town of Tillsonburg COUNCIL MEETING Monday, October 23, 2017 4:00 PM Council Chambers 200 Broadway, 2nd Floor MINUTES 13 Council Meeting – Minutes - 2 - 3. Moment of Silence 4. Disclosures of Pecuniary Interest and the General Nature Thereof There were no disclosures of pecuniary interest declared. 5. Budget (4:00 – 5:30pm) 5.1. FIN 17-32 Council 2018 Budget Direction FIN 17 - 32 COUNCIL 2018 BUDGET DIRECTION Council provided the following suggestions regarding the capital and operating budgets. It was understood that not all projects can be completed in a single budget year; however this provides staff with a base. Capital Budget  Purchase of a Fire Apparatus  To review increasing size of the proposed outdoor ice pad  To complete parking lot at SW side of Community Centre Complex  It was suggested that we maintain what we have and look at a long term plan for maintaining and updating the Community Centre Complex  To enhance entrances at the community centre in terms of accessibility and aesthetics  To review enhancing the acoustics in the Lions Auditorium  To review increasing access time for the gym  To review adding surveillance cameras at the community centre on all floors  To review enhancing playground equipment in a park which also includes accessible equipment  To review adding a splash pad  To look at extending the CASO trail  To update the library parkette  To review the parkette at Sunbeam Daycare  To coordinate with the County for projects on local infrastructure  To review adding washrooms at Memorial Park  To look at a Town Hall project 14 Council Meeting – Minutes - 3 - Operational Budget  Impact of Bill 148, to provide maximum impact.  Transportation  To review Health Care needs in terms of doctors and walk in clinics  To review removing the leaf pick-up as the transfer stations is now open 6 days a week  To review the customer service model  To review attracting more retail to the community  To review outdoor workers break schedules and efficiencies  To provide enhanced messaging to the public – website, YouTube – to include streaming all council meetings Council also discussed closing and surplusing municipal alleys and offering them to abutting land owners for a minimal price. It was also noted that CPI to be as low as possible. Resolution #2 Moved By: Councillor Rosehart Seconded By: Councillor Hayes THAT Council receives Report FIN 17–32 Council 2018 Budget Direction, as information. Carried Dave Rushton, Director of Finance, left the meeting at 5:30pm. Recess 5:30 – 6:00pm Council reconvened regular session at 6:00pm. 6. Adoption of Council Minutes of Previous Meeting 6.1. Minutes of the Meeting of October 10, 2017 171010 Council MIN Resolution #3 Moved By: Councillor Hayes Seconded By: Councillor Rosehart THAT the Minutes of the Council Meeting of October 10, 2017 be approved. Carried 15 Council Meeting – Minutes - 4 - 7. Delegations and Presentations 7.1. Volunteer Achievement Award - Presentation to Mike Postma 7.2. 2017 Canadian Legion Poppy Campaign Presented By: Don Burton Mr. Burton presented the first poppy of the 2017 Poppy Campaign to Mayor Molnar. 7.3. Senior Centre Activity Update Presented By: Nancy Boutin Senior Delegation Request Nancy Boutin provided an update including membership, grants, programs and activities, the fall fundraiser/concert, and upcoming budget deliberations. Resolution #4 Moved By: Councillor Hayes Seconded By: Councillor Rosehart THAT the Update on Senior Centre Activities for Fall 2017 be received as information. Carried 8. Committee Reports & Presentations 8.1. Canada 150 Committee Events Update Presented By: Jami Stephenson, Committee Chair Jami Stephenson provided an update regarding the Canada 150 Committee events, including the upcoming 1867 concert scheduled for Saturday December 2, the Splash’N Boots concert December 28, and Skating Day December 10. Resolution #5 Moved By: Deputy Mayor Beres Seconded By: Councillor Adam THAT the Canada 150 Committee Events Update, as presented by the Chair of the Canada 150 Committee, be received as information. Carried 16 Council Meeting – Minutes - 5 - Resolution #6 Moved By: Deputy Mayor Beres Seconded By: Councillor Adam THAT Council move into the Committee of Adjustment to hear an application for Minor Variance. Carried 9. Public Meetings 9.1. Application for Minor Variance A-09/17 - Simon Wagler A09-17_rpt Plate 1 Plate 2 Plate 3 Gord Hough, Director of Community Planning, County of Oxford, appeared before Council and presented Report 2017-308. Opportunity was given for Council to ask questions. The applicant was not in attendance. No members of the public appeared in support of, or in opposition to, the application. It was noted that the comments section of the report contained no recognized concerns from the public. Council passed the following resolution. Resolution #7 Moved By: Councillor Adam Seconded By: Deputy Mayor Beres THAT the Tillsonburg Committee of Adjustment approves Application File A-09/17, submitted by Simon Wagler, for lands described as Part Lots 17 & 18, Plan 41M-139, Part 7 of 41R-5498, Town of Tillsonburg, as it relates to: 1. Relief from Section 6.2, Table 6.2 – Zone Provisions, to increase the maximum permitted lot coverage of an ‘R1’ zoned lot from 33% to 35.3% of the lot area; and, 2. Relief from Section 6.2, Table 6.2 – Zone Provisions, to reduce the minimum required rear yard depth from 12 m (39.3 ft) to 10.4 m (34.1 ft), to facilitate the construction of a single detached dwelling, 17 Council Meeting – Minutes - 6 - subject to the condition that a building permit for the proposed dwelling shall be issued within one year of the date of the Committee's decision. Carried Resolution #8 Moved By: Councillor Adam Seconded By: Deputy Mayor Beres THAT Council move out of the Committee of Adjustment and move back into regular Council session. Carried 10. Planning Applications 10.1. OPS 17-10-3, Application to Amend the Official Plan to Permit Connection to the Town Sanitary Collection System (124631 Simcoe St.) OP17-10-3 Briefing Note Gord Hough, Director of Community Planning, County of Oxford, appeared before Council and presented Report OP17-10-3. It was noted that the application was circulated to the Township of Norwich, with no comments back yet. The application will be deliberated at the County level in early November. Council passed the following resolution. Resolution #9 Moved By: Councillor Esseltine Seconded By: Councillor Stephenson THAT Council supports the exemption to the County Official Plan to permit the connection of an existing residential property located at 124631 Simcoe Street, outside of the Tillsonburg settlement boundary to the municipal sanitary collection system. Carried 11. Information Items 12. Mayor 13. Quarterly Reports 18 Council Meeting – Minutes - 7 - 14. Reports from Departments 14.1. Chief Administrative Officer 14.2. Clerk’s Office 14.3. Development and Communication Services 14.3.1. DCS 17-31 Community Improvement Plan Application – 519 Broadway Report DCS 17-31 CIP Application Cephas Panschow, Development Commissioner, was in attendance to answer questions. Resolution #10 Moved By: Councillor Esseltine Seconded By: Councillor Stephenson THAT Council receive Report DCS 17-31 Community Improvement Plan Application – 519 Broadway; AND THAT the 519 Broadway property be approved for the Tax Increment Grant Back Program of the Community Improvement Plan, related to enhancements of the property, at the High Level, which offers the following growth related rebates: • Years 1 to 6 - 50% rebate of the incremental tax increase • Year 7 - 40% rebate • Year 8 - 30% rebate • Year 9 - 20% rebate • Year 10 - 10% rebate with full property taxes being payable in 2028. Carried 14.3.2. DCS 17-32 Community Improvement Plan Application – 136 Broadway Report DCS 17-32 CIP Application Cephas Panschow, Development Commissioner, was in attendance to answer questions. Proposed Resolution #11 Moved By: Councillor Stephenson Seconded By: Councillor Esseltine 19 Council Meeting – Minutes - 8 - THAT Council receives Report DCS 17-32 Community Improvement Plan Application – 136 Broadway; AND THAT the 136 Broadway property be approved for the Tax Increment Grant Back Program of the Community Improvement Plan, related to enhancements of the property, at the High Level, which offers the following growth related rebates: • Years 1 to 6 - 50% rebate of the incremental tax increase • Year 7 - 40% rebate • Year 8 - 30% rebate • Year 9 - 20% rebate • Year 10 - 10% rebate with full property taxes being payable in 2028. Carried 14.4. Finance 14.5. Fire and Emergency Services 14.5.1. FRS 17-05 Huron-Kinloss Fire Communications Contract FRS 17-05 Fire Communications Huron Kinloss H-K Agreement 2017 H-K By-law 2017-100 Resolution#12 Moved By: Councillor Stephenson Seconded By: Councillor Esseltine THAT Council receives report FRS 17-05 Huron Kinloss Fire Communications Contract; AND THAT the capital costs incurred be debt financed with a term not to exceed five (5) years; AND FURTHER THAT By-Law 4144 to authorize an agreement between the Town and the Township of Huron-Kinloss for the provision of Fire Dispatch and Communications Services be brought forward for Council consideration. Carried 14.6. Operations 14.6.1. OPS 17-26 Connecting Link Funding Program Designated Project OPS 17-26 Connecting Link Funding Program Designated Project 20 Council Meeting – Minutes - 9 - OPS 17-26 Attachment 1 - Connecting Link Funding Application Resolution #13 Moved By: Councillor Stephenson Seconded By: Councillor Esseltine THAT Council receives Report OPS 17-26, Connecting Link Funding Program Designated Project; AND THAT Broadway Street Rehabilitation from the north Town limit to the approach lanes south of the North Street intersection be endorsed as the Town’s project for the Connecting Link Funding Application; AND THAT the submitted Application meets the requirements of MTO’s Connecting Links Program as described in the Program Guide; AND THAT a comprehensive Asset Management Plan including connecting links has been completed and publically posted; AND THAT the municipality will comply with the conditions that apply to designated connecting links under the Ontario Highway Traffic Act to ensure the safe and efficient movement of provincial traffic; AND THAT the Application is complete and factually accurate; AND THAT the Chief Administrative Officer be authorized to execute the declaration statement within the formal application; AND THAT the funding source of increased construction costs in the amount $15,500 be referred to the 2018 budget deliberations. Carried 14.7. Recreation, Culture & Park Services 14.7.1. RCP 17-44 – July-September 2017 RCP Departmental Activity Reports RCP 17-44 - July-September 2017 RCP Departmental Activity Reports Jul-Sep 2017 Activity - Recreation Programs & Services Jul-Sep 2017 Activity - Culture & Heritage Jul-Sep 2017 Activity - Parks & Facilities Resolution #14 Moved By: Councillor Rosehart Seconded By: Councillor Hayes THAT Council receives Report RCP 17-44 – July-September 2017 RCP Departmental Activity Reports, as information. Carried 21 Council Meeting – Minutes - 10 - 14.7.2. RCP 17-46 – Senior Centre Software Agreement RCP 17-46 - Senior Centre Software Agreement Resolution #15 Moved By: Councillor Hayes Seconded By: Councillor Rosehart THAT Council receives Report RCP 17-46 – Senior Centre Software Agreement, as information; AND THAT Council authorizes staff to adjust the 2018 Transfer Payment authorized under the Memorandum of Agreement to offset the annual cost of two seat licenses for new recreation management software; AND THAT Council authorizes staff to adjust the 2019 Transfer Payment authorized under the Memorandum of Agreement to offset the annual cost of one seat license; AND THAT Council directs staff, in consultation with the Senior Centre Board of Directors, to prepare and bring forward an updated Memorandum of Agreement for Council’s consideration prior to the end of May, 2018. Carried 14.7.3. RCP 17-49 – Enhanced Beautification – Program Summary RCP 17-49 - Enhanced Beautification - Program Summary RCP 17-17 - Enhanced Beautification Program - Updated Resolution #16 Moved By: Councillor Hayes Seconded By: Councillor Rosehart THAT Council receives Report RCP 17-49 – Enhanced Beautification – Program Summary, as information. Carried 14.7.4. RCP 17-45 – Proposed Gibson House Boathouse and Deck RCP 17-45 - Proposed Gibson House Boathouse and Deck Boathouse sketch The vision is to achieve something that would provide storage as well as some level of enhancement to others in the community. 22 Council Meeting – Minutes - 11 - It was suggested that the Tillsonburg Scout Association contact other groups including the Lake Lisgar Revitalization Project Committee to determine if partnerships can be achieved to help fund and complete a project at Gibson House. This item to come back to Council through budget process. Resolution #17 amended resolution Moved By: Deputy Mayor Beres Seconded By: Councillor Adam THAT Council receives Report RCP 17-45 – Proposed Gibson House Boathouse and Deck, as information. Carried 15. Unfinished Business 16. Staff Information Reports 17. Committee Minutes & Reports 17.1. Committee Minutes 170724 Mem Park MIN 170919 Mem Park MIN 170905 Special Awards MIN 171005 Museum MIN 171016 Canada 150 MIN Resolution #18 Moved By: Deputy Mayor Beres Seconded By: Councillor Adam THAT Council receives the Memorial Park Revitalization Committee Minutes dated July 24 and September 18, 2017; the Special Awards Committee Minutes dated September 5, 2017; the Museum Advisory Committee Minutes dated October 5, 2017; and the Canada 150 Committee Minutes dated September 17, 2017, as information. Carried 23 Council Meeting – Minutes - 12 - 17.2. Long Point Region Conservation Authority Minutes 170906 LPRCA Resolution #19 Moved By: Councillor Adam Seconded By: Deputy Mayor Beres THAT Council receives the Minutes of the Long Point Region Conservation Authority Board of Directors Meeting dated September 6, 2017, as information. Carried 18. Notice of Motions 19. Resolutions 20. Resolutions Resulting from Closed Session 21. By-Laws By-Laws from the Meeting of Monday, October 23, 2017 Resolution #20 Moved By: Seconded By: 21.1. THAT By-Law 4144, To authorize an agreement between The Town and Huron- Kinloss for the provision of fire dispatch and communications services be read for a first, second and third and final reading and that the Mayor and the Clerk be and are hereby authorized to sign the same, and place the corporate seal thereunto. Carried Resolution #21 Moved By: Councillor Esseltine Seconded By: Councillor Stephenson 21.2 THAT By-Law 4145, To Confirm the Proceedings of the Council Meeting of October 23, 2017 be read for a first, second, third and final reading and that the Mayor and the Clerk be and are hereby authorized to sign the same and place the corporate seal thereunto. Carried 24 Council Meeting – Minutes - 13 - 22. Items of Public Interest The Yard Waste Depot at the Transfer Station is open 6 days a week 9am to 5pm. The Large Item Depot at the Transfer Station is now open all day Saturday 9am to 5pm. Loose leaf collection is scheduled to begin Monday, November 6. Additional information regarding the Transfer Station and leave collection is available on the Town’s website. The winter overnight parking restriction between 2am to 6am is effective from November 15 to March 31. 23. Adjournment Resolution #22 Moved By: Councillor Esseltine Seconded By: Councillor Stephenson THAT the Council Meeting of Monday, October 23, 2017 be adjourned at 8:13 p.m. Carried 25 26 MOTION COUNCIL FOR THE TOWN OF TILLSONBURG MUNICIPALITIES CALL ON PROVINCE FOR “RIGHT TO APPROVE” LANDFILL DEVELOPMENTS WHEREAS municipal governments in Ontario do not have the right to approve landfill projects in their communities, but have authority for making decisions on all other types of development; AND WHEREAS this out-dated policy allows private landfill operators to consult with local residents and municipal Councils, but essentially ignore them; AND WHEREAS proposed Ontario legislation (Bill 139) will grant municipalities additional authority and autonomy to make decisions for their communities; AND WHEREAS municipalities already have exclusive rights for approving casinos and nuclear waste facilities within their communities, AND FURTHER that the province has recognized the value of municipal approval for the siting of power generation facilities; AND WHEREAS the recent report from Ontario’s Environmental Commissioner has found that Ontario has a garbage problem, particularly from Industrial, Commercial and Institutional (ICI) waste generated within the City of Toronto, where diversion rates are as low as 15%; AND UNLESS significant efforts are made to increase recycling and diversion rates, a new home for this Toronto garbage will need to be found, as landfill space is filling up quickly; AND WHEREAS municipalities across Ontario are quietly being identified and targeted as potential landfill sites for future Toronto garbage by private landfill operators; AND WHEREAS other communities should not be forced to take Toronto waste, as landfills can contaminate local watersheds, air quality, dramatically increase heavy truck traffic on community roads, and reduce the quality of life for local residents; AND WHEREAS municipalities should be considered experts in waste management, as they are responsible for this within their own communities, and often have decades’ worth of in-house expertise in managing waste, recycling, and diversion programs; 27 AND WHEREAS municipalities should have the exclusive right to approve or reject these projects, and assess whether the potential economic benefits are of sufficient value to offset any negative impacts and environmental concerns; THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT the Town of Tillsonburg calls upon the Government of Ontario, and all political parties, to formally grant municipalities the authority to approve landfill projects in or adjacent to their communities, prior to June 2018; AND THAT in the case of a two-tier municipality, the approval be required at both the upper-tier and affected lower-tier municipalities; AND FURTHER THAT the Town of Tillsonburg encourage all other municipalities in Ontario to consider this motion calling for immediate provincial action. 28 29 Report Title 2017 Third Quarter Financial Results Report No. FIN 17-33 Author JANELLE COSTANTINO Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date NOVEMBER 13, 2017 Attachments 2017 Q3 Consolidated Results Page 1 / 1 FIN17-33 2017 Third Quarter Financial Re RECOMMENDATION THAT Council receives report FIN 17-33 2017 Third Quarter Financial Results as information. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY To provide Council with the January 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017 Town wide actual financial results. SUMMARY OF OPERATIONAL RESULTS The attached spreadsheet summarizes by department the variances between 2017 actual results for the quarter ending September 30, 2017 and the 2017 YTD budget. The Q3 results show an overall Town wide consolidated 2017 surplus of $644,509, however, the Town’s projected surplus is $229,800. The differences are due to timing of when revenues and expenditures are budgeted and posted to the Town’s general ledger. Questions or comments relative to the departmental 2017 Q3 revenues and expenditures should be referred to the other members of the Senior Leadership Team for commentary. 30 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Levy, PILS (14,295,573) (14,267,754) 27,819 0% Grants (284,726) (291,178) (6,452)2% User Charges (3,889,458) (3,801,184) 88,274 2% Other Revenue (55,400) (58,230) (2,830)5% Specified Revenue - (280,819) (280,819)100% Contribution from Reserves - (264,138) (264,138)100% Total Revenues (18,525,157) (18,963,303) (438,146)0 - Expenditures Labour 6,610,447 6,312,604 (297,843)5% Purchases 3,254,537 2,970,988 (283,549)9% Contracted Services 3,238,227 3,083,824 (154,403)5% Contribution to Reserves 190,025 727,743 537,718 283% Interfunctional Adjustments 303,330 295,720 (7,610)3% Debt Principal & Interest 847,857 847,181 (676)0% Total Expenditures 14,444,423 14,238,060 (206,363) Total Net Levy (4,080,734) (4,725,243) (644,509) 31 Report Title 2017 Third Quarter Finance Department Results Report No. FIN 17-34 Author JANELLE COSTANTINO Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date NOVEMBER 13, 2017 Attachments Q3 Results - Finance Page 1 / 2 FIN17-34 2017 Third Quarter Finance Depa Results RECOMMENDATION THAT Council receives report FIN 17-34 2017 Third Quarter Finance Department results as information. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY To provide Council with the actual January 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017 Finance Department financial results and the projected Finance Department 2017 financial results. SUMMARY OF OPERATIONAL RESULTS 2017 Business Objectives Objective Target Date Status Monthly reporting to Management Q2 In progress; to be implemented once PO software is in place – anticipated to begin January 2018 Debt Policy Q2 Completed Reserve Policy Q2 Completed Replace computers Q2 Completed Website shopping cart Q2 In testing phase – to be launched in Q4 Purchase Order Software Q2 In progress – go live date of November 9th Customer Service Delivery Model Q2 Anticipated completion in Q4 Replace Server Q3 Deferred to 2018 Telephone System Replacement Q3 In progress at County; anticipated completion in Q4 Tax e-bill software Q3 Software installed; marketing to commence Cash Forecasting Model Development Q4 Investigate The One Investment Program Q4 Completed Contribution to Reserves – Future IT Q4 Completed Great Plains Point of Sale/CLASS replacement Q4 In progress Develop plan/implement departmental overhead costs for IT Q4 Completed 32 Page 2 / 2 2017 Third Quarter Finance Department Results Contribution to Reserves - Records management storage Q4 Completed Local Government Week Q4 Completed Increase customer transactions on website Ongoing In progress – website shopping cart anticipated to help increase transactions Additional Information Objective Target Date Status Move from Cheque to EFT Payments Q3 Implemented EFTs as of September 30 with the hope of having the majority of invoices being paid by EFT by December 31, 2017. Audited financial statements Q2 Completed Key Indicators 09/30/2017 09/30/2016 Tax Receivables $6,127,870 $6,515,328 Accounts Receivable $ 387,956 $249,990 Increase in AR is due to timing of billing of Airport Land rental. In 2016, invoices were billed in two installments while in 2017 invoice was billed in its entirety with the1st installment due in Q2 and the second in Q4 2017. GOALS FOR Q4 2017 • 2018 budgets and business plans FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE The 2017 third quarter Finance Department surplus is $165,958. This is broken down as follows: Department 100 – Council (2,657) Department 110 - Finance 155,852 Department 120 - Customer Service 12,763 $ 165,958 The Finance department is expecting a surplus of approximately $50,000 due to fewer legal and consulting fees than anticipated. Customer service is expecting a surplus of approximately $6,000 due to higher water volume revenues. Details on major variances can be found in the attached Q3 results spreadsheet. 33 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Total Revenues - - - - Expenditures Labour 119,259 119,573 314 0% Purchases 137,850 140,197 2,347 2% Contribution to Reserves 10,000 10,000 -0% Interfunctional Adjustments 18,301 18,297 (4)0% Total Expenditures 285,410 288,067 2,657 Total Net Levy 285,410 288,067 2,657 34 2017 2017 Actual %Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Grants (232,700) (231,473) 1,227 1% User Charges (28,150) (27,938) 212 1% Other Revenue (7,250) (13,951) (6,701)92%1 Specified Revenue - (6,287) (6,287)100%2 Contribution from Reserves - (254,138) (254,138)100%3 Total Revenues (268,100) (533,787) (265,687)99%0 Expenditures Labour 942,549 923,466 (19,083)2% Purchases 345,181 330,270 (14,911)4% Contracted Services 337,899 221,274 (116,625)35%4 Contribution to Reserves 100,400 360,854 260,454 259% Interfunctional Adjustments (305,474) (305,478) (4)0% Debt Principal & Interest 83,329 83,333 4 0% Total Expenditures 1,503,884 1,613,719 109,835 7%0 Total Net Levy 1,235,784 1,079,932 (155,852)13%0 Notes 1 Interest revenue 2 Development charge revenue 3 Prior year surplus $254,138 4 Legal/Auditing/Consultant Exp under $44,100; Equipment Maintenance Contract Exp under $62,200 ; Subcontractor Expense under $10,300- timing 35 2017 2017 Actual %Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (201,575) (207,420) (5,845)3% Other Revenue - (209) (209)100% Total Revenues (201,575) (207,629) (6,054)3% Expenditures Labour 335,819 346,423 10,604 3% Purchases 75,970 69,792 (6,178)8%1 Contracted Services 13,500 10,653 (2,847)21% Interfunctional Adjustments (179,100) (187,388) (8,288)5%2 Debt Principal & Interest 1,491 1,491 -0% Total Expenditures 247,680 240,971 (6,709)3% Total Net Levy 46,105 33,342 (12,763)28% Notes 1 Equipmental rental and supplies expense under $4,900 2 Additional gain on the Water billing contract 36 Report Title Building, Planning & By-Law Services 2017 Q3 Results Report No. DCS 17-36 Author Geno Vanhaelewyn, Chief Building Official Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date NOVEMBER 13, 2017 Attachments N/A RECOMMENDATION THAT Council receives Report DCS 17-36 Building, Planning & By-Law Services 2017 Q3 Results as information. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This report contains information on activity volumes, trends over time, financials and updates on major initiatives. The statistics provided are inclusive from January 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017. BUILDING SERVICES Building Services recorded a slight increase in the number of permits issued, however, experienced a slight decrease in total value of construction compared to 2016. The slight reduction in total value of construction was a result of reduced activity in the commercial and industrial sectors. The residential sector remains strong although a slight decrease in the value of construction was recorded. These statistics are noted in the tables below. 2017 – Building Permit Activity Overview - Q3 ending (Jan 1/17 – Sept 30/17) Total Permits Issued 351 Total Construction Value $19,323,478 Total Permit Revenue $246,789 37 2 CAO VALUE OF CONSTRUCTION COMPARISON Value of Construction Comparisons (Jan 1/17 – Sept 30/17) TYPE 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Residential (Value) 12,007,013 8,154,687 9,579,435 11,490,650 10,324,893 18,157,198 17,016,615 Commercial (Value) 1,158,835 7,008,100 1,298,772 1,108,797 684,728 4,044,397 1,271,159 Industrial (Value) 2,719,100 421,000 3,347,100 1,477,900 272,600 2,102,500 488,804 Institutional (Value) 107,867 215,350 917,675 17,605,392 1,379,173 75,114 546,900 TOTAL 15,992,815 15,799,137 15,142,982 31,682,739 12,661,394 24,379,209 19,323,478 RESIDENTIAL $17,016,615 INSTITUTIONAL $546,900 COMMERCIAL 1,271,159 INDUSTRIAL $488,804 38 3 CAO Number of Permits Issued (Jan 1/17 – Sept 30/17) TYPE 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 Single Detached Dwellings 40 41 44 55 39 84 64 Total Dwelling Units 116 44 47 58 62 84 70 Total All Permits 250 242 257 309 220 341 351 Residential Development DEVELOPER NUMBER OF SINGLE DETACHED DWELLINGS Hayhoe Homes –Glendale West/Brookside 21 PK Construction – Baldwin Place/Brookside 19 Riviera Homes – Victoria Wood 1 Landmark Homes – Oak Park - William Street 2 Bamford Homes – South Ridge Heights 6 Oxford Builders – Annandale Phase 7 5 Gentrac Homes – Wood Haven 1 Misc./Private 9 Inspection Activity Comparisons (Jan 1/17 – Sept 30/17) Output Measures/Activity Quantity 2014 Quantity 2015 Quantity 2016 Quantity 2017 Building Inspections Completed 1036 990 1219 1704 Major Construction/Development Projects: • 230 Lisgar – Lisgar Plaza – Renovation • 142 Maple Lane- Fourplex • 131/133 Tillson Ave – Automotive Shop • 183 Tillson – Tillsonburg Rentals - Renovation • 268 Tillson Ave – Rona – Storage Building • 2 Clearview Dr - Mini Storage Building • 95 Spruce – Inovata Foods - Addition • Andrew’s Crossing – residential development Building Financial Impact Financial records indicate that the Building sector has a deficit of $4,820 at the end of Q3. The decrease in value of construction is a direct result of the decrease in revenue found in the financial records. The forecast for year end is to be on budget. 39 4 CAO PLANNING SERVICES 2017 – Planning Activity Output Measures/Activity 2014 2015 2016 2017 Minor Variance Applications 9 12 12 8 Zone Change Application 11 6 6 11 Site Plan Formal Consultations 2 7 4 5 Site Plan Approvals 4 6 10 3 Site Plan Applications (in progress) 4 5 5 5 Subdivision Agreements 1 2 4 2 Subdivision Amendment Agreements 1 1 1 0 Draft Plan of Subdivision Approval Ext 2 0 2 2 Site Plan Applications (in progress) • 360 Quarter Town Line- Simply 360 Carefree Living • 253 Broadway – Commercial/Residential • 20 Vance Drive - Tillsonburg Custom Foods • 83 Rolph Street – Shane Curtis (Rolph Street Public School) • 3 John Pound Road – John Pound Road Residential Development BY-LAW SERVICES Records indicate that by-law and property standard activities and occurrences are fairly consistent with the previous year. These activities are noted in the tables below. 2017 – By-Law Activity (Jan 1/17 – Sept 30/17) Output Measures– Quantity 2014 2015 2016 2017 Parking Tickets Issued 335 427 611 440 Animal Tags Issued Cats 972 1046 1221 1023 Dogs 2110 2145 2100 2261 Enforcement – Complaints and Occurrences Parking, Noise, Garbage, Taxi 105 121 87 107 Property Stds, Zoning, Clean Yard, Sign, Fence, etc. 163 205 245 283 Animal Control 334 312 273 262 By-Law Financial Impact 40 5 CAO Financial records indicate that the By-Law sector has a surplus of $24,292 at the end of Q3. The surplus is a result of increased revenue and savings from the Animal Control contract. The forecast for year end is to be under budget. DEPARTMENTAL TASKS Q3 misc. tasks/projects: • Open Permit Project – closed 168 open permits • Property File Scan Project • Building Inspector orientation/training • 2017 Façade Improvement Program – ongoing • Departmental website content review - ongoing • Review animal licence tracking solution – ongoing • Planning presentation - Tillsonburg District Real Estate Board • Central Area Design Study review - ongoing The fourth quarter will continue to keep staff busy with increased development/construction activity, 2018 budget and the ongoing departmental projects noted above. 41 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (64,924) (75,489) (10,565)16%1 Total Revenues (64,924) (75,489) (10,565)16% 0% Expenditures Labour 165,924 165,076 (848)1% Purchases 15,325 7,706 (7,619)50%2 Contracted Services 26,249 10,433 (15,816)60%3 Interfunctional Adjustments 21,375 21,366 (9)0% Total Expenditures 228,873 204,581 (24,292)11% Total Net Levy 163,949 129,092 (34,857)21% 0 Notes 1 Bylaw enforcement revenue over $4,900; Licence fee revenue over $4,900 2 Supplies under $7,600 3 Subcontractor Exp under $15,800 - Animal Control 42 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (276,550) (268,570) 7,980 3% Total Revenues (276,550) (268,570) 7,980 3% 0% Expenditures Labour 224,691 231,209 6,518 3% Purchases 27,872 24,520 (3,352)12% Contracted Services 6,500 8,154 1,654 25% Interfunctional Adjustments 24,300 24,300 -0% Total Expenditures 283,363 288,183 4,820 2% Total Net Levy 6,813 19,613 12,800 188% 0 Notes 43 Report Title Third report 2017 Department Results Report No. FRS 17-06 Third Quarter Results Author Jeff Smith Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date November 13, 2017 Attachments • Financial Plan Summary (Fire and Police) Page 1 / 4 RECOMMENDATION THAT Report FRS 17-06 Third Quarter 2017 Department Results be received for information. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY To provide Council with the July 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017 Fire & Rescue Services performance results. SUMMARY OF OPERATIONAL RESULTS 2017 Business Objectives Objective Target Date Status Bunker Gear Decontamination Q3 PO Issued, install scheduled Gas Detection & Air Monitoring Q3 PO Issued Low Angle Rescue Q2 Quotes being received Fire Comm Infrastructure Reserve Q4 Incomplete Traffic Signal Priority Control System Q3 Incomplete Auto Extrication Equipment Q3 PO issued SCBA Reserve Contribution Q4 Incomplete Live Fire Training Simulator Q3 Quotes received (PO to be issued Q4) Fire Ground Equipment Q2 Complete Strategic Planning Committee Ongoing Committee Work Progressing Succession Management Ongoing Reservist Program depleted. Hiring program being scheduled. Needs Assessment for Ladder 4 Q4 Complete (2018 Budget process) Fire Comm Customer Development Ongoing CEMP Update Q3 Incomplete Fire Underwriters Survey Q1 Complete – awaiting report release from FUS 44 Page 2 / 4 Key Indicators 21 Firefighters on average attended training exercises with an average participation rate of 79%. The year to date average is 22 Firefighters attending an average of 80% of training exercises. The Average firefighter, year to date, has attended 71% of “Platoon” calls and 57% of “All Calls”. Fire Suppression Division emergency calls to end of Q3 are 12% above than the same period last year and 12% above than the three year call volume average for the same period. 2017 Alarm Data (Year to Date) OFM Response Type Total Incidents Total Staff Hours Property Fires/Explosions 17 207 Overpressure Rupture/Explosion (No Fire) 7 94 Pre Fire Conditions/ No Fire 32 224 False Fire Calls 47 274 Carbon Monoxide False Calls 30 144 Public Hazard 16 181 Rescue 35 157 Medical/Resuscitator Call 15 57 Other Response 18 212 YTD 217 1550 2017 Dollar Loss / Loss Prevention Number of Property Fire Incidents Estimated Property Value at Risk Estimated Structure Fire Loss Estimated Content Fire Loss Property Fire Loss Prevented Q1 1 $3,165,000 $0 $0 $3,165,000 Q2 6 $6,905,000 $6000 $1200 $6,897,800 Q3 2 $992,000 $1000 $5000 $986,000 Q4 Year to Date Total Fire Loss (structure & contents): $13,200 Fire Prevention Inspections 3rd Quarter 2017 Year to Date Assigned 5 22 In Progress 1 2 Follow Up 0 1 Legal Action 0 0 Rescinded 0 0 Closed 7 25 45 Page 3 / 4 Apparatus Utilization Apparatus 2017 3rd Quarter 2017 Year to Date 2016 3rd Quarter 2016 Year End Car 1 10 30 20 63 Car 2 22 52 19 87 Pumper 1 65 158 28 109 Pumper 2 21 77 52 161 Rescue 3 34 84 67 94 Ladder 4 32 109 117 142 Public Education Types 2017 3rd Quarter 2017 Year to Date 2016 3rd Quarter 2016 Year End Station Tours 2 4 6 7 Presentations 6 14 10 20 Newspaper/Media 0 2 0 4 Charity Event 3 4 2 4 Fire Communication Report Town of Tillsonburg Calls 2017 2ND Quarter On Call Called Out 2017 YTD On Call Called Out YTD Customer Service 254 N/A 898 N/A OPP 26 N/A 89 N/A WORKS 26 6 84 34 HYDRO 56 15 431 68 WATER 19 5 91 28 KENNEL 8 3 21 11 Tillsonburg Fire 2017 3rd Quarter 2017 YTD Administration Lines 92 411 Emergency Calls 211 521 Non Emergent Calls 324 847 Side Door 88 377 Fire Incidents 84 217 Fire Comm 2017 3rd Quarter 2017 YTD Emergency Calls 1428 4216 Non Emergent Calls 2145 6849 Fire Incidents 692 1841 46 Page 4 / 4 FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE Fire & Rescue Service is currently $55,281under budget. Development Charge revenue is $33,947 over budget. Supplies are $16,800 under budget. Police Services is $11,716 over budget. Full time labour is $14,100 over budget due to coverage for medical leave. The financial forecast for Fire & Rescue Services through to December 31, 2017 is to be on budget. The financial forecast for Police Services is to be $11,750 over budget through to December 31, 2017. 47 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (249,440) (245,502) 3,938 2% Specified Revenue - (33,947) (33,947)100%1 Total Revenues (249,440) (279,449) (30,009)12% Expenditures Labour 733,279 726,448 (6,831)1% Purchases 169,551 131,541 (38,010)22%2 Contracted Services 65,324 51,088 (14,236)22%3 Contribution to Reserves - 33,947 33,947 100%1 Interfunctional Adjustments 139,725 139,689 (36)0% Debt Principal & Interest 10,404 10,298 (106)1% Total Expenditures 1,118,283 1,093,011 (25,272)2% Total Net Levy 868,843 813,562 (55,281)6% 0 Notes 1 Development charge revenue 2 3 Subcontractor Expense under $12,200 Supplies under $16,800; Training under $13,100 48 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Grants (3,000) (2,963) 37 1% User Charges (240,300) (237,242) 3,058 1% Specified Revenue - (3) (3)100% Total Revenues (243,300) (240,208) 3,092 1% Expenditures Labour 77,927 92,048 14,121 18%1 Purchases 58,452 61,523 3,071 5% Contracted Services 2,302,349 2,293,774 (8,575)0% Contribution to Reserves - 3 3 100% Interfunctional Adjustments 6,449 6,453 4 0% Total Expenditures 2,445,177 2,453,801 8,624 35% Total Net Levy 2,201,877 2,213,593 11,716 1% Notes 1 FT labour over $14,100 - CSR coverage for sick leave 49 Report Title 2017 Third Quarter Operations Services Report No. OPS 17-27 Author Kevin De Leebeeck, P.Eng. Director of Operations Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date November 13, 2017 Attachments • Operating Summaries Page 1 / 3 RECOMMENDATION: THAT Council receive Report OPS 17-27, 2017 Third Quarter Operations Services as information. SUMMARY To provide Council with the January 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017 Operations Services financial results. Table 1: 2017 Operations Business Plan Objective Target Project Status Continue H&S policy and procedure update/revisions for the Department Q1 – Q4 In Progress Review of Public Works and Engineering policies, procedures and records management Q1 – Q4 In Progress Review and renegotiations of Solid Waste and Recycling Agreement with Oxford County Q3/Q4 Not Started Complete Winter Maintenance Review and associated Winter Operations Plan Q3 Delayed Update Engineering Design Criteria to current industry standards & practices Q3 Delayed Revise Subdivision & Site Plan Guidelines for improved communication with development community Q4 Delayed Asset Management Q1 – Q4  Develop AMP policy and procedures Delayed  Bridge & Culvert Management Strategy Completed  Expand Streetlight Inventory Attribute Data In Progress LED Streetlight Conversion Business Case Q3/Q4 In Progress Broadway Mid-Block (Town Centre Mall) Audible and Accessibility Upgrades Q2 In Progress Broadway & Glendale Pedestrian Crossing Cont’d Q3 In Progress Broadway & Oxford Intersection Audible & Accessibility Upgrades Q2/Q3 In Progress 50 Page 2 / 3 OSIM Biennial Bridge & Culvert Inspections (O.Reg. 104/97) Q3 Completed Quarter Town Line Corridor Management Q2/Q3 In Progress Transfer Station Improvements Cont’d Q3 Completed Airport Self-Serve Fuelling Conversion Q2 Completed Airport Main Runway Crack Sealing Q3 Completed Paget & Rolling Meadows Drain Rehabilitation Q3/Q4 In Progress North Street Sidewalk – Phase C (Oxford County Rd 20) Q3/Q4 In Progress Potters Road Sidewalk (Oxford County Rd 37) Q3/Q4 In Progress Newell Road Reconstruction Q3/Q4 Completed Riverview Reconstruction – Stage 2 of 2 Q2/Q3 Substantially Completed Broadway Connecting Link Rehabilitation – Town limit to North St. Q3/Q4 Funding Request Unsuccessful Asphalt Resurfacing Program Q3/Q4 Completed Light Duty Vehicle Replacements  Facilities Unit # 29 – 2003 Pickup Truck Q2 Completed  Roads Unit # 25 – 2007 Pickup Truck Q3 Completed Medium Duty Vehicle Replacements  Fleet Unit #42 – 1990 Service Truck Q4 In Progress  Water Unit #44 – 2008 Service Truck Q4 In Progress  Hydro Unit #41 – 2003 Utility Truck Q4 Not Started Heavy Duty Vehicle Replacements  Roads Unit #64 – Snowplow Truck Q4 In Progress  Hydro Unit #74 – Cable Truck Q4 Not Started Off Road Equipment Replacements  Roads Unit #83 – 2008 Sidewalk Machine Q3 In Progress  Roads Unit #85 – 2009 Street Sweeper Q4 Bid Request Issued  Parks Unit #89 Upgrade – 2000 55hp Tractor Q2 Completed Key indicators measure growth in terms of infrastructure i.e. Roads, Sewers, Watermain, Sidewalk, Boulevards, etc. and the associated maintenance level of service. No additional resources have been allocated to meet the increased growth demonstrates the Towns ability to mitigate the associated incremental costs to maintain the additional infrastructure. Key Indicators 2016 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 Roads (Lane km) 229.4 226.8 226.1 225.5 224.5 220.1 Sidewalks (km) 92.4 89.8 87.7 87.3 86.3 83.1 51 Page 3 / 3 GOALS FOR NEXT QUARTER • Complete remaining infrastructure capital projects • Implement traffic management capital initiatives • Continue H&S, Records Management and LED streetlight conversion • Commence pre-winter fleet maintenance activities • Prepare, train and perform winter maintenance activities • Data gathering and surveying of future infrastructure capital projects FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE The consolidated 2017 Q3 Operations Services overall variance is summarized in Table 2. Table 2: Third Quarter Budget vs. Actual Variance Summary Department (Surplus) / Deficit Operations Administration (5,815) Engineering Services (40,256) Public Works (102,583) Airport Operations (17,062) Waste Management 1,754 Fleet Services (73,283) Enterprise Services (8,950) Total Variance (246,195) Projection of variances to December 31, 2017 is summarized in Table 3. Table 3: 2017 Annual Projection Summary Department (Surplus) / Deficit Operations Administration - Engineering Services (35,000) Public Works (90,000) Airport Operations (10,000) Waste Management - Fleet Services (30,000) Enterprise Services - Total Variance (165,000) 52 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (958,071) (960,786) (2,715)0% Specified Revenue - (56,487) (56,487)100%1 Total Revenues (958,071) (1,017,273) (59,202)6% - Expenditures Labour 224,363 189,310 (35,053)16%2 Purchases 389,995 353,837 (36,158)9%3 Contracted Services 5,500 6,106 606 11% Contribution to Reserves - 56,487 56,487 100%1 Debt Principal & Interest 101,197 101,234 37 0% Total Expenditures 721,055 706,974 (14,081)2% Total Net Levy (237,016) (310,299) (73,283)31% 0 Notes 1 Development charge revenue 2 FT labour under $30,400 - Vacant Fleet Mechanic, OT under $4,700 3 Fuel & Oil under $37,600 53 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (20,862) (25,331) (4,469)21% Other Revenue - (33) (33)100% Total Revenues (20,862) (25,364) (4,502)22% Expenditures Labour 28,001 5,016 (22,985)82%1 Purchases 12,869 8,971 (3,898)30% Contracted Services - 22,435 22,435 100%2 Interfunctional Adjustments 5,400 5,400 -0% Total Expenditures 46,270 41,822 (4,448)10% Total Net Levy 25,408 16,458 (8,950)35% 0 Notes 1 Net labour under $22,900 - More time being allocated to Streetlights and other THI activities 2 Subcontractor Expense over $22,400 - timing, offsetting revenue from Bell and Rogers to be received 54 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Total Revenues - - - Expenditures Labour 172,645 169,793 (2,852)2% Purchases 7,151 4,188 (2,963)41% Interfunctional Adjustments (4,725) (4,725) -0% Total Expenditures 175,071 169,256 (5,815)3% Total Net Levy 175,071 169,256 (5,815)3% 55 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (7,124) (14,085) (6,961)98%1 Total Revenues (7,124) (14,085) (6,961)98% - Expenditures Labour 343,523 309,269 (34,254)10%2 Purchases 19,822 17,018 (2,804)14% Interfunctional Adjustments (113,324) (109,561) 3,763 3% Total Expenditures 250,021 216,726 (33,295)13% - Total Net Levy 242,897 202,641 (40,256)17% - Notes 1 Inspection revenue over $7,300 2 Net labour under $37,000 - Vacancies throughout the year 56 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges - (19,384) (19,384)100%1 Specified Revenue - (138,392) (138,392)100%2 Total Revenues - (157,776) (157,776) Expenditures Labour 513,847 440,435 (73,412)14%3 Purchases 182,224 186,838 4,614 3% Contracted Services 55,751 49,669 (6,082)11%4 Contribution to Reserves - 156,452 156,452 100%1 & 2 Interfunctional Adjustments 184,801 184,797 (4)0% Debt Principal & Interest 207,950 207,961 11 0% Total Expenditures 1,144,573 1,226,152 81,579 7% Total Net Levy 1,144,573 1,068,376 (76,197)7% 0 Notes 1 Sidewalk contribution from Developer (Victoria Woods Subdivision) 2 Development charge revenue 3 4 Subcontractor expenses under $6,100 - timing Net labour under $73,400 - Vacancies throughout year, OT under, allocation within Roads departments 57 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Total Revenues - - - Expenditures Labour 155,250 123,053 (32,197)21%1 Purchases 92,500 61,841 (30,659)33%2 Contracted Services 2,000 - (2,000)100% Interfunctional Adjustments 146,925 146,844 (81)0% Total Expenditures 396,675 331,738 (64,937)16% - Total Net Levy 396,675 331,738 (64,937)16% - Notes 1 FT Reg under $14,300 - early winter HEO dismissal; Overtime under $18,600 2 Supplies under $30,700 - Salt 58 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Levy, PILS (142,357) (137,267) 5,090 4% Specified Revenue - (23) (23)100% Total Revenues (142,357) (137,290) 5,067 4% Expenditures Labour 20,425 16,288 (4,137)20% Purchases 374 28,060 27,686 7,403%1 Contracted Services 18,750 14,657 (4,093)22% Contribution to Reserves - 23 23 100% Interfunctional Adjustments 23,774 23,778 4 0% Debt Principal & Interest 7,230 7,265 35 0% Total Expenditures 70,553 90,071 19,518 28% 0 Total Net Levy -71,804 -47,219 24,585 34% 0 Notes 1 Insurance Claims $27,900 59 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges - (220) (220)100% Total Revenues - (220) (220) Expenditures Labour 19,867 31,305 11,438 58%1 Purchases 198,953 206,333 7,380 4% Contracted Services 2,250 1,204 (1,046)46% Interfunctional Adjustments 14,400 14,400 -0% Total Expenditures 235,470 253,242 17,772 8% - Total Net Levy 235,470 253,022 17,552 7% 0 Notes 1 Increased FT labour allocation from Hydro Services $11,700 60 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Grants (5,000) (5,000) -0% User Charges (446,209) (391,157) 55,052 12%1 Other Revenue - (248) (248)100% Total Revenues (451,209) (396,405) 54,804 12% - Expenditures Labour 164,538 146,915 (17,623)11%2 Purchases 238,672 188,652 (50,020)21%3 Contracted Services 22,400 18,185 (4,215)19% Contribution to Reserves 6,000 6,000 -0% Interfunctional Adjustments 7,577 7,569 -8 0% Debt Principal & Interest 19,579 19,579 0% Total Expenditures 458,766 386,900 (71,866)16% 0 Total Net Levy 7,557 (9,505) (17,062)226% 0 Notes 1 2 3 Material/Inventory under $44,400 - fuel purchase Fuel Sales under $55,100 Savings realized from Card Lock system 61 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Specified Revenue - (6,164) (6,164)100%1 Total Revenues - (6,164) (6,164) Expenditures Labour 27,900 33,583 5,683 20%2 Purchases 2,776 310 (2,466)89% Contracted Services 16,500 9,697 (6,803)41%3 Contribution to Reserves - 6,164 6,164 100%1 Interfunctional Adjustments 18,000 18,000 -0% Total Expenditures 65,176 67,754 2,578 4% - Total Net Levy 65,176 61,590 (3,586)6% 0 Notes 1 2 3 Development Charges Revenue Net labour over $5,700 - Allocation within Roads Department Subcon expense under $6,800 due to timing of repair work 62 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (82,876) (97,758) (14,882)18%1 Total Revenues (82,876) (97,758) (14,882)18% - Expenditures Labour 27,528 26,512 (1,016)4% Purchases 72,748 83,554 10,806 15%1 Contracted Services 71,750 78,604 6,854 10%2 Interfunctional Adjustments 86,552 86,544 (8)0% Total Expenditures 258,578 275,214 16,636 6% - Total Net Levy 175,702 177,456 1,754 1% Notes 1 2 More Bagtags were sold vs the amount of bag tags purchased with a net profit Subcontractor Exp over $7,200 - Delayed receipt of Q2 Large Item bin Invoices 63 Report Title Recreation Culture and Parks 2017 Q3 Results Report No. RCP 17-47 Author Rick Cox Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date October 23, 2017 Attachments • Memo re RCP Q2 Results • RCP Q3 2017 Financial Summaries Page 1 / 3 RCP 17-47 - Recreation Culture and Parks RECOMMENDATION THAT Report RCP 17-47 - Recreation Culture and Parks 2017 Q3 Results be received for information. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This report provides Council with the January 1, 2017 to September 30, 2017 Department year to date operational and financial results for Recreation, Culture & Parks. BACKGROUND 2017 Business Objectives Division Item Target Date Status Programs & Services Host the 3rd Run The Runway event to generate funds in support of the F.A.R.E. subsidy program. Q2 Complete Implementation (training) of new Recreation Management Software to replace current CLASS software in 2018. Q1-Q4 In Progress Grow participation and revenue with an expanded calendar of adult and youth recreation programs. Q1-Q4 In Progress Implement Liquid Gym/Water Bike Program. Q1-Q4 Complete Implement capital levy surcharge on pool fees to fund pool deck replacement and future improvements. Q2 Complete Implement capital levy surcharge on waterpark admissions to fund capital repairs and improvements. Q2 Complete Implement marketing strategy for facility rentals at the TCC. Q2 In Progress Apply for grant funding to host 3 Physical Literacy Workshops and Physical Literacy Summit. Q1-Q4 In Progress Open retail storefront for Town merchandise & select sporting goods Q1 Complete Culture & Heritage Canada 150 Events – Dr. Hevenor Art Exhibition, Dominion Days, Confederation Challenge, String Fling, Canada Day. etc. Q1-Q4 In Progress Oxford Remembers – Oxford’s Own. Project to commemorate 100th Anniversary of W.W. I Q2-Q4 In Progress 64 Page 2 / 3 RCP 17-47 - Recreation Culture and Parks Division Item Target Date Status Wilde Week – to celebrate 135th Anniversary of Oscar Wilde’s visit to Oxford County and his influence on the decoration of Annandale NHS Q2 Complete Additional Exhibits & Events as listed in 2017 Calendar including special Exhibit and programs commemorating the 80th Anniversary of the Great Flood Q1-Q4 In Progress Parks & Facilities Review of contracted cleaning services model Q3 Deferred to 2018 Complete repairs of Carroll Trail Q1-Q2 Q3-Q4 Continue implementation of Cemetery Master Plan (columbaria area, road network extensions, scattering garden). Q3 Complete Annual playground equipment replacement program Q1-Q2 Deferred to 2018 Continue implementation of the Memorial Park Revitalization Plan Q1-Q4 On Schedule Roof rehabilitation, repairs and replacements at TCC Q3 Complete TCC Fire alarm system panel and exterior door replacements Q2 Fire panel deferred to Q4. Doors to 2018 Continue implementation of the Asset Management Action Plan Q1-Q4 On Schedule LLWP maintenance (slide tower, basin, spray elements) Q1-Q4 On Schedule Indoor pool deck replacement and asbestos removal Q3 Asbestos complete; Deck deferred to 2018 TCC Lions Auditorium kitchen upgrades phase 1 Q2 Q3-Q4 Rink area LED light conversion Q3 Complete TCC Energy Retrofit pre-tender technical design (I.B. Storey) Q2-Q3 Complete Physical security report on all facilities Q1 Deferred to 2018 Joy Mausoleum Repairs Q2 Complete Cemetery Rear Yard Fencing Q2 Deferred to 2018 Replacement of Museum program room floor tile Q2 Complete Repair of Annandale House eaves & fascia Q2 Deferred to 2018 Customer Service Centre Façade brick repair/restoration Q2 Cancelled Relocation of the water stack in the server room at the Customer Service Centre Q1 In progress Dog Park 2017 Build Q4 Enhanced Beautification Q2-Q3 Complete 65 Page 3 / 3 RCP 17-47 - Recreation Culture and Parks Key Indicators FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE The RCP Department’s 2017 Q3 operational financial variance summary is as follows: As noted in the Memo provided to Council in September regarding the Q2 results (attached), Q3 & Q4 spending will consume the majority of the in-year surplus by year-end. The projected year- end discretionary surplus, if realized, is largely a result of energy conservation and may be contributed to reserves for investing in similar future projects. COMMUNITY STRATEGIC PLAN (CSP) IMPACT This report provides information in alignment with the following Objectives of the Community Strategic Plan: • Objective 1 – Excellence in Local Government • Objective 2 – Sustainable Economy • Objective 4 – Culture & Community Key Indicators 2017 2016 % change Comment Museum: attendance - headcount 10,437 9,117 14% Programs: Advanced/Leadership - headcount 78 184 -58% Indoor pool closure prevented leadership program Programs: Aquatic registrations - headcount 3,039 2,661 14% Programs: Public Swim attendance - headcount 8,784 9,318 -6%Indoor pool closure Programs: Memberships sold 1,731 1,357 28%Aquafit passes at LLWP Programs: Health Club attendance - headcount 18,390 21,167 -13%pool closure, NHL event closure Programs: Water Fitness attendance - headcount 7,562 7,688 -2%Aquacycling program added in 2017 Programs: Land Fitness attendance - headcount 1,647 1,446 14%Yoga attendance increased Programs: Public Skating attendance - headcount 2,931 2,220 32%Free program Programs: Roller Skating attendance - headcount 503 350 44%Popluar program Programs: Squash Courts - headcount 840 985 -15% Programs: Waterpark attendance - headcount 16,098 25,932 -38%Bad weather, water clarity early closures Programs: Youth registrations - headcount 3,682 3,830 -4% Programs: Advertising revenue (guide,boards,fences)29,754$ 30,236$ -2%no ball fence advertising Programs: Rink bookings (ice) -hours 3,740 2,406 55%significant increase in casual and mini rink users Programs: Rink bookings (floor) - hours 600 165 263%ball hockey, dog show, NHL event Programs: Tournaments (ice/pool/field)13 11 18% Programs: Room rentals (non-admin)685 573 20% Programs: Aquatic user fees collected 9,746$ n/a New fee for 2017 Programs: Rental insurance program 3,925$ na/New program for 2017 Cemetery: Niche & Plot sales (count)53 49 8% Cemetery: Interments (count)104 92 13% Data for Q1-Q3 Division YTD Budget YTD Actual Variance Forecast Cemetery 111,999 81,730 (30,269)(6,750) Parks 446,276 433,863 (12,413)20,600 Community Programs 34,000 55,850 21,850 23,000 Recreation Programs 298,379 304,452 6,073 54,500 Facilities 1,585,597 1,427,663 (157,934)(104,000) EFC (16,398)(30,575)(14,177)----- Museum 245,702 243,949 (1,753)----- Totals 2,705,555 2,516,932 (188,623)(12,650) 66 Date: September 11, 2017 To: Members of Council From: Rick Cox, Director of Recreation, Culture & Parks RE: RCP 17-40 Recreation Culture & Parks 2017 Q2 Results In response to questions from Council about the consolidated RCP departmental YTD surplus of $272,546.00 reported on in RCP 17-40 Recreation Culture & Parks 2017 Q2 Results, I submit the following commentary: Situational Summary In each Division, the significant contributors to the net surplus are summarized in the table to the right. I anticipate achieving savings from energy conservation and FT labour vacancies over the course of the year. By year end, the timing-related surplus will have been consumed, leaving any remaining HLW and labour savings to offset revenue shortfalls or higher-than-expected costs elsewhere. The mid-year surplus position is anticipated to be consumed by year-end as follows: Moving forward, we will refine the year-end projection as the Q3 expenses and revenues are posted, and update Council through the Q3 report and the 2018 budget process. (272,000) 169,000 (103,000) 60,000 8,000 (35,000) 35,000 0 LLWP net additional loss (estimate) AHNS net additional loss (estimate) Year-end discretionary surplus (estimate) Projected RCP Dec 31, 2017 surplus Contribution to reserve for future energy projects June 30 surplus timing-related spending Mid-year discretionary surplus (estimate) Division Timing HLW Labour Cem (18,700)5,000 Parks (63,300)(5,700)(6,000) CP (10,000) Programs (14,000) Facilities (45,800)(74,300)(21,900) EFC (8,400) Museum (9,000) Contribution to Surplus (169,200)(80,000)(22,900) Contributors to Surplus 67 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (98,175) (118,014) (19,839)20%1 Other Revenue (3,250) (3,770) (520)16% Total Revenues (101,425) (121,784) (20,359)20% - Expenditures Labour 102,065 98,709 (3,356) 3% Purchases 31,885 33,568 1,683 5% Contracted Services 17,000 12,513 (4,487) 26% Interfunctional Adjustments 62,474 58,864 (3,610) 6% Total Expenditures 213,424 203,654 (9,770) Total Net Levy 111,999 81,870 (30,129)27% 0 Notes 1 Services Revenue over $8,800; Foundation Revnue over$5,700; Plot sales revnue over $4,600 68 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (20,700) (25,333) (4,633)22% Other Revenue (1,949) (3,660) (1,711)88% Total Revenues (22,649) (28,993) (6,344)28% - Expenditures Labour 126,445 126,415 (30)0% Purchases 99,175 64,775 (34,400)35%1 Contracted Services 104,800 133,073 28,273 27%2 Contribution to Reserves 11,000 11,273 273 2% Interfunctional Adjustments 67,600 67,416 (184)0% Debt Principal & Interest 59,905 59,903 -2 0% Total Expenditures 468,925 462,855 (6,070) Total Net Levy 446,276 433,862 (12,414)0 Notes 1 2 Subcontractor Exp over $26,700 - sports fields and trees Supplies Exp under $8,300; Equipment Supplies & Repairs under $9,800; HLW under $6,600 69 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Grants (3,000) (10,250) (7,250)242%1 User Charges - (7,383) (7,383)100%2 Other Revenue - (7,772) (7,772)100%3 Contribution from Reserves - (10,000) (10,000)100%4 Total Revenues (3,000) (35,405) (32,405)1080% 1 Expenditures Labour - 10,056 10,056 100%5 Purchases 37,000 81,199 44,199 119%6 Total Expenditures 37,000 91,255 54,255 147% 0% Total Net Levy 34,000 55,850 21,850 64% 0 Notes 1 2017 Council grant - Cultural Advisory Committee 2 Canada 150 Tree program 3 Donation Revenue - Kinsmen for Fireworks 4 $10,000 contribution to NHL Centennial event, funded from Reserves 5 Labour allocated towards NHL event & turtle fest 6 Cultural Grant Expense $6,000; Supplies Expense over $7,700 - fireworks; Special projects over $9,500 -NHL event; Canada 150 Tree program $21,000 70 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Grants (32,026) (34,647) (2,621)8% User Charges (986,800) (914,034) 72,766 7%1 Other Revenue (21,501) (21,631) (130)1% Total Revenues (1,040,327) (970,312) 70,015 7% - Expenditures Labour 1,081,521 1,033,308 (48,213)4% Purchases 206,824 192,800 (14,024)7%2 Interfunctional Adjustments 43,051 41,320 (1,731)4% Debt Principal & Interest 7,310 7,337 27 0% Total Expenditures 1,338,706 1,274,765 (63,941)5% Total Net Levy 298,379 304,453 6,074 2% Notes 1 2 Net User charge revenue under $72,800 Net Supplies under $16,400 - timing; 71 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (4,725) (5,725) (1,000)21% Specified Revenue - (39,516) (39,516)100%1 Total Revenues (4,725) (45,241) (40,516)857% 100% Expenditures Labour 595,897 547,950 (47,947)8%2 Purchases 609,896 521,253 (88,643)15%3 Contracted Services 151,404 131,009 (20,395)13%4 Contribution to Reserves - 39,474 39,474 100%1 Interfunctional Adjustments 31,500 31,500 -0% Debt Principal & Interest 201,625 201,717 92 0% Total Expenditures 1,590,322 1,472,903 (117,419)7% 0% Total Net Levy 1,585,597 1,427,662 (157,935)10% 0 Notes 1 Development charge revenue 2 Net FT labour under $47,900 - vacant positions; PT labour under $13,700; Net OT over $8,300 3 HLW under $66,800; Equipment Supplies & Repairs under $5,900; Building Repairs & Maint under $11,400 4 Subcontractor Exp under $8,000 - Elevator Maint, garbage lifts and snow removal; Equipment Maint Contract under $12,400 - KeyTech (aquaplan program) and Cimco (refrigeration) - timing 72 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues User Charges (61,875) (74,982) (13,107)21%1 Total Revenues (61,875) (74,982) (13,107)21% - Expenditures Purchases 14,320 12,337 (1,983)14% Contracted Services - 912 912 100% Debt Principal & Interest 31,157 31,158 1 0% Total Expenditures 45,477 44,407 (1,070)2% Total Net Levy (16,398) (30,575) (14,177)86% - Notes 1 Rent Revenue over $13,100 73 2017 2017 Actual % Note YTD Budget YTD Actuals Variance Variance Reference Revenues Grants - (700) (700)100% User Charges (30,477) (21,189) 9,288 30%1 Other Revenue (21,450) (5,956) 15,494 72%2 Total Revenues (51,927) (27,845) 24,082 46% - Expenditures Labour 202,336 200,365 (1,971)1% Purchases 74,894 52,396 (22,498)30%3 Contracted Services 7,200 6,695 (505)7% Interfunctional Adjustments 13,199 12,339 (860)7% Total Expenditures 297,629 271,795 (25,834)9% 0 Total Net Levy 245,702 243,950 (1,752)1% Notes 1 Net User charges revenue under $9,300 2 Special revenue under $16,800 3 Special events Exp under $7,400; Building repairs & Maintenance Exp under $7,400 74 Report Title 0.5 FTE Increase – Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering Report No. CAO 17- 05 Author David Calder, CAO Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date November 13, 2017 Attachments LETTER – CHAIR TILLSONBURG HYDRO INC Page 1 / 2 0.5 FTE Increase - Manager of Hydro Oper RECOMMENDATION: That Council receives report CAO 17-05 0.5 FTE Increase – Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering. And that the Council of the Town of Tillsonburg authorizes the CAO to increase the Town FTE complement by 0.5 to allow for a full time Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering to be funded by Tillsonburg Hydro Inc. effective January 1, 2018. Background At its meeting of September 29, 2017, the Board of Directors of THI passed the following resolution: “THAT the Board receives Report CEO THI 10-17 FTE Increase for the Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering, Town of Tillsonburg; AND THAT the Board approves a budget increase to allow for a permanent 0.5 increase for a full time Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering for the Town of Tillsonburg; AND THAT the Board Chair and the THI Chief Executive Officer present the request to Council for endorsement of an additional 0.5 FTE as soon as possible in order to start the hiring process.” On October 19, 2017, the Town of Tillsonburg received the attached letter addressed to the CAO of the Town of Tillsonburg from the Chair of Tillsonburg Hydro Inc. (THI) requesting Council to endorse an additional 0.5 FTE to provide for a full time Manager of Hydro Operations and Engineering. This position would provide full time services to THI and be funded within the THI budget. The Town of Tillsonburg would recover the 100% of the cost of this position from THI. The Chair of THI and the CEO will be present to answer any questions related to the requested increase in FTE. 75 Page 2 / 2 COMMUNITY STRATEGIC PLAN (CSP) IMPACT This report recommends taking actions that are in alignment with the following Objectives of the Community Strategic Plan: • Objective 1 – Excellence in Local Government 76 77 Report Title Bonds for Development Securities Report No. CAO 17-06 Author David Calder Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date November 13, 2017 Attachments • SUBDIVISION BONDS FOR DEVELOPMENT DOCUMENT • SUBDIVISION SECURITY COMPARISON • FRANK COWAN DOCUMENT Page 1 / 2 RECOMMENDATION THAT Council receive report CAO 17-06 Bonds for Development Securities; AND THAT the Council of Town of Tillsonburg amend the Site Plan Agreement By-law and Subdivision agreement to include Bonds as an additional form of financial security for site plan applications and subdivision developments. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Currently, the Town of Tillsonburg requires securities as part of site plan agreements and subdivision agreements to ensure that the necessary site infrastructure (roads, curbs, water, sewer, landscaping, etc) will be put in place in a timely fashion and warranted by the developer. Further, to ensure that the developer has the necessary financial resources to provide and pay for the required infrastructure, the Town requires financial security from the developer. This security traditionally has taken the form of cash or letters of credit. Recently, a local developer has requested the posting of a bond for the purposes of securities under a site plan application. BACKGROUND The advantage of a bond for a developer is that bonds do not encumber a developers’ balance sheet as a letter of credit would. A bond as a form of security maximizes the financial resources available to the developer. A bond also allows the developer to access cash that is usually tied up in a letter of credit thus increasing cash flow that can be better used to develop the project. A bond still protects the municipality from a developer default as a bond is liquid financial security that can be accessed by the municipality without taking action against the developer. As a result, there does not appear to be any additional risk to the Town should it accept bonds as a 78 Page 2 / 2 CAO form of security. As noted a bond would be another form of security which still provides an option for the developer to provide securities in the form of cash, letter of credit or bond. From the municipalities perspective an advantage of accepting a bond as an alternate form of financial security is that it shows support to the development community that the Town is responsive to the needs of developers. As previously noted, this can be achieved without increasing financial risk to the Town. As noted in the staff recommendation, the Town’s Site Plan Agreement By-law and Subdivision Agreement do not currently provide for the posting of a bond as a development security. Staff have attached documentation that supports bonds as a viable security for development activities. CONSULTATION/COMMUNICATION Staff obtained legal advice as to the acceptance of a bond as a form of security. The Town’s solicitor notes that a “bond is probably sufficient to protect the Town. However, the Town should be aware that it is not as good as an irrevocable letter of credit. First, the bond is more similar to a form of insurance whereas the letter of credit is a credit facility. Second, many municipalities require the irrevocable letter of credit from one of the chartered banks whereas the performance bond is coming from an insurer.” FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE There is no direct financial impact of amending the Site Plan Agreement By-law and the Subdivision Agreement to provide for the option of providing a bond as an alternate form of security. The true impact of a bond will not be realized until such time as a developer defaults on a development project. To date, the Town of Tillsonburg has been fortunate that it has a strong development community that has not defaulted on their development agreements with the Town of Tillsonburg. COMMUNITY STRATEGIC PLAN IMPACT As noted in the Community Strategic Plan (CSP), the plan identifies Excellence in Local Government as a strategic outcome and participating on the Local Court Security Advisory Committee will reinforce positive local decision making. 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 Report Title Committee Appointment Report No. CL 17-21 Author Donna Wilson, Town Clerk Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date November 13, 2017 Attachments RECOMMENDATION THAT Council receive Report CL 17-21, Committee Appointment; AND THAT Reg Butcher be appointed to the Heritage, Beautification & Cemetery Advisory Committee; AND THAT By-Law 4147, to Amend Schedule A of By-Law 3876, be brought forward for Council consideration. BACKGROUND The Clerk’s Office has received an application requesting appointment to the Heritage, Beautification & Cemetery Advisory Committee from Reg Butcher. The Committee has been notified of the application and have no objection to the appointment. The Heritage, Beautification & Cemetery Advisory Committee (HBC Committee) was established by Council to advise Council on all matters with respect to architectural and historical significance. To assist Council in conserving Tillsonburg’s historic past and to promote public education concerning preservation of unique architectural and heritage of Tillsonburg. To make recommendations to Council regarding designations of buildings with historical significance, this would ensure the conservation, protection and preservation of heritage in Ontario, in accordance with the Ontario Heritage Act. To make recommendations to Council on the Tillsonburg Cemetery. FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE There will be no additional impact to the 2017 budget as a result of the appointment. COMMUNITY STRATEGIC PLAN (CSP) IMPACT 1.Excellence in Local Government 1.1 Demonstrate strong leadership in Town initiatives Committee appointments demonstrate an excellence in local government through increased opportunities for citizens and stakeholders to be included in oversight on municipal operations. Page 1 / 1 Report CL 17-21 – Committee Appointment 87 88 89 Report Title Sign Variance – 360 Quarter Town Line – Simply 360 Residential Development Report No. DCS 17-34 Author Geno Vanhaelewyn, Chief Building Official Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date NOVEMBER 13, 2017 Attachments N/A Page 1 / 4 DCS 17-34 - Sign Variance 360 Quarter RECOMMENDATION THAT Council receive report DCS 17-34 Sign Variance – 360 Quarter Town Line – Simply 360 Residential Development. AND THAT a variance to Sign By-Law 3798 be approved for the construction of a temporary 38 m2 (400 ft2) subdivision promotional banner sign mounted on a trailer located on the East side of Quarter Town Line between Trillium Drive and Southridge Road described as 360 Quarter Town Line (Plan 41M119, LOT 2) with the following conditions: (i) A sign permit is obtained; (ii) Skirting is installed around the bottom perimeter of the trailer acceptable to Building/By-Law Services; (iii) Signage is maintained as per Sign By-Law 3798, Clean Yard By-Law 3810 and maintained reasonably level; (iv) If the maintenance of the sign becomes derelict in any manner the signage will be ordered to be removed and any replacement signage will be required to be installed as per Sign By-Law 3798. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The recent installation of new signage located at 360 Quarter Town Line was identified by By- Law Services. In review, the sign was installed without consultation or a permit and is in contravention of Sign By-Law 3798. As a result, By-Law staff advised the developer of the contraventions and provided three options; remove the signage, install signage that complies with the by-law or apply for a sign variance. In this case the developer opted to apply for a sign variance and the applicant is requesting a variance to the Sign Bylaw 3798 to permit the existing signage. The sign consists of a 38 m2 (400 ft2)/15.2m (50 ft) x 2.4m (8 ft) subdivision promotional banner sign mounted on a trailer on the East side of Quarter Town Line between Trillium Drive and Southridge Road known as 360 Quarter Town Line as indicated on the following illustrations/site plans. The purpose of the 90 Page 2 / 4 CAO signage is to promote the Simply 360 residential townhouse development that has recently obtained site plan approval SITE PLAN SIGN COPY/ELEVATION 91 Page 3 / 4 CAO Sign By-Law 3798 notes the following related to this request: Trailer signs and banner signs are prohibited: 5.1 SPECIFIC SIGN PROHIBITIONS (d) Vehicle/Trailer sign on non-motorized vehicles where the purpose of the sign meets the definition of a sign under this By-law; (p) Banner Signs Maximum area of Subdivision Development Signs are 25m2(269 ft2) per sign 7.3 PROPERTY USE CATAGORIES (SCHEDULE A) SUBDIVISION DEVELOPMENT SIGN - 1 sign per 150 m of road frontage up to a maximum of 4 signs - maximum area per sign 25 m2 (269 ft2) In this case: - the sign is a trailer sign which is not permitted - the sign copy is displayed on a banner which is not permitted - the sign is 13 m2 (140 ft2) larger than permitted The municipality recognizes in “Section 9 – Variances” of the by-law that there may be exceptions and therefore the Director or Council can consider variance requests. This application was deemed major in that the Director/CAO cannot approve the request which therefore requires Council consideration. CONSULTATION/COMMUNICATION This application was referred to internal departments and external agencies and the following comments were received: i) By-Law Services noted concerns related to the deterioration of banner signs, the aesthetics of the trailer body and potential sinking/levelness of the overall sign. ii) CAO noted concerns related to the temporary duration requirements of the sign , maintenance and deterioration of banners and aesthetics of the trailer body particularly the under body such as tires, rusting of underbody, etc. 92 Page 4 / 4 CAO Recommendation That the Town of Tillsonburg Council approve the variances to Sign By-Law 3798 for the construction of a temporary 38 m2 (400 ft2) subdivision promotional banner sign mounted on a trailer located on the East side of Quarter Town Line between Trillium Drive and Southridge Road described as 360 Quarter Town Line (Plan 41M119, LOT 2) with the following conditions: (i) A sign permit is obtained; (ii) Skirting is installed around the bottom perimeter of the trailer acceptable to Building/By-Law Services; (iii) Signage (including the trailer body) is maintained as per Sign By-Law 3798, Clean Yard By-Law 3810 and kept reasonably level; (iv) If the maintenance of the sign becomes derelict in any manner the signage will be ordered to be removed and any replacement signage will be required to be installed as per Sign By-Law 3798. The proposed variances along with the recommended conditions are: (i) reasonably desirable for the location and use of the land; (ii) in-keeping with the general intent and purpose of the Town of Tillsonburg Sign By-law No. 3798 as it relates to development; (iii) supportive of the Community Strategic Plan Objective 2 – Economic Sustainability FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE N/A COMMUNITY STRATEGIC PLAN (CSP) IMPACT - Community Strategic Plan Objective 2 – Economic Sustainability 93 Report Title Sign Variance – 180-190 Simcoe Street – Billboard Sign Report No. DCS 17-35 Author Geno Vanhaelewyn, Chief Building Official Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date NOVEMBER 13, 2017 Attachments N/A Page 1 / 6 DCS 17-35 Sign Variance 180-190 Simcoe RECOMMENDATION THAT Council receive report DCS 17-35 Sign Variance – 180-190 Simcoe Street – Billboard Sign AND THAT Council not approve the sign variance application request for the placement of a billboard sign noted in report DCS 17-35 Sign Variance – 180-190 Simcoe Street – Billboard Sign; AND THAT the signage is removed on or before November 20, 2017. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The recent installation of new signage located at 180-190 Simcoe Street was identified by By- Law Services. In review, the sign was installed on the existing sign frame for the Harvest/Nautical Lands development. The change of the sign copy from a development sign advertising Harvest/Nautical Lands to a billboard sign advertising Titan Trailers without consultation or a permit triggered the contravention of Sign By-Law 3798. As a result, By-Law staff advised the developer of the non-compliance and provided two options; remove the signage or apply for a sign variance. In this case the developer opted to apply for a sign variance and the applicant is requesting a variance to the Sign Bylaw 3798 to permit the existing signage. The proposed application is for permission to permit a billboard sign to advertise an off-site business on the 6.1 m x 6.1 m (20 ft x 20 ft) sign that is already constructed on the properties as indicated on the following site plan/elevation. 94 Page 2 / 6 CAO SITE PLAN PREVIOUS “HARVEST” SIGN COPY/ELEVATION 95 Page 3 / 6 CAO PROPOSED/EXISTING SIGN COPY/ELEVATION 96 Page 4 / 6 CAO The application requires relief from: Section 7.2 • Schedule A- Permitted Location: To permit a billboard sign in a Service Commercial Zone. Billboard signs are only permitted in Future Development zones. • Schedule A- Area: To increase the maximum sign area from 19m2 (200ft2) to 37.16m2 (400ft2). • Schedule A- Height: To increase the maximum height of the sign from 7.5m (24.61ft) to 9.14m (30ft). Section 8.2 • To decrease the location from another billboard sign from 400m (1,312.24ft) to 122m (403ft). Sign By-Law 3798 notes the following related to this request: 7.2 Signs In Schedules To This By-Law a) A sign that is listed in a schedule as being allowed shall only be allowed if it satisfies all applicable provisions of this By-law and any other applicable law. Schedule A- Permitted Sign Use/Property Use Table TYPE OF SIGN S. Permit ? RESIDENTIAL INDUSTRIAL COMMERICAL INSTITUTIONAL FUTURE DEVELOPMENT ENTREPRENEURIAL CENTRAL COMMERCIAL Billboard Sign 8.2 YES Not Permitted Not Permitted Not Permitted Not Permitted Allowed: one sign Not Permitted AREA:19 m2 (200 ft2) Not Permitted HEIGHT: 7.5 m (24.61 ft) Section 8- Specific Sign Regulations 8.2- Billboard Signs a) A billboard sign shall not be located, erected or displayed within 400 meters (1,312.24 ft.) of any other billboard sign. The municipality recognizes in “Section 9 – Variances” of the by-law that there may be exceptions and therefore the Director or Council can consider variance requests. This application was deemed major in that the Director/CAO cannot approve the request which therefore requires Council consideration. 97 Page 5 / 6 CAO CONSULTATION/COMMUNICATION This application was referred to internal departments and external agencies and the following comments were received: i) By-Law Services noted concerns related to the installation of the signage without consultation or a sign permit. Billboard signs are the only permitted form of off-site advertising and by permitting variances as such may cause confusion for other businesses whether or not off-site advertising is permitted. By-Law Services is therefore not in support of this application. ii) Building/Planning Services noted concerns related to the removal of development advertising for the use as a billboard and that the signage on the property should only be used to market the development land the sign is on or the development lands directly to the north. iii) CAO noted concerns related to the permanent nature of a billboard sign and recommends that the signage, if approved, be for a temporary period (6 months+/-) only. iv) Tillsonburg BIA noted that the By-Law should be followed and does not support the variance request. If the signage is permitted to remain the BIA has concerns related to perception and possible precedence setting. v) Tillsonburg District Chamber of Commerce commented that variances as such should not become a regular occurrence. The concern is that once these signs are permitted, more will follow; and the Town's entrance image will be compromised if there are too many billboard signs. Recommendation THAT the Town of Tillsonburg Council not approve the sign variance application request for the placement of a billboard sign noted in report DCS 17-35 Sign Variance – 180-190 Simcoe Street – Billboard Sign; AND THAT the signage is removed on or before November 20, 2017. The proposed variances are not: (i) reasonably desirable for the location and use of the land; (ii) in-keeping with the general intent and purpose of the Town of Tillsonburg Sign By-law No. 3798. 98 Page 6 / 6 CAO Alternative Recommendation(s) 1. THAT the Town of Tillsonburg Council approve the variances to Sign By-Law 3798 for the construction of a temporary 37.16m2 (400 ft2) x 9.14m (30ft) high billboard sign located within 122m (403ft) of another billboard sign on the North side of Simcoe Street between Westtown Line and Goshen Street described as Part Lot 24 PLAN 1653, Part 7 41R8458 & Lot 30 PLAN 1653 with the following conditions: (i) A sign permit is obtained; (ii) The variance for a billboard sign is temporary and shall be removed on or before December 31, 2017 at which time the sign will be designated as a promotional development sign to promote the development lands on or directly north of the sign; (iii) The variance is applicable for the proposed sign copy only; any change in billboard sign copy is not permitted. FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE N/A COMMUNITY STRATEGIC PLAN (CSP) IMPACT N/A 99 Report Title International Per Diem Rate Report No. DCS 17-37 Author Cephas Panschow Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date NOVEMBER 13, 2017 Attachments Page 1 / 2 RECOMMENDATION THAT Council receive Report DCS 17-37 International Per Diem Rate; AND THAT the Treasury Board Secretariat of Canada’s Meal Per Diem Rate be approved for use for international travel instead of the Town’s standard per diem rate; AND THAT the Town’s Personnel Policy be amended to reflect this change. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The purpose of this report is to seek Council approval to use an alternate per diem reimbursement rate for meals instead of the Town’s standard per diem rate. The reason is that meal expenses outside of Canada tend to be significantly higher than that experienced in Canada and the Town’s Personnel Policy is silent on reimbursement for additional costs incurred for travel out of country. BACKGROUND Town Council approved the use of the Treasury Board Secretariat of Canada’s Meal Per Diem Rate for the 2015 Mission to Japan and staff is seeking approval to use their rates for this trip. This is due to the fact that meal costs internationally, including Asia, are very high. For example, Tokyo has some of the highest costs for food in the world. If the Town’s standard per diem rate was used for the trip, it is possible that Town representatives would be responsible to pay a significant portion of the trip costs out of their own pocket. The rates being proposed are developed by the National Joint Council of the Public Service of Canada (www.njc-cnm.gc.ca), which is the Forum of Choice for co-development, consultation and information sharing between the government as employer and public service bargaining agents, and are based on actual costs in different cities around the world. 100 Page 2 / 2 Their rates for various cities are: City Secretariat Rates (in foreign currency) Secretariat Rates (in Canadian Currency)* Canada (for comparison purposes) N/A $85.35 China (Beijing) 700 RMB $135 Germany (Frankfurt) 116.85 Euro $173 Japan (Nagoya) 11,705 yen $131 United States $85.35 $109 *Canadian currency equivalent as of November 4, 2017 The Per Diem Rates in the above table are based on actual costs in specific cities and it is clear that the cost for meals is significantly higher than the Town’s Standard Per Diem rates. Hence, staff is recommending that the Treasury Board Secretariat of Canada’s Meal Per Diem Rate be approved for use for travel outside of Canada. CONSULTATION/COMMUNICATION Not applicable. FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE The 2017 Economic Development & Marketing budget contains $12,000 in funding for the Mission to Asia and the reimbursement of meal costs at the Secretariat’s rate would be funded out of this amount. COMMUNITY STRATEGIC PLAN Not applicable. 101 Report Title Parking Improvements at Community Centre Report No. OPS 17-28 Author Eric Flora, P. Eng., CET, Manager of Engineering Geno Vanhaelewyn, Chief Building Official Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date November 13, 2017 Attachments Parks & Recreation Advisory Committee Report Page 1 / 4 RECOMMENDATION: THAT Council receive Report OPS 17-28, Parking Improvements at Community Centre; AND THAT the cost estimate of $175,000 associated with enhancing parking at the Tillsonburg Community Centre be referred to the 2018 budget deliberations. BACKGROUND At the July 10, 2017 Council meeting, Operations and By-law Enforcement staff were requested to review the Parks & Recreation Advisory Committee’s motion that parking be removed from the west side of Hardy Avenue and on the south side of Lisgar Avenue between Broadway and Hardy Avenue, and that enhancement of the parking lots at Welding Lane and Hardy Avenue be reviewed and the associated cost estimates be addressed during the 2018 budget deliberations. At the same meeting, the Committee also raised the following safety concerns: speed on both Lisgar Avenue and Hardy Avenue, poor visibility when leaving the current parking lot on Hardy Avenue and the inability for emergency vehicles to access the Community Centre and all outdoor facilities (ball diamonds, pump track, skate park when cars parking on both sides). Also noted was the fact that during winter months, Hardy Avenue becomes very narrow after snow plowing activities. SUMMARY Parking is currently allowed along the south side of Lisgar Avenue from 125 metres east of Broadway to 35 metres east of Devon Court (approximately 110 metres of permitted on-street parking). Along Hardy Avenue from Lisgar Avenue towards the Community Centre, parking is allowed on both sides. The section of Hardy Avenue (inside portion of roadway near Community Centre) is signed as ‘No Parking/Emergency Vehicle Parking Only’ as illustrated in Figure 1. The current posted speed limit along Lisgar Avenue is 50 km/h while the current posted speed limit along Hardy Avenue is 40 km/h. 102 Page 2 / 4 Figure 1 shows the existing Welding Lane parking lot limits and the area between the existing tennis courts and Hardy Avenue that could possibly be used for additional parking. Staff have undertaken a preliminary concept design of these two proposed parking lots. The proposed parking lot adjacent to the tennis courts can accommodate approximately 35 spaces, while the Welding Lane parking lot can accommodate approximately 94 spaces. The preliminary design allows for the required number of accessible stalls that meet zoning and legislative requirements. The cost estimate to improve the Welding Lane lot is $245,000 with a paved surface and $175,000 with a porous surface, while the cost estimate to construct the lot adjacent to the tennis courts is $125,000 with a paved surface and $95,000 with a porous surface. Council may wish to consider the same capital investment in the proposed ‘east of Tillsonburg Community Centre parking area’ as shown on Figure 1, as the construction of this lot would likely be more beneficial considering the new dog park and the proposed outdoor rink. These new amenities will eventually generate an increased demand for parking. In order to address the speeding concern, staff have contacted the Ontario Provincial Police and requested that spot speed surveys and increased enforcement be provided along both Lisgar Avenue and Hardy Avenue. In order to address the poor visibility concern raised by the Committee, staff undertook sight line reviews at the following locations: • Intersection of Lisgar Avenue/Hardy Avenue, • Entrance/Exit to the existing Hardy Avenue parking lot, and • Intersection of Hardy Avenue/Community Centre north entrance/exit. The sight lines at the Lisgar Avenue/Hardy Avenue intersection exceed the minimum sight distance requirements. At the existing Hardy Avenue parking lot entrance/exit, it is recommended to clearly delineate no parking zones on the west side of Hardy Avenue, north and south of the entrance/exit, in order to improve the visibility of vehicular traffic entering/exiting the lot (see Figure 1). Parking restrictions should also be implemented on the northwest and northeast corners of the Hardy Avenue/Community Centre north entrance/exit, as shown on Figure 1. Any removal of the parking stalls along Lisgar Avenue and/or Hardy Avenue should be conditional upon new parking lots/stalls being established, in order to offset parking demands and minimize impacts on facility users. The Traffic By-law can be amended once new parking areas are established and the exact ‘No Parking/Stopping’ restriction limits have been determined. 103 Page 3 / 4 Staff also discussed the ‘inability for emergency vehicles to access the Community Centre and all outdoor facilities’ with the Fire and Rescue Services Department. For a fire alarm sounding, the first fire apparatus is deployed to the Lion’s Den/Colin Campbell entrance area where the fire connection at the Community Centre is located. Vehicles improperly parked within the No Parking/Emergency Vehicle Parking Only Zone make access to that area difficult. Staff recommend improving the Fire Route signage and pavement markings within the areas surrounding the Community Centre, as well as continued enforcement by Town By-law staff and Ontario Provincial Police. CONSULTATION/COMMUNICATION Town By-Law Enforcement, the Fire and Rescue Services Department, and Recreation, Culture and Parks staff were consulted in preparation of this report and associated recommendations. FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE Staff are requesting that the capital budget implications associated with proposed parking lot improvements be referred to the 2018 budget deliberations. COMMUNITY STRATEGIC PLAN (CSP) Investment into parking enhancements at the Tillsonburg Community Centre supports Objective 4 – Culture & Community of the Community Strategic Plan. 104 Page 4 / 4 105 Report Title Parking at Community Centre Report No. Author Mel Getty – Chair – Parks & Recreation Advisory Committee Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date July 10, 2017 Attachments RECOMMENDATION THAT Council receives the recommendations from the Parks & Recreation Advisory Committee for Parking at the Community Centre, as information; AND THAT the matter be referred to the Works Department and By-Law Enforcement for review and recommendations. BACKGROUND The Parks & Rec Advisory Committee RESOLVES On a MOTION made, SECONDED and CARRIED that the parking be removed from the West side of Hardy Ave and on the south of Lisgar Ave between Broadway and Hardy Ave. Also enhancement of the parking lot at Welding Lane and Hardy Ave, this is to include signage and parking curbs. Moved By: D. Scanlan Seconded By: S. Wray EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: At the June 20th meeting of the Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee the following safety concerns were discussed: speed on both Lisgar Ave & Hardy Ave, poor visibility when leaving the current parking lot on Hardy Ave and the inability for emergency vehicles to access the community centre and all outdoor facilities – ball diamonds, pump track, skate park when cars parking on both sides. During winter months Hardy Ave becomes very narrow after snow ploughing. FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE: Parking Lot on Welding Lane and Hardy Ave to be addressed in the 2018 Budget. Page 1 / 1 2017 Parks Recreation Advisory Committe.docx 27106 Report Title Implementing an Energy Retrofit at the Tillsonburg Community Centre Report No. RCP 17-48 Author Rick Cox Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date November 13, 2017 Attachments • RCP 17-02 – Budget Issue Paper: Utilities Cost Increases • Tillsonburg Community Centre Consolidated Scope of Work • Example amortization schedule from Infrastructure Ontario Page 1 / 8 RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retro RECOMMENDATION THAT Report RCP 17-48 –Implementing an Energy Retrofit at the Tillsonburg Community Centre be received; AND THAT Council give 2018 pre-budget approval and authorize staff to proceed with implementing the Energy Retrofit project as designed by I.B. Storey Inc.; AND THAT Council award RFT 2017-011 – Refrigeration to Cimco Refrigeration Division of Toromont Industries at their tendered price of $693,700.00 before taxes; AND THAT Council award RFT 2017-012 – Automation to Trane Sales Agency - N.L. Clarke Sales Ltd. at their tendered price of $76,450.00 before taxes; AND THAT Council award RFT 2017-014 – Electrical Co-Generation to Whitby Hydro Energy Services Corporation at their tendered price of $1,033,585.00 before taxes; AND THAT Council authorize the Construction Oversight, Commissioning and Turnover & Closeout phases of the contract with I.B. Storey Inc. at a cost not to exceed $99,000; AND THAT pursuant to the Town of Tillsonburg’s Debt Management Policy, the Director of Finance is authorized to place debt to finance the project with the debt servicing costs funded through operational savings (reduced energy consumption) resulting from completing the project; AND THAT in collaboration with Oxford County, the Town commits to complete a community- wide greenhouse gas inventory, targets and plan by April 2019 in order for this project to be eligible for submission to the GHG Challenge fund. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY With Council’s authorization via the 2017 Budget and RCP Workplan, staff has worked with I.B. Storey Inc. to complete the technical design of an energy retrofit project at the Tillsonburg Community Centre. This project moves the facility to true emergency centre readiness with improved patron, staff and neighbourhood safety. It addresses imminent lifecycle replacement 107 Page 2 / 8 RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retro issues and reduces operating costs enough to both avoid impact to the tax rate and recover the cost of the project in a reasonable timeframe. Tenders were issued for the project components to secure firm market pricing for implementing the project. This report requests authorization to execute the energy retrofit project using debt financing funded through the operational savings achieved by implementing the project. Other non-tax funding sources will also be pursued as appropriate. BACKGROUND In alignment with the Town of Tillsonburg’s Energy Conservation and Demand Management Plan submitted in 2014 as part of the requirements of the Green Energy Act, staff continue to identify and pursue ways to reduce the Town’s energy footprint. In 2015, funding was secured through Tillsonburg Hydro’s Conservation Demand Management initiatives to execute a Detailed Engineering Study (DES) of the Tillsonburg Community Centre. I.B. Storey Inc. was hired to conduct the DES and their report was independently reviewed by the IESO. The study identified a variety of projects to achieve energy savings. The report was presented to Council in July, 2016. Council adopted the following resolution: Moved By: Councillor Rosehart Seconded By: Councillor Hayes THAT Council receive Report RCP 16-19, TCC Detailed Engineering Study Report and Recommendations; AND THAT Council authorize staff to enter a single-source contract with I. B. Storey Inc. to develop the system design and RFP specifications for an energy conservation retrofit at the Tillsonburg Community Centre. The contract was negotiated to include five phases, with a break point between phase 2 and 3 in order to secure Council authorization to proceed further. The initial phases of the contract with I.B. Storey Inc. were funded in the 2017 budget and staff received Council’s consent to proceed to tender in order to secure market pricing (RCP 17-02). No commitment beyond phase 1 and 2 of the design work has been made. With confirmed pricing now secured, Council should consider implementing the project for summer 2018 as planned. The costs secured through the procurement process are in line with the project budget that was presented in 2016 by I.B. Storey Inc. A Condensed Scope of Work is attached providing a brief overview of the project. After the design was completed, four tender packages were prepared and issued. Three of the tenders closed with at least one qualified bidder. No bids were received for RFT 2017-013 – Mechanical. The results are presented in the table below. 108 Page 3 / 8 RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retro Two vendors proposed alternative cogeneration technology but were evaluated and found non- equivalent. Neither submitted a bid. A technical review of the submissions received and confirmation of the bona fides of the proponents has confirmed the highlighted vendors be awarded the work at their tendered price. As no bids were received for the Mechanical tender, if Council authorizes the implementation of this project staff will work with I.B. Storey Inc. to confirm the scope and negotiate a change order cost with the contractor awarded the Refrigeration tender. Emergency Preparedness & Business Continuity As a designated evacuation centre for the Town and within the larger County emergency planning context, the Community Centre may be needed to shelter people in an emergency. Currently, if there is a power outage the building must be evacuated. A backup generator can be brought on site and used to provide power to some parts of the building, but the process takes time and may not be possible if the road network is affected. • Emergency Evacuation Centre – As a designated evacuation centre for the Town and within the larger County emergency planning context, it is a best practice to have on-site hydro generation capacity to keep power on in the building in an emergency. • Short-term power outages – As experienced in recent power outages, patrons in the pool or on the ice must immediately leave the building and cannot be allowed back in until power is restored. This can be quite uncomfortable when it happens in the middle of a swimming lesson or hockey game in February. The new system will make it possible to quickly restore enough power to the building to allow people to at least get changed and retrieve their belongings. (NOTE: in a fire alarm situation, everyone will still have to leave the building until allowed back in by the fire department. • Business continuity – with onsite generation in place and working all the time, most rentals, games, lessons & activities would not need to be cancelled. For example, a wedding reception or fundraising event could be allowed to continue with minimal interruption. The generation capacity will not be able to support continued operation of the ice plant or pool filtration systems in an emergency. A typical emergency backup generator installation is installed with the hope that it is never used. However it requires maintenance, fuel, regular testing, and takes up room. If continuous electrical generation is available on site, the need for additional or separate backup power is eliminated. The control systems will be sophisticated enough to monitor whether the overall costs are lower using hydro from the grid or using the natural gas powered generators instead, enabling the facility to switch to the more economical source at any given point. The investment in generating capacity will not sit idle waiting for a disaster; it will be continually deployed in a way that maximizes the benefit to the Town. Tender Bidder Bid Price Cimco Refrigeration: A Division of Toromont Industries (London)693,700$ Black & MacDonald Ltd. (Stoney Creek)698,908$ RFT 2017-12 - Automation Trane Sales Agency - N.L. Clark Sales Ltd. (London)76,450$ RFT 2017-13 - Mechanical Whitby Hydro Energy Services Corporation (Whitby)1,033,585$ E. S. Fox Limited. (Niagara Falls)2,744,168$ RFT 2017-11 - Refrigeration RFT 2017-14 - Electrical Co-Generation NO BIDS RECEIVED 109 Page 4 / 8 RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retro Timing Considerations There are several reasons for recommending approval of this project at this time: • User impact - The impact of this project on facility operations is significant. It will require the ice plant to be shut down for construction no later than the end of April. No ice will be available for summer programming for May through August. User groups need to have as much notice as possible to plan accordingly. • Regulatory approvals – The co-generation component of the project requires regulatory approval from the local utility and the Ontario Energy Board prior to construction. This process takes time and needs to be initiated as soon as possible. • 2018 budget planning – As noted above, there is considerable impact to the facility operations in 2018. Confirming this 2018 project now enables staff to incorporate the corresponding revenue and expenditure adjustments into the 2018 draft budget from the earliest stages. • Incentive programs – IESO-supported energy savings incentive and rebate programs are expected to change at the end of 2017. By initiating the project now, the rebate and incentives calculated into the project ROI will be secured; • Procurement process – The irrevocable period for the bids submitted as part of the tendering process ends on November 15, 2017. After that date the pricing is no longer secured. The successful bidders need to incorporate these large projects into their work schedule for 2018 in order to meet the required construction schedule. • Lifecycle renewal – Among other components, 2 of 3 chillers, 2 of 3 compressors and the condenser are scheduled for replacement between 2018 and 2020. As they approach their nominal end-of-life, the risk of a failure that impacts ice users increases. If Council chooses not to proceed now, the project cannot be scheduled for 2018. The prices received through the tendering process will no longer be firm, and the tenders will have to be cancelled. Service Level Improvements In addition to achieving considerable energy consumption reductions, the project incorporates several increases in service level for the residents of the Town of Tillsonburg. • Increased refrigeration capacity – the improved ice plant includes capacity to support the outdoor artificial ice pad planned by the J.L Scott McLean Legacy Fund. The current ice plant does not have the effective capacity to support that additional load. The incremental cost for this capacity is approximately $10,000. A stand-alone project to supply refrigeration for the outdoor pad would cost significantly more. • Onsite emergency power – the cogeneration turbines will provide onsite emergency backup power for the facility in case of power outage. A stand-alone standby emergency generator system of the required capacity would cost $250,000 • Increased safety – the new ice plant configuration reduces the amount of ammonia charge required to power the system by over 60%. Ammonia is an extremely hazardous substance and the potential impact of a spill or leak is dramatically reduced in the new system. There is no value that can be placed on this enhancement to staff and patron safety. • Net metering readiness – the project puts the facility in a position to take advantage of future changes to the hydro system when net metering is rolled out. This strategy is in alignment with the Future Oxford Sustainability Plan. Despite repeated applications, the facility has not yet secured a contract to generate hydro through a FIT or Micro-FIT contract for rooftop solar, which makes net metering a very attractive opportunity to reduce utility costs when it becomes available. 110 Page 5 / 8 RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retro As outlined in the bullet list above, this project not only supports needed lifecycle renewal of existing infrastructure and achieves consumption cost reductions, it brings a net service level increase to the residents of Tillsonburg in terms of capacity, safety, emergency resiliency and future readiness. Environmental Impact The project is designed to reduce electrical consumption, dependence on diesel fueled emergency backup, make more efficient use of natural gas and reduce the use of ammonia as a refrigerant. The project includes replacement of compressors, chillers and pumps in the ice plant with new, more efficient equipment and the conversion of the mini-pad to GLICE (a high-slip, low-maintenance plastic). The project also incorporates a natural gas powered co-generation turbine system. The concept behind co-generation is that the heat given off by a turbine that is generating electricity needed for the facility is captured and used for other purposes like cooling or heating. At the Community Centre, there is considerable and continuous need for heating and/or cooling water and space. The waste heat from the co-gen system will be used to reduce the need to use electrical and natural gas in other parts of the Community Centre by heating water for the pool and dressing rooms, for under floor heating to prevent frost build up, and in HVAC equipment to regulate air temperature and humidity. Initially, the pool, the Auditorium, the dressing rooms and the ice plant will be recipients of the waste heat. As HVAC equipment is replaced over time, more and more of the waste heat will be recaptured, further reducing the overall energy consumption and GHG footprint. Maximizing the Investment Asset management planning to accommodate the replacement cycle of the ice plant components like the chillers, compressors and condenser would require the equivalent of the refrigeration component of this project to be executed between 2018 and 2020. By consolidating the refrigeration work into one project there are mobilization savings. Although they make the up-front costs higher, by including the cogeneration and automation components, this project provides a way of offsetting the capital costs while achieving service level increases as noted above. The increasing maintenance costs of the aging ice plant are putting additional pressure on annual operational budgets. A recent failure in the heat exchanger supplying warm brine to prevent frost build-up under the ice pads is an example of how the current plant components are Component Installation Date Projected Replacment Date Replacement value (2017 $) Compressor 2 1996 2018 85,000$ Compressor 3 1996 2018 60,000$ Chiller 2 1991 2018 175,000$ Chiller 3 1991 2018 175,000$ Condenser 2004 2018 150,000$ Electrical Panel 2000 2020 60,000$ 6000E Controller 2015 2025 50,000$ Compressor 1 2004 2029 125,000$ Chiller 1 2004 2029 175,000$ Memorial Floor 2002 2050 600,000$ Community Floor 2004 2050 600,000$ 111 Page 6 / 8 RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retro reaching their end of life. It makes sense to replace this heat exchanger with one that will use waste heat from the co-gen system when it is online. In 2015, the Town invested in a state-of-the-art CIMCO 6000E controller for the ice plant to maximize our ability to control energy costs with the tools available in the existing ice plant. The 6000E will be redeployed in the new ice plant, but will have a much more sophisticated system to work with. In the new system, the compressors and chillers will not need replacement for 30 years, the micro-turbines will be scheduled for replacement in 20 years, and the condenser will be scheduled for replacement in 15 years. FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE The known and estimated costs of the project are provided in the table to the right. Additional external funding will be sought through the current GHG Challenge Fund opportunity, which may fund up to 50% of the eligible costs. The pre-tax total project cost including contingency is $2,337,983. This cost will be partially offset by IESO applicable rebate and incentive funds estimated at $252,200 for a projected net cost to the Town of $2,083,783. The funding model for this project is that the capital costs for implementing the project will be paid for using debt. The annual principle and interest costs for the servicing will be paid for by a corresponding reduction in energy consumption costs. The amount of debt required to finance the project will be reduced by the energy rebates and incentives received for the project. This funding model is in alignment with the Town’s Debt Management Policy to use debt to finance projects that will be repaid through operational savings. Modeling of the project using current energy costs results in a calculated annual energy cost savings of approximately $142,000. This is equal to 26% of the current (2016) annual utility cost for the facility. This amount, supplemented with savings achieved during the construction shut- down, matches the semi-annual debt servicing costs based on a 20-year debenture. An amortization schedule for Infrastructure Ontario financing based on a 20 year debenture has been attached for information purposes. The actual amount of debt placed will change to reflect the receipt of grants and rebates, and the amortization period adjusted accordingly. Starting in 2019, the annual utility budget of the facility will be reduced to offset the semi-annual payments, with the funds instead shown as a budgeted contribution to the Recreation, Culture & Parks Reserve. P&I payments will be shown in the operation budget beginning in 2019, with a contribution from the Recreation, Culture & Parks reserve to offset them. Component Refrigeration 697,370$ Mechanical*255,245$ Automation 76,450$ Co-generation 1,033,585$ Engineering 164,000$ 5% Contingency 111,333$ 2,337,983$ Rebate & Incentive offsets*(254,200)$ Total project cost**2,083,783$ Expended to date 65,600$ NOTES *Estimate **Before taxes 112 Page 7 / 8 RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retro This project will not only pay for itself but will pay for approximately $800,000 in refrigeration plant replacement costs that are required to continue current service levels and would otherwise have had to be paid through taxation. In order to provide appropriate authorizations and provide a documentation trail, staff request that this project be given pre-budget approval for inclusion in the 2018 budget. 113 Page 8 / 8 RCP 17-48 - Implementing an Energy Retro COMMUNITY STRATEGIC PLAN (CSP) IMPACT This report recommends taking actions that are in alignment with the following Objectives of the Community Strategic Plan: • Objective 1 – Excellence in Local Government • Objective 2 – Sustainable Economy • Objective 4 – Culture & Community 114 Report Title Budget Issue Paper: Utilities Cost Increases Report No. RCP 17-02 Author Rick Cox, Director of Recreation, Culture & Parks Meeting Type Budget Meeting Council Date January 10, 2017 Attachments • The Mysteries of Electricity Pricing in Ontario • Guide to Electricity Pricing in Ontario Page 1 / 3 RCP 17-02 - Budget Issue Paper - Utilities Cost Increases.docx RECOMMENDATION THAT Report RCP 17-02 – Budget Issue Paper – Utility Cost Increases be received for information. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Unit costs for utilities (electricity, gas & water) have risen over the last five years. Increases in the budget allocation for utilities have not kept up with increases in actual costs. The largest contributor to the increased cost is the increase in the unit cost of hydro. BACKGROUND The combined cost to the Town for utilities continues to rise year over year. 2012 was the last year for which the annual budget allocation for utilities was not exceeded by actual utility costs. The largest increase in cost that the Town is experiencing is for electricity. As an example, the amount the Town paid for streetlight hydro in 2012 was just over $186,000. By 2015 that amount was almost $237,000, an increase of 27% over that time period. Factors contributing to the unit rate of electricity: The electricity price portion of the bill is broken down into two price components: • Electricity Price: Also known as the spot price, the market clearing price (MCP) or the Hourly Ontario Energy Price (HEOP) • Global Adjustment: The global adjustment (GA) is the difference between the market price and the electricity price contracted by the government. It is the “top-up” that most suppliers are paid when they generate electricity. This means that as the market price goes up, the global adjustment goes down because suppliers are recovering more of their Year Budget Actual*Difference 2011 905,999$ 915,051$ -1% 2012 935,383$ 881,010$ 6% 2013 843,630$ 895,679$ -6% 2014 866,250$ 872,656$ -1% 2015 949,921$ 966,254$ -2% 2016 980,500$ 1,052,837$ -7% * 2016 value is projected as Jan-Nov 2016 actual plus 105% of Dec 2015 actuals 115 Page 2 / 3 RCP 17-02 - Budget Issue Paper - Utilities Cost Increases.docx costs from the market. As a consumer, the Town pays both the electricity price and the global adjustment. Publications prepared by the Environmental Commissioner of Ontario and Bruce Power are attached with this issue paper as additional explanation. This cost/kWh graph illustrates the unit cost increase that is being experienced for our largest hydro accounts at the Complex and for streetlights. For Jan-Nov this year, the cost for hydro at the Complex is approximately $363,000 at an average unit cost of $0.152. If the 2013 average price of $0.119 was in effect, the same hydro would have cost approximately $287,000. Efforts to reduce the cost: As per the Town’s Energy Conservation and Demand Management plan approved in 2014, there are continual efforts to reduce consumption of utilities through operational process changes and selection of new equipment. An example of a process change that results in substantial annual consumption savings was delaying the start-up of the Memorial ice rink until after the Shriners’ annual Pork BBQ. This collaboration between the Town, the Shriners and the Agricultural Society has permanently reduced the amount of hydro used at the Complex during the period of Aug-Nov by 7-9% depending on the weather. While there has been ‘cost avoidance’ this has translated into little actual cost savings, as the 2016 hydro cost for that period is 21% higher for 7% less hydro than in 2013. Other process changes that have been implemented include: • eliminating winter use of Summer Place (hydro savings) • using passive solar to pre-heat water for the Waterpark (natural gas savings) Since hydro is such a large component of the overall town utility cost it has and continues to be hydro consumption reductions that is the main focus. Further, the largest hydro account is the Complex, so the majority of interventions and changes are being made there in order to realize the largest proportional benefit. The 2017 draft capital budget includes two energy conservation-related projects to continue efforts to reduce consumption. One will replace the high-pressure sodium lights above both rinks with new LED technology. The second is the start of implementing the energy retrofit project for the ice plant and pool HVAC that has been developed out of the I. B. Storey Inc. study. In 2017, the design will be completed and tendered to secure firm costs for construction in the summer of 2018. 116 Page 3 / 3 RCP 17-02 - Budget Issue Paper - Utilities Cost Increases.docx CONSULTATION/COMMUNICATION N/A FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE If the budget allocation for utility costs is inadequate, there is an impact on the Town’s in-year financial position. COMMUNITY STRATEGIC PLAN (CSP) IMPACT This issue paper provides information in alignment with the following Objective of the Community Strategic Plan: • Objective 1 – Excellence in Local Government 117 CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY ONTARIO OFFICE: 400 Applewood Crescent Suite 100 Vaughan, ON. L4K 0C3 Phone: 519-800-0454 Fax: 647-438-5707 TOWN OF TILLSONBURG MAJOR INTEGRATION PROJECT CONDENSED SCOPE OF WORK CSOW 17-011 TOWN OF TILLSONBURG, ONTARIO CANADA VERSION 2.0 OCTOBER 16, 2017 Prepared by: I. B. Storey Inc. Email: info@ibstorey.ca Website: www.ibstorey.ca ATLANTIC OFFICE: 151 Great George St., Suite 302 Charlottetown, PEC1A 4K8 Phone: 902-367-3545 Fax: 902-367-3546 118 C ONDENSED SCOPE OF WORK MAJOR INTEGRATION PROJECT Town of Tillsonburg CSOW 17-011 Revision: 2.0 Date: 16-OCT-17 I.B.Storey Inc. CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY Professional Energy Solutions Version 2.0 MANDATE & OBJECTIVE The intent of this project to provide a life cycle replacement to aging refrigeration equipment while upgrading to a modern, high efficiency refrigeration system, as well as modifications to ventilation to provide demand control ventilation (DCV) and reduced fan consumption using variable frequency drives (VFDs) on fans. Micro co-gen turbines are to be installed to reduce grid-based electricity consumption, provide back-up power in the event of emergencies, and to recover waste heat for building heating. The intent of this system is to provide:  New, high efficiency refrigeration plant  Micro Co-Gen system to provide back-up power and recover waste heat  Demand control ventilation in high demand areas  Artificial ice on the small slapshot pad for reduced refrigeration load  Pool pump controls upgrades to improve efficiency  Tie-ins and capacity for an additional outdoor ice sheet in the future Site address: Tillsonburg Community Centre 45 Hardy Avenue Tillsonburg, ON N4G 3W9 119 C ONDENSED SCOPE OF WORK MAJOR INTEGRATION PROJECT Town of Tillsonburg CSOW 17-011 Revision: 2.0 Date: 16-OCT-17 I.B.Storey Inc. CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY Professional Energy Solutions Version 2.0 REFRIGERATION New refrigeration plant cooling to provide a lifecycle replacement to aging equipment, improve efficiency of the refrigeration system, and reduce annual operating costs. Equipment to be sized for potential upgrade to include an outdoor ice surface as a later expansion. Two (2) new Mycom N4MII compressors at 1125 RPM and one (1) new Mycom N4MII Compressor at 880 RPM.  Existing Horsepower: 275 HP Existing Capacity: 200 TR New Horsepower: 275 HP New Capacity: 230 TR (15% increase in capacity)  New high efficiency reciprocating compressors to provide additional capacity for the same power consumption.  Designed with extra capacity for future outdoor ice sheet expansion and additional air conditioning capacity. New Plate and Frame Chiller with integrated surge drum for rink cooling.  Capacity: 260 TR  High efficiency plate and frame chiller allowing a higher suction temperature, reducing the load on the compressors.  “U-Turn” integrated surge drum, reducing the ammonia charge needed in the system while providing a relatively small footprint for the chiller. Variable Frequency Drives (VFDs) and inverter duty motors for the two (2) existing brine pumps.  VFDs to be used in conjunction with temperature sensors to slow the speed of the pumps to deliver the required rink cooling at lower power consumption. New Evapco LSC-355E Evaporative Condenser for lifecycle replacement  Capacity: 3,809 MBH @ 96.3°F CT / 78°F WB  New condenser to replace the aged existing unit, which operates at reduced capacity. New Condenser Water Tank for lifecycle replacement  Capacity: 340 USGAL  Size to be confirmed on site by contractors. 120 C ONDENSED SCOPE OF WORK MAJOR INTEGRATION PROJECT Town of Tillsonburg CSOW 17-011 Revision: 2.0 Date: 16-OCT-17 I.B.Storey Inc. CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY Professional Energy Solutions Version 2.0 New Condenser Pump for lifecycle replacement  Power: 15 HP  Flow: 515 USGPM  Head: 50 ft. H2O  Speed: 1770 RPM BACK-UP GENERATOR / CO-GENERATION SYSTEM Three (3) new Capstone C65 Micro Turbine natural gas generators to provide on-site emergency back-up and co-gen operation for cost savings.  Current Back-Up Capacity: 175 kW (Off-site)  Capstone Back-Up Capacity: 195kW  Integrated heat recovery infrastructure for micro co-gen application.  High efficiency micro turbines with air bearings, producing low noise levels and requiring little maintenance (<6 hours per year, 99% uptime). HEAT RECOVERY INFRASTRUCTURE Complete piping, valves and controls to recover heat from the new micro turbine generators to provide 200°F glycol to heat loads throughout the building. Existing heating equipment kept in place to offer maximum flexibility to provide heating through heat co-gen heat recovery or existing gas burners.  Pool Room Boiler heat exchanger to provide 319 kW of supplemental heating to the existing boiler loop  3 HP Pool Room Heat Exchanger pump to provide flow through the heat exchanger  Refrigeration Room hot water heat exchanger to provide 211 kW of supplemental heating to the existing hot water system  Lion’s Auditorium heating coil in existing duct work to provide 50 kW of supplemental heating to Auditorium.  HRU-1 heating coil to provide 132 kW of supplemental heating to the arena dressing rooms.  HVDE heating coil to provide 107 kW of supplemental heating to the concourse areas near the arenas.  Rink refrigeration heat exchanger sized to match existing loads. To be sized by contractor in conjunction with I.B. Storey.  5 HP heat recovery pump equipped with VFD and controls to maintain heat recovery loop temperatures and reduce operating costs. 121 C ONDENSED SCOPE OF WORK MAJOR INTEGRATION PROJECT Town of Tillsonburg CSOW 17-011 Revision: 2.0 Date: 16-OCT-17 I.B.Storey Inc. CONFIDENTIAL & PROPRIETARY Professional Energy Solutions Version 2.0 ARTIFICIAL ICE FOR THE SLAP SHOT PAD Remove cooling to the floor and replace the current ice surface with a Glice artificial ice surface that requires no refrigeration, cutting energy costs from maintaining unnecessarily thick ice.  Low maintenance required – regular cleaning and annual pressure washing to maintain ice surface.  Keep the existing air transfer fan to the arena zone to keep air temperatures consistent. DEMAND CONTROL VENTILATION (DCV) AND DEHUMIDIFICATION IMPROVEMENTS Improved controls to provide more fresh air based on zone CO2 measurements to maximize user comfort and minimize energy costs, with improvements to pool dehumidification logic to use outdoor air for dehumidification whenever possible.  New VFDs on fans from ERV-1, HRU-1, HVDE-1 and HRV-1, CO2 sensors and enhanced controls for the following areas:  Pool dressing room  Pool zone  Arena dressing room  Arena area concourse. POOL PUMP VFD AND TURBIDITY CONTROLS Pool Pump to be equipped with a new 10 HP inverter duty motor and VFD with controls to adjust rate of filtration based on measurements from a new turbidity sensor, with a minimum speed to exceed minimum required filtration levels. 122 Amortizing Debenture Schedule $2,100,000.00 20 Payment Frequency Loan Type 3.4900% Semi Annual Amortizing 11/1/2018 Tillsonburg 11/1/2038 Organization Name Maturity Date (m/d/yyyy) Principal Amount Annual Interest Rate Loan Term (Year) Debenture Date (m/d/yyyy) 5/1/2019 $73,375.70 $36,730.70 $36,645.00 $2,063,269.30 11/1/2019 $73,375.70 $37,371.65 $36,004.05 $2,025,897.65 5/1/2020 $73,375.70 $38,023.79 $35,351.91 $1,987,873.86 11/2/2020 $73,375.70 $38,687.30 $34,688.40 $1,949,186.56 5/3/2021 $73,375.70 $39,362.39 $34,013.31 $1,909,824.17 11/1/2021 $73,375.70 $40,049.27 $33,326.43 $1,869,774.90 5/2/2022 $73,375.70 $40,748.13 $32,627.57 $1,829,026.77 11/1/2022 $73,375.70 $41,459.18 $31,916.52 $1,787,567.59 5/1/2023 $73,375.70 $42,182.65 $31,193.05 $1,745,384.94 11/1/2023 $73,375.70 $42,918.73 $30,456.97 $1,702,466.21 5/1/2024 $73,375.70 $43,667.66 $29,708.04 $1,658,798.55 11/1/2024 $73,375.70 $44,429.67 $28,946.03 $1,614,368.88 5/1/2025 $73,375.70 $45,204.96 $28,170.74 $1,569,163.92 11/3/2025 $73,375.70 $45,993.79 $27,381.91 $1,523,170.13 5/1/2026 $73,375.70 $46,796.38 $26,579.32 $1,476,373.75 11/2/2026 $73,375.70 $47,612.98 $25,762.72 $1,428,760.77 5/3/2027 $73,375.70 $48,443.82 $24,931.88 $1,380,316.95 11/1/2027 $73,375.70 $49,289.17 $24,086.53 $1,331,027.78 5/1/2028 $73,375.70 $50,149.27 $23,226.43 $1,280,878.51 11/1/2028 $73,375.70 $51,024.37 $22,351.33 $1,229,854.14 5/1/2029 $73,375.70 $51,914.75 $21,460.95 $1,177,939.39 11/1/2029 $73,375.70 $52,820.66 $20,555.04 $1,125,118.73 Payment Date Total Payment Principal Amount Interest Amount Principal Balance Printed on: 10/15/2017 15:34:52 Page 1 of 2 123 11/1/2029 $73,375.70 $52,820.66 $20,555.04 $1,125,118.73 5/1/2030 $73,375.70 $53,742.38 $19,633.32 $1,071,376.35 11/1/2030 $73,375.70 $54,680.18 $18,695.52 $1,016,696.17 5/1/2031 $73,375.70 $55,634.35 $17,741.35 $961,061.82 11/3/2031 $73,375.70 $56,605.17 $16,770.53 $904,456.65 5/3/2032 $73,375.70 $57,592.93 $15,782.77 $846,863.72 11/1/2032 $73,375.70 $58,597.93 $14,777.77 $788,265.79 5/2/2033 $73,375.70 $59,620.46 $13,755.24 $728,645.33 11/1/2033 $73,375.70 $60,660.84 $12,714.86 $667,984.49 5/1/2034 $73,375.70 $61,719.37 $11,656.33 $606,265.12 11/1/2034 $73,375.70 $62,796.37 $10,579.33 $543,468.75 5/1/2035 $73,375.70 $63,892.17 $9,483.53 $479,576.58 11/1/2035 $73,375.70 $65,007.09 $8,368.61 $414,569.49 5/1/2036 $73,375.70 $66,141.46 $7,234.24 $348,428.03 11/3/2036 $73,375.70 $67,295.63 $6,080.07 $281,132.40 5/1/2037 $73,375.70 $68,469.94 $4,905.76 $212,662.46 11/2/2037 $73,375.70 $69,664.74 $3,710.96 $142,997.72 5/3/2038 $73,375.70 $70,880.39 $2,495.31 $72,117.33 11/1/2038 $73,375.78 $72,117.33 $1,258.45 $0.00 Infrastructure Ontario does not warrant or make any representations regarding the use or the results of the use of the calculator found herein in terms of their correctness, accuracy, timeliness, reliability, or otherwise. Under no circumstances shall Infrastructure Ontario be held liable for any damages, whether direct, incidental, indirect, special, or consequential, and including, without limitation, lost revenues or lost profits, arising from or in connection with your use or reliance on the calculator found herein. This calculator is provided for general illustrative purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. To take into account your specific circumstances, you should obtain professional investment, legal and/or tax advice, as appropriate. DISCLAIMER: Payment Date Total Payment Principal Amount Interest Amount Principal Balance $2,935,028.08 $2,100,000.00 $835,028.08Total Printed on: 10/15/2017 15:34:52 Page 2 of 2 124 Report Title Visitor Parking Improvements at OPP Station Report No. RCP 17-50 Author Rick Cox, Director of Recreation, Culture & Parks Meeting Type Council Meeting Council Date November 13, 2017 Attachments Page 1 / 3 RCP 17-50 - Visitor Parking Improvements RECOMMENDATION: THAT Council receive Report RCP 17-50 - Visitor Parking Improvements at OPP Station; AND THAT the costs associated with implementing additional visitor parking at the OPP Station are considered during the 2018 budget deliberations. BACKGROUND At the January 23, 2017 Council meeting, the Chair of the Police Services Board advised Council members that the location of the existing island within the visitor parking area impacts traffic flow and snow removal operations. This causes visitors to use the rear parking lot which is designated for police personnel only. Town staff were requested to review the visitor parking at the OPP station and determine if additional parking stalls can be accommodated. SUMMARY Tillsonburg Zoning By-Law 3295 requires that at least one (1) accessible parking stall be provided, which is already present on the subject property. The Zoning By-law also requires that each parking stall be a minimum of 2.7m wide and a minimum of 5.5m in length, while a parking aisle is to be a minimum of 7.3m in width. Based on these requirements, Figure 1 illustrates the proposed visitor parking configuration, where six (6) new stalls can be accommodated. Planning staff have confirmed that the proposed visitor parking lot improvements at the OPP station would not require Site Plan approval. The proposed visitor parking reconfiguration scope of work would include the removal of the center grassed area, new curbing and asphalt with the additional parking stall area and some site restoration work. The cost to improve the visitor parking lot is estimated at $25,800. The lease between the Town and the Government of Ontario with respect to the OPP station is clear that leasehold improvements initiated by the tenant are to be paid for by the tenant, while leasehold improvements initiated by the landlord are the responsibility of the landlord. In this 125 Page 2 / 3 RCP 17-50 - Visitor Parking Improvements case, while the suggested alterations are supported by the local OPP administration, they have been requested by the Police Services Board and are therefore not initiated by the tenant. CONSULTATION/COMMUNICATION Operations and Facility staff were consulted regarding this request. FINANCIAL IMPACT/FUNDING SOURCE Staff recommend that the capital budget implications of approximately $25,800 associated with the proposed visitor parking lot improvements are considered during the 2018 budget deliberations. A capital project under the Police Services Budget has been inserted into the draft budget documents. The six parking spots created by this alteration will cost approximately $4,300 each to create. COMMUNITY STRATEGIC PLAN (CSP) This report provides information in alignment with the following Objectives of the Community Strategic Plan: • Objective 1 – Excellence in Local Government • Objective 2 – Sustainable Economy • Objective 4 – Culture & Community 126 Page 3 / 3 RCP 17-50 - Visitor Parking Improvements 127 = ATTENDANCE Shane Curtis John Prno John Bamford Jim Hayes Gord Roesch Stephen Molnar Mel Getty Staff: Becky Turrill, Secretary MEMBERS ABSENT/REGRETS Jeff Smith, Fire Chief Mike Dean 1. Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 7:05p.m. 2. Adoption of Agenda Moved By: John Prno Seconded By: John Bamford Resolution #1 THAT the agenda for the September 12, 2017 meeting as amended be approved. CARRIED 3. Disclosures of Pecuniary Interest and the General Nature Thereof - None 4. Adoption of Minutes of Previous Meeting Moved By: Gord Roesch Seconded By: Jim Hayes Resolution #2 The Corporation of the Town of Tillsonburg FIRE STRAT PLANNING COMMITTEE September 12, 2017 7:00 p.m. Fire Station Training Room 80 Concession Street East MINUTES 128 Fire Services Strategic Planning Committee Meeting Minutes - 2 - THAT the minutes of the July 11, 2017 meeting be adopted. CARRIED 5. General Business & Reports 5.1. Hazard Risk Assessment 5.1.1. Chief Smith to have stats on response time 2002 vs 2016 along with # of responders per call 5.1.2. Summary – update with suggestions 5.2. Needs Assessment 5.2.1. Deferred to October meeting 6. Next Meeting The next meeting of the Fire Services Strategic Planning Committee will be on October 17, 2017 at 7:00pm. 7. Adjournment Moved By: John Bamford Seconded By: Gord Roesch Resolution #3 THAT the Fire Services Strategic Planning Committee meeting of October 17 , 2017 be adjourned at 8:25p.m. CARRIED 129 = ATTENDANCE, Penny Esseltine MEMBERS PRESENT: Ken Butcher, Penny Esseltine, Robert Marsden, Christine Nagy, Sue Saelens, Maurice Verhoeve, Paul Wareing MEMBERS ABSENT/REGRETS: Charles Baldwin, Paul DeCloet, Marian Smith 1. Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 9:03 a.m. 2. Adoption of Agenda Moved By: C. Nagy Seconded By: P. Wareing Proposed Resolution #1_ THAT the Agenda for the Heritage, Beautification & Cemetery Advisory Committee meeting of October 5, 2017, be adopted with additions. Carried. 3. Disclosures of Pecuniary Interest and the General Nature Thereof: None 4. Adoption of Minutes of Previous Meeting Moved By: S. Selens Seconded By: M. Verhoeve Proposed Resolution #2 THAT the minutes for the September 7, 2017 meeting be approved. Carried. 5. Delegations and Presentations - none 6. General Business & Reports 6.1 Report from Tillsonburg Horticultural Society (THS) – C. Nagy reported that BIA did a survey of all of the flower pots large and small and shared some of the results with us - approval was general comments - maybe more colour in the pots with different flowers added or ribbons etc. Many would do it again to beautify downtown Tillsonburg. Question was asked about the dead spaces left by trees on Broadway St - what is being done to replace them? BIA looking to this and into lighting through some infrastructure that we have talked about for Broadway St. We must look at presenting a budget to Council for 2018 program and doing a power point presentation, sharing survey results, etc. Members of H&B along with the Hort Society need to be at Council when discussing a budget for next year's beautification project. Moved By: C. Nagy Seconded by: P. Wareing Proposed Resolution #3 The Corporation of the Town of Tillsonburg HERITAGE, BEAUTIFICATION & CEMETERY ADVISORY COMMITTEE October 5, 2017 9:00 a.m. Corporate Annex 200 Broadway MINUTES 130 THAT the Heritage, Beautification & Cemetery Advisory Committee accept the report as submitted. Carried 7. Correspondence 8. Other Business 8.1 Heritage Designations – church windows as a possible designation for H&B to consider - St. Paul's church to look at seriously - Bob defer to next meeting 8.2 Significant Tree program – Brochure of Significant Trees - where is that now and where do we want to go with this project - Marian could possibly speak to this 8.3 Committee Vacancy - Ken Butcher will possibly be taking her place once he goes through the application channels. A card or letter from H&B should go out to Janet for her years of work 8.1 Invasive species – Invasive Species of trees growing in Tillsonburg - Corey to address this issue as to a plan of action 8.2 Kiwanis sign at Coronation Park falling apart - a possible hazard and liability - Corey to look into this matter 8.3 Laurel Beechey interested in projects at cemetery - would like to be informed so that she can contribute in some way 8.4 Donna Scanlan request to removal of broken branches and downed trees within Tillsonburg being unsightly and a liability - discussed briefly as to this being an operational job and has nothing to do with this committee - Corey to address this e-mail 9. Next Meeting The next meeting of the Heritage, Beautification & Cemetery Advisory Committee will be on November 2, 2017 at 9:00 a.m. in the Annex Meeting Room, 200 Broadway. 10. Adjournment Moved By: S. Saelens Proposed Resolution #4 THAT the Meeting of Heritage, Beautification & Cemetery Advisory Committee on October 5, 2017 be adjourned at 10:10 a.m. Carried. 131 = ATTENDANCE Henry Atkinson, Euclid Benoit, Andre Brisson, Valerie Durston, Geoffrey Lee, Rick Lee, John Prno, Jeremy Stockmans, Richard Van Maele Staff: Annette Murray, Dan Locke Guests: Michael Desroches, Jay Heaman (By Skype) MEMBERS ABSENT/REGRETS Mel Getty, Chris Rosehart 1. Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 5:04 p.m. Euclid Benoit sat as the Chair and John Prno acted as Recording Secretary for the meeting. Euclid opened the meeting by introducing Dan Locke as the Town’s new Manager of Public Works, and the Committee’s Staff Liaison. 2. Adoption of Agenda Resolution #1 Moved By: Richard Van Maele Seconded By: Jeremy Stockmans THAT the Agenda as prepared for the Airport Advisory Committee meeting of October 12, 2017, be adopted. Carried 3. Disclosures of Pecuniary Interest and the General Nature Thereof None Declared 4. Adoption of Minutes of Previous Meeting The Corporation of the Town of Tillsonburg AIRPORT ADVISORY COMMITTEE October 12, 2017 5:00 p.m. Tillsonburg Regional Airport Boardroom 244411 Airport Rd., South-West Oxford MINUTES 132 Airport Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes, October 12, 2017 - 2 - 4.1. Minutes of the Meeting of March 23, 2017. Resolution #2 Moved By: Andre Brisson Seconded By: Richard Van Maele THAT the Minutes of the Airport Advisory Committee Meeting of March 23, 2017, be approved. Carried 5. Delegations and Presentations 5.1. Michael Desroches, CEO, Tillsonburg Hydro Michael presented a comprehensive summary of the hydro limitations at the Airport (presentation attached). The Airport presently exceeds Hydro One’s Conditions of Service, with five transformers on the property exceeding 200kVA. As a result, Hydro One has capped growth to this location. Once a property has exceeded these conditions, the property owner needs to own all of the power assets within. Previous discussions had led the Committee to understand that this “re-powering” initiative could cost as much as $1 million. Michael has clarified in discussion with Hydro One that the two conventional options, i.e., purchasing the aging Hydro One infrastructure and continuing to use it, or purchasing and having the Town replace with new infrastructure, would cost under $100,000. There are also opportunities to partner and take advantage of government programs to reduce the cost to generate electricity and contribute to the improvement of climate change. In summary, Airport growth is achievable, but will require investment. 5.2. Jay Heaman, Manager of Strategic Initiatives, Oxford County Jay concurred with Michael’s comments and started by discussing the County’s adopted commitment to 100% renewable energy by 2050, and the Town’s documented interest in partnering with the County on green energy initiatives. He went on to discuss how the timing of our discussions was ideal, given the number of funding opportunities pending. Among them: • Hydro One has approached the County to see if there are projects they could partner together on. They have a new senior management goal to work on micro-grid development on customer property. • Smart Cities Canada has $300 million in Federal funding available for green energy projects. 133 Airport Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes, October 12, 2017 - 3 - • Up to $10 million per project is available through the Ontario Ministry of the Environment Greenhouse Gas Reduction program. Weaning hangars from propane heating to renewable energy (geothermal) would qualify. • The Oxford Community Co-Operative Foundation is also interested in green energy partnerships locally. Timing is critical as some of these projects have application timelines forthcoming in 2018. Priority should be on measuring baseline hydro usage by hour of day through a real-time reporting application. Many reasonable technologies are available, or a reputable company can be hired to do the study. Once this data is in hand, a Blue Sky think tank involving the Committee and other interested stakeholders, could be convened to discuss options and develop a plan for moving forward. The Town and County could work jointly on funding submissions. Resolution #3 Moved By: Valerie Durston Seconded By: Rick Lee THAT the Committee explore the cost of monitoring hydro consumption, and continue to work with Michael Desroches and Jay Heaman on opportunities for Green Energy in developing Airport Hydro options going forward. Carried 6. General Business & Reports 6.1. Update on Airport Activities As the Committee had not met for the past six months, Annette Murray provided an update on airport activities since the last meeting: • The Fuel Card Lock System was installed in May. Staff have worked through a number of issues including user familiarity and poor WiFi coverage, but most of the kinks have now been worked out. • Crack sealing of the entire runway and apron have now been completed as per the capital budget. The plan is to include an amount annually to ensure the condition is maintained. • After having received four responses to the RFP, Council has approved the agricultural land use contract with a Norwich company. The 5 year term is for $260/acre, a reduction from the previous $385/acre, but on par with what is 134 Airport Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes, October 12, 2017 - 4 - expected at area airports. The new contract results in reduced annual revenue of approximately $51,000. • Work is underway on renovations to the reception area in the terminal building. Due to the reduction in staff on duty, the large reception desk is no longer needed, and is being removed. Staff will work out of the office as needed, and additional seating will be provided in the reclaimed space. • No options have been found to improve the maintenance (rolling) of the grass runways. The Woodstock Airport roller was found not to be available and the traditional small roller was used again this spring. No complaints about runway conditions have been received to date. 6.2. Committee Vacancy With the receipt of Donna Scanlan’s resignation from the Committee, discussion took place on the need for a replacement. As the Committee has strong membership well in excess of the requirements in the Terms of Reference, and as Donna’s position was not from one of the stakeholder groups with minimum membership numbers, the Committee felt there was no need to add a new member at this time. Resolution # 4 Moved By: Andre Brisson Seconded By: Valerie Durston THAT, no additional Airport Advisory Committee member be added at this time. Carried 7. Correspondence None Received 8. Other Business 8.1. Terms of Reference As Committee Terms of Reference should be reviewed annually, and as this was last done May 5, 2016, the Secretary distributed copies of the current Terms of Reference for review prior to, and discussion at the next Committee meeting. 135 Airport Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes, October 12, 2017 - 5 - 8.2. Taxiway Condition Discussion took place regarding the deteriorating condition of the East-West Taxiway in the area north of the Harvard hangar. Annette Murray noted this was not on the current capital work plan, but would review the request. 8.3. Hangar Numbering The lack of hangar numbers to aid emergency services in locating a specific location was discussed. Staff have been waiting for finalization of the Airport Master Plan to number the buildings, but after discussion it was decided to temporarily number the hangars using the existing numbers. Annette Murray will source numbers and apply in a standard position easily seen from the paved access to each hangar. Upon finalization of the Master Plan, consideration will be given to a large sign on the entrance road to clarify building locations. 8.4. Colour of Miller Hanger Discussion took place about the exterior colour of the new hangar being a shade lighter than that required of tenant buildings, and the precedent being set for following other Airport rules if this one is disregarded. Dan Locke will take this issue forward to senior management for discussion. 9. Closed Session No actions requiring documentation. 10. Next Meeting The next meeting of the Airport Advisory Committee will be on Monday, November 20, 2017 at 5:00 p.m. 11. Adjournment Resolution #4 Moved By: Rick Lee Seconded By: Richard Van Maele THAT the Airport Advisory Committee Meeting of October 12, 2017, be adjourned at 6:30 p.m. Carried 136 = Attendance: Peter Staley, Chair, Mike Cerna, Robert Doerr, Michael Kadey, Margaret McCrimmon Regrets: Councillor Stephenson, Scot Richardson Staff: Donna Wilson, Town Clerk, 1. Call to Order The meeting was called to order at 3:05 p.m. 2. Adoption of Agenda 5.4 Downtown parking study was added to the agenda. Resolution #1 Moved By: Mike Cerna Seconded By: Margaret McCrimmon THAT the Agenda as prepared for the Accessibility Advisory Committee meeting of October 17, 2017, be adopted. Carried 3. Disclosures of Pecuniary Interest and the General Nature Thereof No disclosures of pecuniary interest were declared. 4. Adoption of Minutes of Previous Meeting – June 20, 2017 Resolution #2 Moved By: Robert Doerr Seconded By: Michael Kadey THAT the Accessibility Advisory Committee Meeting Minutes of June 20, 2017, be approved. Carried The Corporation of the Town of Tillsonburg ACCESSIBILITY ADVISORY COMMITTEE October 17, 2017 3:00 p.m. Board Room Customer Service Centre, Tillsonburg MINUTES 137 Accessibility Advisory Committee Meeting – Agenda - 2 - 5. General Business & Reports 5.1 Enabling Accessibility Fund Project Submission The Town is still awaiting word regarding the Enabling Accessibility Fund Project Submission according to the Director of Recreation Culture & Parks. 5.2 Community Improvement Plan – Accessibility Renovation Grant Eric Gilbert, Senior Planner appeared before the committee to explain the CIP Accessibility Renovation Grant. CIP incentive has an accessibility fund for grants up to $3,000 to improve existing buildings. The Town Development commissioner receives applications and processes them accordingly. Council sets a yearly budget for CIP grants. It may be advisable that this type of CIP grant application come to this committee for review and endorsement. The committee members were given the opportunity to asks the Planner questions Information was provided regarding the process and available funds. Suggestion was to put a ramp in the front of the Town Centre Mall. It was also suggested that the mall install automatic sliding doors as well. The Mall would be eligible for this grant request. In the year 2025 all buildings must be accessible. The Building code will be changing in 2018 and it is likely that accessible requirements for buildings will be increased. Delivery trucks that block ramps are liable for an infraction. Issues can be logged in ACR through the Tillsonburg Customer Service Centre. Town new band shell does not currently have a ramp. It was noted that the original plans indicate a ramp, the ramp will be implemented in the near future. 5.3 Update Accessible Corporate Office The Corporate office is fully accessible in terms of an automatic door, access to all offices and Council chambers are also now accessible. 138 Accessibility Advisory Committee Meeting – Agenda - 3 - 5.4 Downtown parking study Study will be underway soon. The study will include a review of accessible stalls, curb cuts and downtown parking lots in terms of where accessible spots should be located. Handicap parking spots often block the ramp, this is an issue which will be reviewed. Audible signals are also going in at Oxford and Broadway and an audible aspect incorporated into the cross walk across from the Mall to the Library. The plan is to add accessible and audible walkways throughout the downtown. It was suggested that the plan be brought to this committee for review and comment. It may be valuable for a member of the committee to be involved in terms of consulting and accessibility. Roundtable It was noted that some of the intersection buttons to change the light to walk are not working. Staff to review. It was noted that accessible parking at the A & W on Broadway is not usable. Staff to review the original site plan to determine if there have been changes made which affected the compliance. 6. Next Meeting The next meeting of the Accessibility Advisory Committee will be held on Tuesday, November 14, 2017 at 3:00 p.m. in the Board Room, Customer Service Centre. 7. Adjournment Resolution #3 Moved By: Margaret McCrimmon Seconded By: Mike Cerna THAT the October 17, 2017 Accessibility Advisory Committee meeting be adjourned at 4: 21 p.m. Carried 139 140 141 142 143 144 145 1 TILLSONBURG POLICE SERVICES BOARD Minutes MEETING: GENERAL MEETING PLACE: Tillsonburg, OPP Detachment Boardroom DATE: Wednesday, September 20, 2017 TIME: 8:00 a.m. AGENDA ITEM DISCUSSION OUTCOME/ACTION 1 Call to Order The Chair called the General session of the Board to order at 8:02 am. 2 Attendance Present: Regrets: Larry Scanlan, Chair Ann Loker Greg Horvath Councilor Chris Rosehart Mayor Steve Molnar Becky Turrill, Secretary Inspector Hymers None 3 Declaration of Pecuniary Interest None declared 4 Approval of Agenda The Agenda was presented to the Board for approval. On motion made by Mayor Molnar, seconded by Ann Locker, and carried, the Agenda was approved. 5 Approval of Previous Minutes The Minutes of a meeting of the Board held on August 16, 2017 were presented to the Board for approval. On motion made by Greg Horvath, seconded by Councilor Rosehart and carried the Minutes of the meeting held on August 16, 2017 were approved. 6 Issues Arising from previous minutes None 7 Presentations / Delegations None 8 Correspondence None 9 Financial None 146 2 AGENDA ITEM DISCUSSION OUTCOME/ACTION 10 Detachment Commander Reports  OPP contract Policing - Tillsonburg Inspector Hymers presented the August 2017 contract statistics and memorandum which reported: • 66 provincial offences tickets written • 59.25 hours of Foot Patrol Members of the OPP attended 607 calls for service with an 87.8% clearance rate.  Inspector Hymers presented the Tickets Written in Tillsonburg for the month of August 2017 report: • Speeding, 12 • Fail to Stop, 3 • Plate/Permit/Insurance, 32 • Trespass/Intox in Public, 1 • Careless, 0 • Seatbelt, 1 • Hand Held Device, 1 • Fail to Yield / Improper turn, 11 • Other, 5 Total for August 2017, 66  Inspector Hymers presented the OPP Auxiliary Monthly Unit Summary for August 2017 • Total Hours within Tillsonburg 25  Crime Stoppers of Oxford Inc. Report Inspector Hymers presented the report for Oxford Crime Stoppers for August 2017. Monthly Tip Statistics for August 2017 Total Calls Received, 30 Woodstock PS Tips , 7 OPP Tips, 12 Assigned out to other Crime Stoppers Programs , 1 Meetings/Events Attended in May • Crime Stoppers Monthly meeting – August 8, 2017 • Woodstock Street Festival Media Relations • Crime of the week – sent to local media including Social media and website 147 3 AGENDA ITEM DISCUSSION OUTCOME/ACTION 10 cont’d Fundraising • Golf Tournament – September 14, 2017 Promotions • IDCI Art class poster contest – Postponed to Fall 2017 Upcoming Events • Oxford County Farm Show – September 12-14, 2017 • Golf Tournament – September 14, 2017  Haldimand Norfolk Crime Stoppers: Monthly report distributed for Board information (August) 11 Committee Reports None 12 OAPSB 13  Marijuana Dispensary Legislation Update given by Chair L. Scanlan  Fentanyl Lecture- October 4, 2017 – Tillsonburg Community Centre – Lion’s Auditorium  Letter of support to Council re: Free standing generator for the Community Centre  Bike Auction Inspector Hymers to get date to L. Scanlan  Visitor Parking Lot - Update Kevin Deleebeck to look after.  Crime Stoppers Golf Game – good turn out TPSB sent a team of four and Chair Scanlan attended the BBQ  Long Load Legislation – Update given  Auxiliary BBQ Inspector Hymers to get date for the board  Two Retirement Parties Crime Analyst Cst. James Robb Sgt. George Musikov  Take Back the Night – Thursday September 21 @ Clock Tower – OPP to escort  OPP/Fire Parking Lot Thefts Remind all officers and Firefighters to lock their vehicles  Fire Hall Electronic Signs – Possibility of the TPSB to use the sign as well 148 4 AGENDA ITEM DISCUSSION OUTCOME/ACTION  Shopping Carts – located all over town Chair to present findings from previous Board discussion at October Board meeting 14 Date of Next Meeting Wednesday, October 18, 2017 15 Adjournment On motion made by Mayor Molnar, seconded by Councilor Rosehart and carried, the meeting was adjourned at 9:07 a.m. _______________________________ __________________________________ Larry Scanlan, Chair Becky Turrill, Secretary 149 THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF TILLSONBURG BY-LAW NUMBER 4147 A BY-LAW to amend By-Law 3876, to Define the Mandate, Membership, and Meeting Procedures for Committees Established by The Corporation of the Town of Tillsonburg. WHEREAS The Town of Tillsonburg is desirous of amending By-Law 3876; AND WHEREAS it is deemed necessary and expedient to amend Schedule A of By- Law 3876; NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT the Council of The Corporation of the Town of Tillsonburg enacts as follows: 1. THAT Schedule A to By-Law 3876 be amended as attached hereto; 2. THAT the amendments to Schedule A of By-Law 3876 are hereby declared to be part of that By-Law as if written therein; 3. THAT this by-law comes into full force and effect upon the day of passing. READ A FIRST AND SECOND TIME THIS 13th DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2017. READ A THIRD AND FINAL TIME AND PASSED THIS 13th DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2017. _______________________ MAYOR – Stephen Molnar ___________________________ TOWN CLERK - Donna Wilson 150 Last revised July 10, 2017 By-Law to Schedule “A” to Amend By-Law 3876 Town of Tillsonburg Committees 2014 – 2018 Board/Committees Citizen Appointments Terms of Reference Composition Council Representatives Staff Liaison Accessibility Advisory Committee Mike Cerna Robert Doerr Margaret McCrimmon Michael Kadey Scot Richardson Peter Staley The mandate of the Accessibility Advisory Committee is to fulfill the duties of a Municipal Accessibility Advisory Committee, as outlined in the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act, 2005 and to provide advice to Council on programs, policies and services provided to persons with disabilities and seniors. 7 members 1 Staff 1 Councillor Councillor Stephenson Deputy Clerk Airport Advisory Committee Rick Lee Richard Van Maele Geoffrey Lee Euclid Benoit Andre Brisson Henry Atkinson Jeremy Stockmans John Prno Mel Getty Councillor Valerie Durston (South-West Oxford) To advise and assist the Town of Tillsonburg on matters pertaining to the Tillsonburg Regional Airport. The Airport Advisory Committee will provide a forum for receiving input and advice from aviation stakeholder groups and the community with respect to the Airport Master Plan, strategic initiatives and operational improvements. The Committee will also provide a forum for dialogue, communication and education. Councillor Rosehart Manager of Public Works Airport Administrator Councillor Stephenson 151 Last revised July 10, 2017 Town of Tillsonburg Committees 2014 – 2018 Board/Committees Citizen Appointments Terms of Reference Composition Council Representatives Staff Liaison Canada 150 Ad Hoc Committee Virginia Armstrong Wendy Cameron Mariana Carson Tabitha Dalm Josiane DeCloet Irene Hurley Heather Cnockaert Karen Smith Jami Stephenson Paul Weaver Aleksandra Webber 10 members 3 Staff 1 Councillor Clerk Culture & Heritage Manager Recreation Programs Supervisor Cultural Advisory Committee Erin Getty Josiane DeCloet Heather Benton Jami Stephenson Terry Fleming Vern Fleming To advise Council on matters, issues and policies pertaining to tourism, cultural events and festivals and to actively encourage partnerships. To develop and obtain Council endorsements of sub- committees when necessary to establish events such as Turtlefest, Airshows, Tillsonburg Christmas Festival, etc. To develop relationships for coordinating events with local service groups, BIA, Chamber of Commerce, Station Arts Centre and sports groups. 8 members 1 Staff 1 Councillor Councillor Stephenson Culture & Heritage Manager Development Committee Lisa Gilvesy Steve Spanjers Randy Thornton John Veldman Andrew Burns To advise and assist in the promotion of development within the Town. To develop alliances and partnerships to advance the Town’s strategic plan and to assist in the overall 9 members 1 BIA Rep 1 Chamber Rep 1 Real Estate Rep Councillor Hayes CAO Development Commissioner 152 Last revised July 10, 2017 Town of Tillsonburg Committees 2014 – 2018 Board/Committees Citizen Appointments Terms of Reference Composition Council Representatives Staff Liaison Paul DeCloet Ashton Nembhard Kirby Heckford Lindsay Morgan – Real Estate Rep Cedric Tomico - BIA Rep Jesse Goossens – Chamber Rep community growth within the Town. 2 Staff 1 Councillor Heritage, Beautification and Cemetery Committee Paul DeCloet Sue Saelens Marion Smith Robert Marsden Ken Butcher Charlie Baldwin Paul Wareing Christine Nagy Maurice Verhoeve Reg Butcher To advise and make recommendations to Council on all matters with respect to architectural and historical significance, beautification of public spaces, including trees, and Tillsonburg cemeteries. To advise Council of new and relevant legislation and funding initiatives; to make recommendations and assist with the development of education programs; and to liaise with the community and other organizations to promote Tillsonburg heritage, beautification and cemeteries. 9 members 1 Staff 1 Councillor Councillor Esseltine Facilities Manager Museum Advisory Committee Dianne MacKeigan Robert Marsden Mary Lou Sergeant Marianne Sandham Jami Stephenson Aleksandra Webber To research, collect, preserve, exhibit and promote the Tillsonburg Museum. To make recommendations to Council on policies and procedures pertaining to the museum. To work with the Tillsonburg Historical Society regarding trusts for restoration and artifact purchases. 6 members 1 staff 1 Councillor Councillor Rosehart Culture & Heritage Manager 153 Last revised July 10, 2017 Town of Tillsonburg Committees 2014 – 2018 Board/Committees Citizen Appointments Terms of Reference Composition Council Representatives Staff Liaison Parks and Recreation Advisory Committee Donna Scanlan Bob McCormick Donald Baxter Mike Cerna Mel Getty James Payne Paul DeCloet Susie Wray Craig Cole To advise Council and make recommendations on the programming and utilization of Parks, Trails, Green Space and Recreational facilities within Tillsonburg. To help implement the Community Parks, Recreation & Cultural Strategic Master Plan. To develop and obtain Council endorsements of sub-committees when necessary to deal with Trails, Tillsonburg Wall of Fame, etc. 12 members 2 staff 1 Councillor Councillor Rosehart Recreation Programs Services Manager Special Awards Committee John Armstrong Sam Lamb Matt Scholtz Mary Anne VanGeertruyde To advise Council and make recommendations on awards for volunteer service within the Town of Tillsonburg. The Volunteer Service Recognition Program shall recognize volunteers on a monthly basis when nominations are received by the Special Awards Committee. The Committee shall organize a Town of Tillsonburg volunteer recognition social event on a yearly basis with budget approval. Councillor Stephenson Town Clerk or Designate 154 Last revised July 10, 2017 Town of Tillsonburg Committees 2014 – 2018 Board/Committees Citizen Appointments Terms of Reference Composition Council Representatives Staff Liaison Town Hall Project Committee Andrew Gilvesy Rick Strouth John Veldman Jesse Goossens To advise Council on matters related to the Town Hall Project which may include, space needs, building location, joint use, etc. To advise and inform Council of budget needs based on building location, space needs, and furniture and equipment. To advise and develop working relationships with various stakeholders. To advise and assist with the development of a public engagement program and promote the activities of the Committee. Councillor Esseltine CAO Development Commissioner 155 THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF TILLSONBURG BY-LAW NUMBER 4148 BEING A BY-LAW to confirm the proceedings of Council at its meetings held on the 13th day of November, 2017 WHEREAS Section 5 (1) of the Municipal Act, 2001, as amended, provides that the powers of a municipal corporation shall be exercised by its council; AND WHEREAS Section 5 (3) of the Municipal Act, 2001, as amended, provides that municipal powers shall be exercised by by-law; AND WHEREAS it is deemed expedient that the proceedings of the Council of the Town of Tillsonburg at this meeting be confirmed and adopted by by-law; NOW THEREFORE THE MUNICIPAL COUNCIL OF THE CORPORATION OF THE TOWN OF TILLSONBURG ENACTS AS FOLLOWS: 1. All actions of the Council of The Corporation of the Town of Tillsonburg at its meeting held on November 13th 2017, with respect to every report, motion, by-law, or other action passed and taken by the Council, including the exercise of natural person powers, are hereby adopted, ratified and confirmed as if all such proceedings were expressly embodied in this or a separate by-law. 2. The Mayor and Clerk are authorized and directed to do all the things necessary to give effect to the action of the Council of The Corporation of the Town of Tillsonburg referred to in the preceding section. 3. The Mayor and the Clerk are authorized and directed to execute all documents necessary in that behalf and to affix thereto the seal of The Corporation of the Town of Tillsonburg. 4. This By-Law shall come into full force and effect on the day of passing. READ A FIRST AND SECOND TIME THIS 13th DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2017. READ A THIRD AND FINAL TIME AND PASSED THIS 13th DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2017. _____________________________ MAYOR – Stephen Molnar ______________________________ TOWN CLERK – Donna Wilson 156